Re: Contacts re email deliverability problem to tmomail.net?

2010-05-17 Thread Tim Franklin
That may be, but it would surprise me. The carriers still get paid by virtue of charging the recipients for the SMSes, and in this particular case cutting off this line of communication is leaving money on the table, as email-SMS deliverability is desired yet optional/secondary

Re: BT strike could affect internet and phone connections

2010-05-27 Thread Tim Franklin
Internet and phone connections across Britain could go into meltdown as BT workers threaten their first national strike for 23 years... ‘Many business and residential phonelines could go out of action, and if broadband crashes then thousands and thousands of people will find their internet

Re: Nato warns of strike against cyber attackers

2010-06-10 Thread Tim Franklin
I would expect that the increased awareness of network security that resulted would pay dividends in business and home use of networks. I'd expect a lot of nice business for audit firms with the right government connections, and another checklist with a magic acronym that has everything to do

Re: Nato warns of strike against cyber attackers

2010-06-10 Thread Tim Franklin
Checklists come in handy in fact if many were followed (BCP checklists, appropriate industry standard fw, system rules) the net would be a cleaner place. Sensible checklists that actually improve matters, yes. The audit checklists I've often been subjected to, full of security theatre and

Re: Addressing plan exercise for our IPv6 course

2010-07-29 Thread Tim Franklin
I look at this as water under the bridge. Yep, it was complicated code and now it works. I can run bittorrent just fine beyond an Apple wireless router and I did nothing to make that work. Micro-torrent just communicates with the router to make the port available. So, the security model here

Re: Addressing plan exercise for our IPv6 course

2010-07-29 Thread Tim Franklin
Why waste valuable people's time to conserve nearly valueless renewable resources? See my earlier comments on upsell and control. While you have some ISPs starting from the mentality that gives us accepting incoming connections is a chargeable extra, they're also going to be convinced that

Re: Addressing plan exercise for our IPv6 course

2010-07-29 Thread Tim Franklin
Owen DeLong wrote: If you want to build a business based on upsell and control by trying to convince users that they should give you extra money to provision a resource that costs you virtually nothing, then more power to you. However, I think this will, in the end, be as popular as

Re: Addressing plan exercise for our IPv6 course

2010-07-29 Thread Tim Franklin
Jeroen Massar wrote: See my earlier comments on upsell and control. While you have some ISPs starting from the mentality that gives us accepting incoming connections is a chargeable extra, they're also going to be convinced that there's a revenue opportunity in segmenting customers who want

Re: RIP Justification

2010-09-30 Thread Tim Franklin
I think BGP is better for that job, ultimately because it was specifically designed for that job, but also because it's now available in commodity routers for commodity prices e.g. Cisco 800 series. +1 - for me, if I need a dynamic routing protocol between trust / administrative domains,

Re: RIP Justification

2010-10-01 Thread Tim Franklin
Now, when traffic comes from head office destined for a site prefix, it hits the provider gear. That provider gear will need routing information to head to a particular site. If you wanted to use statics, you will need to fill out a form each time you add/remove a prefix for a site and the

Re: RIP Justification

2010-10-01 Thread Tim Franklin
- Ruben Guerra ruben.gue...@arrisi.com wrote: Using BGP would be overkill for most. Many small commercial customers to not want the complexity of BGP This one keeps coming up. Leaf-node BGP config is utterly trivial, and is much easier for the SP to configure the necessary safety devices

Re: New hijacking - Done via via good old-fashioned Identity Theft

2010-10-07 Thread Tim Franklin
If i have to wait for 20 minutes for an email, i've started skype already.. You know what, why don't we simply turn the smtp servers -off- and use skype and msn for everything... saves electricity :P By that argument, why don't we turn off the Internet and use SMS for everything? It may be

Re: Failover IPv6 with multiple PA prefixes (Was: IPv6 fc00::/7 - Unique local addresses)

