Re: [MD] The Intellectual Level

2013-08-21 Thread MarshaV
Greetings, Pirsig uses the term ‘subject-object metaphysics’ (SOM) for any metaphysics (explicitly or implicitly) that perceives reality as either mind and/or matter such as idealism, materialism, and dualism. This recognition is not unique to Pirsig as, for instance, the Cambridge

Re: [MD] The Intellectual Level

2013-08-21 Thread Ian Glendinning
Hi DMB, Ian [had] replied: Agreed. Precisely ... dmb says: Dude, you've announced your agreement with one bland statement and totally ignored the rest. Why ask the question if you're just going to ignore the answer. Not ignoring, just proceeding carefully, progressively. You say

Re: [MD] The Intellectual Level

2013-08-21 Thread Joseph Maurer
Hi MarshaV and All, Do levels in existence describe reality DQ/SQ? The basis for reality in such an assumption would entail indefinable/definable reality in existence. Does that describe DQ/SQ? Is evolution nothing more than rhetoric? MOQ DQ/SQ proposes indefinable reality. How can I

Re: [MD] The Intellectual Level

2013-08-21 Thread david buchanan
Marsha said: Cannot help but wonder about the knower and the known, or the observer and the observed? Has this dualist perspective vanished into a cloud of pretty rhetorical terms such as elegance, consistency and coherence, and what of phrases like DQ chooses and SOM thinks? Very pretty

Re: [MD] The Intellectual Level

2013-08-21 Thread X Acto
Ian had said: To avoid the (unnecessary) mixing up, to avoid (unnecessarily) working the SOMism to death, let's disentangle any (low quality) narrow, GOF-SOMist-intellectual discourse from a wider (high quality, enlightened, extended) MoQ-ish-intellectual discourse - by expressing what more

Re: [MD] The Intellectual Level

2013-08-21 Thread X Acto
Ian:    without any visible agreements, actual positions get ignored, perceived positions get misquoted (as straw men) and thrown back as misleading positions in ad-hominem arguments. (Half a dozen examples in this thread alone.)   [Ron points out] Notice Ian, how you are making an appeal to

Re: [MD] The Intellectual Level

2013-08-21 Thread MarshaV
Dmb, Pirsig uses the term ‘subject-object metaphysics’ (SOM) for any metaphysics (explicitly or implicitly) that perceives reality as either mind and/or matter such as idealism, materialism, and dualism. This recognition is not unique to Pirsig as, for instance, the Cambridge Dictionary of