Re: [netmod] Y34 - root node

2015-08-25 Thread Kent Watsen
I like the idea of relocatable modules. It is almost to say everything defined by the IETF should be a grouping, allowing others to assemble the pieces as they see fit. I do not think it makes sense for IETF to define an uber structure, especially using a language mandating forever backwards

Re: [netmod] Y26 again, sorry

2015-08-25 Thread Martin Bjorklund
Ladislav Lhotka lho...@nic.cz wrote: On 25 Aug 2015, at 14:48, Martin Bjorklund m...@tail-f.com wrote: Ladislav Lhotka lho...@nic.cz wrote: On 25 Aug 2015, at 14:01, Martin Bjorklund m...@tail-f.com wrote: Hi, I think this could work (thanks Robert; maybe this is what you

Re: [netmod] Y26 again, sorry

2015-08-25 Thread Martin Bjorklund
Hi, I think this could work (thanks Robert; maybe this is what you meant!): container zones { list zone { ... list rrset { ... leaf type { type identityref { ... } } list rdata { key id; ... choice

Re: [netmod] LL review of 6020bis-06

2015-08-25 Thread Martin Bjorklund
Hi Lada, Thank you for this extensive review! Comments inline. Ladislav Lhotka lho...@nic.cz wrote: Hi, this time I reviewed the complete text so my comments aren't limited to YANG 1.1 stuff. Lada General comments 1. Would it make sense to at least mention that YANG is

Re: [netmod] Y26 again, sorry

2015-08-25 Thread Ladislav Lhotka
Randy Presuhn randy_pres...@mindspring.com writes: Hi - From: Ladislav Lhotka lho...@nic.cz Sent: Aug 24, 2015 11:44 AM To: Andy Bierman a...@yumaworks.com Cc: netmod@ietf.org netmod@ietf.org Subject: Re: [netmod] Y26 again, sorry ... YANG does not provide any mechanism to REQUIRE modules A

Re: [netmod] issue and question: YANG short-case-stmt in augment-stmt or uses-augment-stmt

2015-08-25 Thread Ladislav Lhotka
Hi Martin, as far as I can tell, these groupings are OK, and pyang also doesn't complain. Ahoj, Láďa Martin Ciglan -X (mciglan - PANTHEON TECHNOLOGIES at Cisco) mcig...@cisco.com writes: Hello I've come across a yang module which defines a short-case-stmt in augment-stmt or

Re: [netmod] Y34 - root node

2015-08-25 Thread Eric Voit (evoit)
From: Andy Bierman, Friday, August 21, 2015 10:28 AM snip Currently we have a proprietary way of relocating YANG modules, and ODL has its mount, and I think Andy has some other mechanism.  Maybe the time has come to standardize how mount works, and maybe then also standardize the list of

[netmod] issue and question: YANG short-case-stmt in augment-stmt or uses-augment-stmt

2015-08-25 Thread Martin Ciglan -X (mciglan - PANTHEON TECHNOLOGIES at Cisco)
Hello I've come across a yang module which defines a short-case-stmt in augment-stmt or uses-augment-stmt Something like this: grouping grp1 { uses grp2 { augment mychoice { leaf myleaf1 { type string; } } } } grouping grp2 {

Re: [netmod] Y26 again, sorry

2015-08-25 Thread Ladislav Lhotka
On 25 Aug 2015, at 14:48, Martin Bjorklund m...@tail-f.com wrote: Ladislav Lhotka lho...@nic.cz wrote: On 25 Aug 2015, at 14:01, Martin Bjorklund m...@tail-f.com wrote: Hi, I think this could work (thanks Robert; maybe this is what you meant!): container zones { list zone {

Re: [netmod] Y26 again, sorry

2015-08-25 Thread Ladislav Lhotka
On 25 Aug 2015, at 14:01, Martin Bjorklund m...@tail-f.com wrote: Hi, I think this could work (thanks Robert; maybe this is what you meant!): container zones { list zone { ... list rrset { ... leaf type { type identityref { ... } }

Re: [netmod] Y26 again, sorry

2015-08-25 Thread Martin Bjorklund
Ladislav Lhotka lho...@nic.cz wrote: On 25 Aug 2015, at 14:01, Martin Bjorklund m...@tail-f.com wrote: Hi, I think this could work (thanks Robert; maybe this is what you meant!): container zones { list zone { ... list rrset { ... leaf type