2010-11-01 Thread Tim Franklin
This isn't to do with anything low level like RAs. This is about people proposing every IPv6 end-site gets PI i.e. a default free zone with multiple billions of routes instead of using ULAs for internal, stable addressing. It's as though they're not aware that the majority of end-sites on the

Re: Failover IPv6 with multiple PA prefixes (Was: IPv6 fc00::/7 - Unique local addresses)

2010-11-02 Thread Tim Franklin
About the only hack I can see that *might* make sense would be that home CPE does NOT honour the upstream lifetimes if upstream connectivity is lost, but instead keeps the prefix alive on very short lifetimes until upstream connectivity returns. Yep, that's the hack I was getting at. As a

Re: Some truth about Comcast - WikiLeaks style

2010-12-21 Thread Tim Franklin
- Owen DeLong o...@delong.com wrote: Personally, I think that enforced UNE is the right model. If you sell higher level services, you should not be allowed to operate the physical plant. The physical plant operating companies should sell access to the physical plant to higher level

Re: Some truth about Comcast - WikiLeaks style

2010-12-21 Thread Tim Franklin
- Owen DeLong o...@delong.com wrote: Yeah... I'd rather see it done in such a way that there is a prohibition of common ownership or management. Essentially, require that the stock be split and each current owner receives one share in each company with any shareholders who own more than

Re: PPPOE vs DHCP

2011-01-26 Thread Tim Franklin
Terminating PPPoE generally isn't much different than terminating VLANs. In Juniper world, it requires the right equipment. Cisco world, it's not generally a big deal. Unless, for example, you already sunk a chunk of change into Cisco 10Ks, and now want IPv6 on your PPPoE. Not that I'm

Re: Using IPv6 with prefixes shorter than a /64 on a LAN

2011-02-01 Thread Tim Franklin
I think ULA is still useful for home networks. If the home router guys properly generate the ULA dynamically, it should stop conflicts within home networking. There's something to be said for internal services which ULA can be useful for, even when you do fall off the net. I really,

Re: quietly....

2011-02-02 Thread Tim Franklin
So, when I take my laptop from Home to work, to the airport, to some random cyber cafe I should have to manually alter my DNS servers assuming I can find someone in the location who can tell me what they are ?? Or let me guess, I should hardcode some public DNS servers which I can

Re: What vexes VoIP users?

2011-03-01 Thread Tim Franklin
I do not live over there, I have never seen a Vonage or Magic jack or any other VoIP service ad on TV in the UK, ever. Vonage *are* advertising on UK TV. Hardly the carpet-bombing the OP suggests is the case in the US, but they are doing something. It is quite a different market here. I

Re: IP tunnel MTU

2012-10-30 Thread Tim Franklin
Certainly fixing all the buggy host stacks, firewall and compliance devices to realize that ICMP isn't bad won't be hard. Wait till you get started on fixing the security consultants. Ack. I've yet to come across a *device* that doesn't deal properly with packet too big. Lots (and lots

Re: Gmail and SSL

2012-12-14 Thread Tim Franklin
http://www.startssl.com/ Their certs are free and, from what I hear, are accepted by Google. Seconded. I was a hold-out for a long time on personal stuff - I trust me, I'm not paying someone else to trust me - but StartSSL makes a lot of the pain go away with minimal effort. Regards, Tim.

Re: DNS ed.gov translations

2009-06-01 Thread Tim Franklin
ROTFL what an honour ;-), as we are in to weekend mood anyway I share the reason for this. When I joined Colt my signature did look like this: --- ___ ___ ___ ___ Ralf Weber t: +49 (0)69 56606 2780 \C/ \O/ \L/ \T/ System Administrator V V V VCOLT Telecom GmbH

Re: ServerBeach Name Server Outage?

