[mb-style] Re-recorded releases

2007-11-14 Thread Bogdan Butnaru
Hello! I'd like to draw your attention to http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=7814386 and the concerned releases: http://musicbrainz.org/release/e5f8f5dd-73cb-417e-aa88-a14f15619763.html is the original version of Stormblåst, while

Re: [mb-style] Re-recorded releases

2007-11-14 Thread Aaron Cooper
Sounds good. This is becoming more common as I've seen it in a few places. By the way, MMV = 2005 in roman numerals. Cheers! -Aaron On 14-Nov-07, at 6:06 AM, Bogdan Butnaru wrote: Hello! I'd like to draw your attention to http://musicbrainz.org/show/edit/?editid=7814386 and the

Re: [mb-style] Re-recorded releases

2007-11-14 Thread Bogdan Butnaru
On Nov 14, 2007 12:46 PM, Aaron Cooper [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Sounds good. This is becoming more common as I've seen it in a few places. By the way, MMV = 2005 in roman numerals. slaps-forehead/ duh... -- Bogdan Butnaru — [EMAIL PROTECTED] I think I am a fallen star, I should wish on

Re: [mb-style] Re-recorded releases

2007-11-14 Thread Mike Lerch
Johnny Cash did that several times in his career, too. Once it a while a Greatest Hits record would come out and while it would indeed have all his hits, it'd be new versions of all of them, not the Sun records versions or what have you. It's partly done as a way for artists/labels to get

Re: [mb-style] Re-recorded releases

2007-11-14 Thread Philipp Wolfer
a 'version' (at least how it is currently used) is the same as a re-recording, or live performance. Yes, but currently the is a version of AR does not exist for releases, only for tracks. I think Bogdan's approach of defining the existing ARs as subtypes of is a version of is the right thing to

Re: [mb-style] RFC: ReleaseTitle

2007-11-14 Thread Chris B
On 14/11/2007, Chad Wilson [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Kuno Woudt wrote: I'm not entirely certain about the order of (feat.) and (disc #), but can't think of any examples right now to which the style would apply. (so i wouldn't veto an RFV to make this ReleaseTitle as it currently exists

Re: [mb-style] Re-recorded releases

2007-11-14 Thread Chris B
On 14/11/2007, Philipp Wolfer [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: a 'version' (at least how it is currently used) is the same as a re-recording, or live performance. Yes, but currently the is a version of AR does not exist for releases, only for tracks. I think Bogdan's approach of defining the