M-TH: Re: Re: Smith and Cuckson on Lenin & philosophy

2000-07-08 Thread George Pennefather
G'day Hugh, I see Robert Service's new biography of Lenin is, whilst much more generous and sublte than, say, Pipes's hatchet job, also pretty damning of Lenin's philosophying. Reckons he was nothing special as a theorist. That said, when Lenin got to apply his book-learning to reality, reali

M-TH: Middle East settlement

2000-07-08 Thread George Pennefather
It is clear that since the collapse of the Soviet Union and the end of the Cold War the middle east is currently of no strategic interest to Washington and its imperialist subalterns. Consequently Washington is seeking to get the Middle East as a security problem out of the way by cobbling up a de

Re: M-TH: Smith and Cuckson on Lenin & philosophy

2000-07-08 Thread Rob Schaap
A good read, Hugh - and one I can't do justice on grounds of great dollops of ignorance and very few dollopettes of spare time. So I leave chunks of your argument out - point it out if I misrepresent you as a consequence. I've a few quibbles, anyway, natch. Just for clarity's sake, here's your t

Re: M-TH: Re: Re: Smith and Cuckson on Lenin & philosophy

2000-07-08 Thread Rob Schaap
G'day George, >Bob you mention Kautsky. Do you where any of his writings can be obtained >on >the internet. I am also interested in getting my hands on translations >of >Martov's writings too. No, mate. Seems the mainstream has forgotten Kautsky, and the left won't have a bar of him - so he app