2009-08-10 Thread Tim Franklin
Is anyone else that uses ServerBeach hosting having issues with their name servers (ns[12].geodns.net) failing to resolve their hostnames? I haven't seen any recent problems, although I have the geodns servers slaving from my server. Are you doing the same, or generating DNS directly on their

Re: Does Internet Speed Vary by Season?

2009-10-07 Thread Tim Franklin
I read the article and the follow up posts and I wonder if we are all using the same definition for speed here. The article seems to imply you don't get 6 Mbps on your DSL line in summer because the copper is hotter and it's harder to push electrons down the link. That is clearly BS,

Re: Performance Issues - PTR Records

2011-11-04 Thread Tim Franklin
It's already been pointed out that lame delegations are more likely problems for many. But the we'll just pre-fill in-addr to avoid problems isn't going to work for ip6.arpa. If anyone has enough hardware to serve the zone for a /48 (64k * 4bil * 4bil * bytes-in-record), I'd love to see it.

Re: Dynamic (changing) IPv6 prefix delegation

2011-11-22 Thread Tim Franklin
3) If you write an application using anything other than UDP or TCP, it won't work on most networks (with some minor exceptions for PPTP and IPSEC, which work sometimes). This hasn't been my experience unless you're behind some form of NAT. Yes, it is well known that NAT breaks most

Re: AD and enforced password policies

2012-01-03 Thread Tim Franklin
There is indeed a difference between Europe (or is it only .SE?) and USA here; no bank in Sweden lets you login without at least a client certificate and password/pin code. Most banks have a hardware token, either challenge-response or HOTP/TOTP; some use the chip in chip-and-pin cards as

Re: enterprise 802.11

2012-01-16 Thread Tim Franklin
As for the iOS problem, read on here: http://www.net.princeton.edu/apple-ios/ios41-allows-lease-to-expire-keeps-using-IP-address.html That's the iOS issue - out of curiosity, what's the Mac issue? Regards, Tim.

Re: Common operational misconceptions

2012-02-16 Thread Tim Franklin
When I took an A level computing course in the 90s the course material still talked about primary stor and backing stor, batch jobs and the like... I was working with a lot of batch jobs in my first development role in 1993, and still supporting overnight scheduling to make best use of the

Re: dns and software, was Re: Reliable Cloud host ?

2012-03-01 Thread Tim Franklin
GAI/GNI do not return TTL values, but this should not be a problem. If they were to return anything, it should not be a TTL, but a time() value, after which the result may no longer be used. One way to achieve that would be for GAI to return an opaque structure that contained the IP and

Re: Huawei edge routers..

2012-03-07 Thread Tim Franklin
On the other hand, if you hop into other people's Huawei routers via CLI you will curse and scream. As close as I could tell, it handles most functionality of IOS, but they tried to find a synonym for every word cisco used in the cli. This does occasionally brighten up my day with gems like

Re: Shim6, was: Re: filtering /48 is going to be necessary

2012-03-15 Thread Tim Franklin
I don't think the term means what Masataka thinks it means, because nobody in this discussion is talking in terms of circuits rather than packet routing. Geographical addressing can tend towards bellhead thinking, in the sense that it assumes a small number (one?) of suppliers servicing all

Re: Quad-A records in Network Solutions ?

2012-03-29 Thread Tim Franklin
Not to sound like I am trolling here, but how hard is it get VPS servers or some EC2 servers and setup your own DNS servers. Are there use cases where that is not practical? Aren't we talking about NetSol as a *registrar* and inserting quad-A glue? Or did I miss the original intention?

Re: IPv6 /64 links (was Re: ipv6 book recommendations?)

2012-06-25 Thread Tim Franklin
Even though it may be easy to make end systems and local LANs v6 capable, rest, the center part, of the Internet keep causing problems. Really? My impression is that it's very much the edge that's hard - CE routers, and in particular cheap, nasty, residential DSL and cable CE routers. Lots

Re: IPv6 /64 links (was Re: ipv6 book recommendations?)

