RE: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-27 Thread Charles Brown
t: Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature I'll be interested in seeing what Soviet philosophical literature you have. I have tons of it myself, more in book than in journal form, though I probably have articles buried somewhere too. I know someone who wants to support a project to s

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-25 Thread Ralph Dumain
I'll be interested in seeing what Soviet philosophical literature you have. I have tons of it myself, more in book than in journal form, though I probably have articles buried somewhere too. I know someone who wants to support a project to scan it all, but I don't know anyone who has the time

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-25 Thread Steve Gabosch
OK, here is one reference I owe. This is a page from the web site of Keith Sawyer with lots of urls to papers he has written. His whole website is interesting. His papers on emergence are relevant to our current discussion on the topic. His paper entitled "Emergence in Psychology: Lessons f

Re: [marxistphilosophy] Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-24 Thread Ralph Dumain
She's a co-author of EINSTEIN A-Z. I saw both of them here in Washington, and both are foxes. The book itself seems to be primarily of value to those not already well versed in Einstein lore. At 09:33 PM 2/21/2005 -0500, Jim Farmelant wrote: Science writer, Karen C. Fox, has posted on her webs

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-24 Thread Steve Gabosch
I will track down those references I promised and give all these posts the careful read they deserve. Great stuff! But I gotta devote some serious attention to an overdue project for the next week or something like that. I'll be back ... ~ Steve

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-24 Thread Ralph Dumain
There's a treasure trove buried inside mountains of crap, but nevertheless there is a lot of important Soviet work, in the history of philosophy and philosophy of science. Even some of the more general programmatic works are important, because the Soviets had some basic orientations, which were

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-22 Thread Ralph Dumain
References: This is all there is on the subject: Graziano, E.E. "Hegel's Philosophy as Basis for the Dewey Classification Schedule", LIBRI, vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 45-52. Library science book, on integrative levels: Jolley, J. L. The Fabric of Knowledge: A Study of the Relations Between Ideas. Lond

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-22 Thread Ralph Dumain
At 09:05 PM 2/22/2005 -0800, Steve Gabosch wrote: Interesting comment on the Dewey Decimal System. Now I am curious about how it was invented and constructed, and how Hegelianism was part of that. The Library of Congress system also has a logic I haven't investigated but would like to understa

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-22 Thread Steve Gabosch
Charles wrote: Yes, this concept of levels of organization or integration really gets at emergence. For example, biology cannot be _reduced_ to chemistry. There are emergent or qualitatively new aspects to biology that cannot be explained by chemistry principles alone. Emergent levels of integrati

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-22 Thread Steve Gabosch
CB: Hello Steve, Seems to me emergence theory is very much the type of thing that Engels works on dialectics anticipates. No doubt the works of Soviet scientists and philosophers are a treasure trove of work in this area that is as yet only partly touched by Western Marxists. Hi, Charles. Yes, tr

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-22 Thread Steve Gabosch
Thanks for your response, Ralph. A little internet googling reveals that this concept had an interesting journey via library science in the 1950's - as a way of conceptualizing how reality is constructed - and was considered by some as a possible replacement to the Dewey Decimal system. Yes, I'

Re: [marxistphilosophy] Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-21 Thread Jim Farmelant
Science writer, Karen C. Fox, has posted on her website, a a paper that she wrote back in school on the issue of emergentism vs. reductionism in the philosophy of biology, "Does Biology Reduce to Physics? A Look at How the Question Has Been Answered Through Time." (http://www.karenceliafox.com/Sc

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-20 Thread Ralph Dumain
At 11:17 PM 2/19/2005 -0800, Steve Gabosch wrote: What wonderful descriptions of an obviously wonderful person. 35 is way, way to soon to go, what a tragedy. What was Lisa's full name? Does she have a representative piece of writing on the internet or otherwise published? Whether she does or

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-20 Thread Jim Farmelant
On Sat, 19 Feb 2005 23:17:11 -0800 Steve Gabosch <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> writes: > What wonderful descriptions of an obviously wonderful person. 35 is > way, > way to soon to go, what a tragedy. What was Lisa's full name? Does > she > have a representative piece of writing on the internet or o

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-20 Thread Steve Gabosch
What wonderful descriptions of an obviously wonderful person. 35 is way, way to soon to go, what a tragedy. What was Lisa's full name? Does she have a representative piece of writing on the internet or otherwise published? Whether she does or not, she is clearly being remembered here, and t

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-19 Thread Ralph Dumain
I made a comparable argument as part of a recent discussion in a local philosophy group. The topic was emergence. I made a pitch for Engels as a pioneer of this concept. Curiously, much of the literature on the subject--including encyclopedia articles--is heavily biased in citing its history

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-19 Thread Steve Gabosch
I took a peek at some of the posts on Engels and Dialectics of Nature. Sorry about the loss of Lisa, she was clearly a very able thinker and writer. Thank you, Ralph, for sharing your fond memory of her. My own take on dialectics fits very closely with Engels, along the lines George Novack ar

Re: [Marxism-Thaxis] Old Thread: Dialectics of Nature

2005-02-19 Thread Ralph Dumain
Reading this old thread of my late beloved Lisa brings back a lot of memories. I do not, remember, however, how this discussion proceeded from there. I do remember that it was an unfinished discussion, and that I had it in the back of my mind to engage Lisa once again attempting to divert her