Identity and difference

2018-11-01 Thread Alexander Bard
Dear Justin Was Karl Marx an idealist or a materialist? I'm perfectly happy to leave that for you and others to decide. Because I'm a pragmatist and my ideas are pragmatist and the rest is just wordplay to me. I'm interested in factual truth and in whether something works or does not work. I'm

Re: Grand narratives vs Identitarianism

2018-11-01 Thread jan hendrik brueggemeier
Dear nettime list - a little late to the party (and it seems the conversation has already moved on …) i do like to pose some observations/ questions that this thread has triggered for me — although i must admit that i have not read marx (nor rosseau) myself. that’s probably me just being lazy as

Re: Identity and difference

2018-11-01 Thread Justin Charles
Coming in late to this thread but the anti-identity current that's growing more and more prevalent on the left lately seems to be somewhat in opposition to contrary to materialism. To say that "class is class and only class has universal validity" strikes me as pretty idealist, not materialist.

Re: Interview with Richard Stallman in New Left Review (September-October 2018)

2018-11-01 Thread Carsten Agger
On 11/1/18 10:56 AM, mp wrote: James Scott writes about peasant uprising that one of the first points of attacks commonly are the offices of documentation/paper holding bureaucracies: there where power is preserved and managed. That, today, would be server farms, I suppose. So, should we

Re: Interview with Richard Stallman in New Left Review (September-October 2018)

2018-11-01 Thread K E N O
Don’t we have to think about more sustainable ways to produce hardware? There’s – of course – Heidegger viewing technology as the destruction of nature. Even if we wanted, could we stop using and producing hardware? I think it’s hard to condemn free software because of *evil* hardware. We

Re: Interview with Richard Stallman in New Left Review (September-October 2018)

2018-11-01 Thread Emery Hemingway
On Wednesday, October 31, 2018 4:43:20 PM CET, Francis Hunger wrote: Hi everybody, I was a bit disappointed, that this kind of 'weak' Stallman interview was published in the New Left Review. 'Weak' insofar as I can't see much 'leftist' in it. Free Software is barely a political concept as it

Re: Interview with Richard Stallman in New Left Review (September-October 2018)

2018-11-01 Thread mp
On 01/11/2018 08:00, Carsten Agger wrote: > So yes: Software should be available free of charge - and, on the other > hand, those who can should take part in its funding, because with no > funding it won't happen. Software can only be used if you have access to hardware. Hardware can - at

Re: Interview with Richard Stallman in New Left Review (September-October 2018)

2018-11-01 Thread Carsten Agger
On 11/1/18 7:02 AM, Brian Holmes wrote: On Tue, Oct 30, 2018 at 5:17 PM Frederick Noronha mailto:fredericknoro...@gmail.com>> wrote: The 'freedom to afford software' should be actually included as the Fifth Freedom of the Free Software Campaign worldwide. As things stand, the

Re: Interview with Richard Stallman in New Left Review (September-October 2018)

2018-11-01 Thread Brian Holmes
On Tue, Oct 30, 2018 at 5:17 PM Frederick Noronha < fredericknoro...@gmail.com> wrote: > The 'freedom to afford software' should be actually included as the Fifth > Freedom of the Free Software Campaign worldwide. As things stand, the > outrageous pricing of software (notwithstanding the FOSS