2012-06-25 Thread Tim Franklin
The only solution is, IMO, to let multihomed sites have multiple prefixes inherited from their upper ISPs, still keeping the sites' ability to control loads between incoming multiple links. And for the basement multi-homers, RA / SLAAC makes this much easier to do with v6. The larger-scale

Re:

2012-08-23 Thread Tim Franklin
Does anyone have a very lightly used, long long low bandwidth link they can dedicate to The Cause? Dummynet. One cheap PC, two NICs, roll your own, as long as you like. I've had fake circuits running with 2s RTT, applications keep doing their thing, just very slowly. Regards, Tim.

Re: Big Temporary Networks

2012-09-13 Thread Tim Franklin
You'll need a beefy NAT box. Linux with Xeon CPU and 4GB RAM minimum. Or not. The CCC presentation is showing *real* Internet for everyone, unless I'm very much mistaken... Regards, Tim.

Re: The Department of Work and Pensions, UK has an entire /8

2012-09-19 Thread Tim Franklin
So...why do you need publicly routable IP addresses if they aren't publicly routable? Because the RIRs aren't in the business of handing out publicly routable address space. They're in the business of handing out globally unique address space - *one* of the reasons for which may be

Re: guys != gender neutral

2012-09-28 Thread Tim Franklin
Given the lack of truly neutral terms in english, I have taken to alternative my pronouns interchangably when I write. Folks? I really do mean folks when I write guys, but I do understand why it can come across as exclusionary, and I try to force myself into the habit of folks. It sounds a

Re: Anyone notice strange announcements for 174.128.31.0/24

2009-01-14 Thread Tim Franklin
On Tue, January 13, 2009 8:57 pm, Joe Abley wrote: The fact that I choose to stick 701 in an AS_PATH attribute on a prefix I advertise in order to stop that prefix from propagating into 701 is entirely my own business, and it's a practice which, although apparently not commonplace, has been a

Re: Creating demand for IPv6, and saving the planet

2007-10-04 Thread Tim Franklin
On Thu, October 4, 2007 6:49 am, Mike Leber wrote: As the data at http://bgp.he.net/ipv6-progress-report.cgi shows for the IPv6 and IPv4 nameserver tests, some of the time IPv6 connectivity is *faster* than IPv4 connectivity (66 out of 264 test cases), because of network topology differences

Re: InterCage, Inc. (NOT Atrivo)

2008-09-11 Thread Tim Franklin
On Thu, September 11, 2008 10:58 am, Eugeniu Patrascu wrote: Why should an ISP provide proof of the good behavior of their clients ? Or in your conuntry you're considered guilty until proven otherwise ? Conversely, and sticking close to the 'clean house' metaphor, if someone has a history of

Re: T1 aggregation and data center gateways

2010-03-10 Thread Tim Franklin
Isn't that just CYA? Thank the lawyers and corporate compliance offices and professional whiners. The obvious answer is that if your corporate email policy makes you look like an idiot, post to mailing lists from a personal email address that doesn't make you look like an idiot. This

Re: As the NANOG Community Moves to IPv6...

2010-04-06 Thread Tim Franklin
P.S. Does anyone else think that perhaps ipv3.com == Guillaume FORTAINE? It's spewing semi-coherent proposals for unworkable alternative addressing schemes. Sounds more like Jim Fleming to me. Perhaps we start comparing IPv3 to IPv8 and see if we get a reaction? ;) Regards, Tim.

Re: what about 48 bits?

