Re: [MD] Free Will-iam James

2011-06-29 Thread 118
Hi Marsha, If you read A Pluralistic Universe carefully, you will find that free will derives from pluralism, whereas determinism derives from monism. I cannot point to pages since I have the free kindle version. I am not sure if this answers your question. Cheers, Mark On Tue, Jun 28, 2011 at

Re: [MD] Free Will-iam James

2011-06-28 Thread MarshaV
Dmb, Does James's definition of free will conform to the the standard dictionary definition? If it does, why did we need all these quotes and explain it? Marsha On Jun 27, 2011, at 6:29 PM, david buchanan wrote: Charlene wrote: ...The pragmatic method includes directives for

Re: [MD] Free Will-iam James

2011-06-28 Thread MarshaV
Dmb, So while you chastise others for deviating from a standard english dictionary definition, even for example when I cited resources addressing an expanded Buddhist definition of reification, you offer in your discourse on free will what you (dmb) says that Charlene says that James says

Re: [MD] Free Will-iam James

2011-06-28 Thread david buchanan
Marsha asked dmb: Does James's definition of free will conform to the the standard dictionary definition? If it does, why did we need all these quotes and explain it? dmb says: Your question is predicated on a misconception. Dictionaries can only tell us if we're using words properly. They

Re: [MD] Free Will-iam James

2011-06-28 Thread MarshaV
On Jun 28, 2011, at 12:21 PM, david buchanan wrote: Marsha asked dmb: Does James's definition of free will conform to the the standard dictionary definition? If it does, why did we need all these quotes and explain it? dmb says: Your question is predicated on a misconception.

[MD] Free Will-iam James

2011-06-27 Thread david buchanan
For anyone who's genuinely interested in a Jamesian analysis of free will... ...The pragmatic method includes directives for validating a belief, whereas the principle of pure experience includes directives for formulating the belief in experiential terms...He [James] calls on the principle of

Re: [MD] Free Will-iam James

2011-06-27 Thread david buchanan
Charlene wrote: ...The pragmatic method includes directives for validating a belief, whereas the principle of pure experience includes directives for formulating the belief in experiential terms...He [James] calls on the principle of pure experience, for instance, to demonstrate that if