Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-10 Thread MarshaV
Hi John, On May 9, 2011, at 1:20 PM, John Carl wrote: John: What do you mean, Marsha? Don't you think cause exists at least in our own heads? Marsha: As a skeptic it was because I didn't trust what went on in our heads that I came to this list. What do we know and how do we

Re: [MD] Why isn't the MOQ more popular

2011-05-10 Thread Ian Glendinning
Hi Alvaer, Steve's answer is the clue - fashion, 10 second attention spans, 15 minutes of fame, etc. It's a memetic problem. The ideas which spread are not the good ones, just the ones that are easiest to spread. And the ones that are easiest to spread are those than can be communicated in the

Re: [MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-10 Thread david buchanan
Arlo said: ...The key is seeing that these structures both enable the agency of the driver as well as constrain it. Our range of agency is not merely constrained by structure, the structure provides the opportunity for agency as well. ...So we are constrained by the road, but at the same time

Re: [MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-10 Thread Ian Glendinning
Mark asked John Missoula?  Where on God's Green Earth is that? You have read the book Mark, right ? Ian Moq_Discuss mailing list Listinfo, Unsubscribing etc. http://lists.moqtalk.org/listinfo.cgi/moq_discuss-moqtalk.org Archives: http://lists.moqtalk.org/pipermail/moq_discuss-moqtalk.org/

Re: [MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-10 Thread MarshaV
Hi Arlo, Would you please define 'agency' as you are using it so there is no quibbling about the term. Marsha On May 9, 2011, at 12:02 PM, Arlo Bensinger wrote: [Mark] Freedom is a rig full of gas, a wide open road, a stack of audio CDs, and some sweet rock and roll. Oh, yeah,

Re: [MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-10 Thread MarshaV
Hello again, I found this: The debate concerning the primacy of either structure or agency with regard to human behavior is a central ontological issue in sociology, political science, and the other social sciences. In this context, agency refers to the capacity of individuals to act

Re: [MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-10 Thread Arlo Bensinger
[Marsha] Would you please define 'agency' as you are using it so there is no quibbling about the term. [Arlo] Has there been quibbling? Broadly, agency refers to capacity to act, it is defined by range of possibility an actor has at any given point in time. I use the term because freedom and

Re: [MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-10 Thread Arlo Bensinger
[Marsha] Is this about an autonomous individual? [Arlo] No. In this paragraph the author is stating the extremes, or poles, of structure (determinism?) and agency (free will?). There have been other terms for these, but within structuration theories (such as Giddens, Archer, Parker and

Re: [MD] Free Will

2011-05-10 Thread craigerb
[Pirsig] To say that A causes B or to say that B values precondition A is to say the same thing. [Craig, previously] In precondition A (proximity of a magnet to iron filings) the iron filings value B (movement of the iron filings toward the magnet). [Steve] I knew you could figure it out.

Re: [MD] Keep on Truckin'

2011-05-10 Thread MarshaV
On May 10, 2011, at 12:21 PM, Arlo Bensinger wrote: [Marsha] Is this about an autonomous individual? [Arlo] No. In this paragraph the author is stating the extremes, or poles, of structure (determinism?) and agency (free will?). There have been other terms for these, but within

Re: [MD] How to experience Dynamic Quality

2011-05-10 Thread craigerb
[John] Social perfection: Celebrity [Tuukka] I strongly disagree that being a celebrity would be any form of social perfection. IMHO efficiency would be thought of as perfection. Craig Moq_Discuss mailing list Listinfo, Unsubscribing etc.

Re: [MD] How to experience Dynamic Quality

2011-05-10 Thread Leif Gunnar Alvær
[John said] Social perfection: Celebrity Wouldn't social perfection be a society that supports intellectual patterns? The same way as biological perfection would be an organsim that can support social value patterns? leif Moq_Discuss mailing list Listinfo, Unsubscribing etc.

Re: [MD] How to experience Dynamic Quality

2011-05-10 Thread craigerb
[leif] Wouldn't social perfection be a society that supports intellectual patterns? The same way as biological perfection would be an organsim that can support social value patterns? Then? Inorganic perfection: Carbon Biological perfection: Self-consciousness Social perfection: Freedom