2010-04-07 Thread Tim Franklin
This reminds of me of the failure-mode-within-a-failure-mode of 10b2 with vaxstation2000's using vms's vaxcluster software. Unplugging the 10b2 gave you a window of about 10 seconds before one by one every vaxstation2000 would bugcheck. I was always rather astonished that nobody at DEC either

Re: Router for Metro Ethernet

2010-04-14 Thread Tim Franklin
Some caveats: 1. only the ME version supports MPLS, in case you want to overlay an MPLS TE/VPN network on a Metro Ethernet Forum (MEF) ELAN raw Ethernet service. 2. If you are using IP multicast, make sure that the Metro Ethernet provider supports PIM snooping, otherwise (S,G) directed

Re: Router for Metro Ethernet

2010-04-14 Thread Tim Franklin
All of those numbers are straight forwarding with nothing turned on and 64 byte packets. That way you get a nice idea of what the CPU can do. They're also, as ever, unidirectional, so you can immediately halve them if your question is what size pipe can I connect this device to? As a VPN

Re: Connectivity to an IPv6-only site

2010-04-23 Thread Tim Franklin
Which seems a bit far afield from reality to me. Yes, there are lots of folks with IPv6 connectivity and v4-only recursive DNS servers. I don't think ISPs will have problems setting aside a handful of IPv4 addresses for authoritative DNS infrastructure to work around this until v6 transport

Re: Bubba is a 75 year old woman looking to make some extra cash

2011-04-08 Thread Tim Franklin
I guess we have another gem for DeLongFacts.com (in the vein of SchneierFacts.com): He is one of the few natural enemies of the Babushka. Did anyone else suddenly have flashbacks to the VMS Wombat?

Re: How do you put a TV station on the Mbone?

2011-05-04 Thread Tim Franklin
I think that George's POV -- which is also mine -- is that as the world shifts, the percentage of video distribution which is amenable to multicast, and not well served by unicast, is likely to grow, and it would be a Good Idea to be ready for that situation already when it arrives. Really?

Re: Hotmail?

2011-06-08 Thread Tim Franklin
Let me just step in here and say.. it's tough to build onto Zimbra. At work, we support ~1000 users on Zimbra (network edition), with hundreds of thousands of messages flowing through daily, and it doesn't like you tinkering with stuff under the hood. Most of your customizations get blown

Re: The stupidity of trying to fix DHCPv6

2011-06-10 Thread Tim Franklin
Standing back a little, I can see an argument that IPv6 would be an easier 'sell' if there were two modes of operation, one with only RAs, and one with only DHCPv6. This +1. There are plenty of enterprises, employing actual network engineers (allegedly), who are just about getting to grips

Re: NANOG List Update - Moving Forward

2011-07-12 Thread Tim Franklin
Thankfully, the current test has been a success. Including stopping non-members from posting to the list, and other anti-spam? I've got a sudden influx this morning of spam addressed to nanog@nanog.org :( Regards, Tim.

Re: NANOG List Update - Moving Forward

2011-07-12 Thread Tim Franklin
- Original Message - The new posts do not have list (un)subscribe information in the headers. Also, a statement would be nice as to what header definitely *will* be in place that we can filter on. At the moment, I'm assuming 'List-ID', but I'm not sure if that header or its

Re: best practices for management nets in IPv6

2011-07-18 Thread Tim Franklin
You can also use IPv6 privacy extensions (by default on Windows 7), see rfc4941. For Linux, you can also enable it, which is not a default. In the context of addresses I'm using to manage kit, having devices randomly renumber themselves at regular intervals does *not* sound like it's going to

Re: IPv6 end user addressing

2011-08-09 Thread Tim Franklin
Silly confidentiality notices are usually enforced by silly corporate IT departments and cannot be removed by mere mortal employees. They are an unavoidable part of life, like Outlook top posting and spam. Alternatively, if your corporate email imposes stupid policies and / or a stupid email

Re: Reverse DNS RFCs and Recommendations

2013-10-30 Thread Tim Franklin
I've never seen anyone put in rDNS for networks or broadcast addresses. I've done this a fair bit, on both a personal and professional basis. I find it quite helpful when I forget what the subnet masks are (or fail to apply them properly) and try and Do Something with an address that can't be

Re: [nznog] Web Servers: Dual-homing or DNAT/Port Forwarding?

2013-12-11 Thread Tim Franklin
Just because something is public doesn¹t mean you have to accept ALL traffic, it just means you have to anticipate any potential problems based on Larry knowing your address rather than imagining him standing at the front gate of your gated community. ;) (let¹s torture that analogy!) There's

Re: misunderstanding scale

2014-03-24 Thread Tim Franklin
Additional support on my feeling of DO and IPv6, is DO's stance of directly not even allowing IPv6 tunnels to HE, SiXXs, or any of the other providers by specifically teliing them not to allow connections from your IPv4 address space. Say *what*? I've got HE tunnels into DO, purely because

Re: Linux: concerns over systemd adoption and Debian's decision to switch [OT]

2014-10-24 Thread Tim Franklin
All those init.d scripts do about 95% the same thing, all hacked together in shell. Most of them are probably just slightly edited versions of some few paleo-scripts. Set the location of the pid file, set the path of the executable, set the command line flags/options, maybe change some

Re: Recommended wireless AP for 400 users office

2015-02-02 Thread Tim Franklin
That's it. Step 1, buy the equipment at full price. Step 2, pay for the cloud management license, yearly. Step 3, no extended warranty option, so pay full price if equipment from step one fails. As long as you're doing step 2 (which you *have* to, otherwise it's a brick), isn't step 3 report

Re: HTTPS redirects to HTTP for monitoring

2015-01-20 Thread Tim Franklin
By the way, I hope that all of the people who have been ranting about this have read this note. The only way this filtering works is if the client computers have a special CA cert installed into their browsers. That means it's a private organizational network that manages all its client

Re: Verizon Policy Statement on Net Neutrality

2015-03-03 Thread Tim Franklin
I meant that on the Internet as a whole it is unusual for such speeds to actually be realized in practice due to various issues. 8-10Mb/s seems to be what one can expect without going to distributed protocols. Really? I have 2 x VDSL (40/10) to my house, running MLPPP. I can get a

Re: Alcatel-Lucent 7750 Service Router (SR)

2015-05-07 Thread Tim Franklin
I am worried as most tech's know Cisco and Juniper, so going to ALU would be a learning curve based on replies I am getting off list. It's definitely quite different from the CLI. I'm still dabbling, but the guys here who have been through the training and are immersed in it really like it.

Re: Alcatel-Lucent 7750 Service Router (SR)

2015-05-07 Thread Tim Franklin
It really bothers me to see that people in this industry are so worried about a change of syntax or terminology. If there's one thing about the big vendors that bothers me, it's that these batteries of vendor specific tests have allowed many techs to get lazy. They simply can't seem to operate

Re: Fixing Google geolocation screwups

2015-04-08 Thread Tim Franklin
That all said: Restricting content based on location is complete and utter nonsense in 2015. The world is global, people want to pay for content and the content owners just don't allow people to pay for it. Globalisation is for your corporate lords and masters to buy labour and raw materials

Re: Residential VSAT experiences?

2015-06-23 Thread Tim Franklin
Interesting that you say that about sip. We had a client that would use it for sip on ships all the time. It wasn't the best but it worked. Ping times were between 500-700ms. It really depends on your expectations - or more to the point, your end-users' expectations. I've tested SIP in the

Re: Dual stack IPv6 for IPv4 depletion

2015-07-10 Thread Tim Franklin
And I’m saying you’re ignoring an important part of reality. Whatever ISPs default to deploying now will become the standard to which application developers develop. Changing the ISP later is easy. I'm not even convinced of that. Once /56 (or *any* value) is baked into the processes,

Re: maximum ipv4 bgp prefix length of /24 ?

2023-10-02 Thread Tim Franklin
On 02/10/2023 19:24, Matthew Petach wrote: The problem with this approach is you now have non-deterministic routing. Depending on the state of FIB compression, packets *may* flow out interfaces that are not what the RIB thinks they will be. This can be a good recipe for routing micro-loops