Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 2021-01-18 13:42, Felix Stalder wrote: So, what exactly is the lesson that China holds for "us", that is, cultural/knowledge workers While these questions hold promise, it feels to me like the precondition is that cultural/knowledge workers in the west stop carrying water for US

Re: nettime-l Digest, Vol 160, Issue 35

2021-01-18 Thread Anthony Stephenson
> Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy Some people have said that January 6 turned out to be, for many of the participants, little more than a photo op. In 1998, Paul Virilio said “the great ‘danger to the system’ is no longer that of the bankruptcy of companies or banks in a chain reaction, such

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Iain Boal
Nettimers, I’ve no idea of the identity of the sinomane telecommunist (‘Kleiner') defiling this conversation, or their whereabouts, or their condition (though the aggressive logorrhoea is suggestive). However, to call Brian’s profound - and profoundly open, generous, and dialogical -

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
Notes: - I'm an unknown, illegitimate, defiler with a mania for china. - Brian is a profound ubermench whose invoking of stalin and hungary where totally relevant. - The mods should intervene to silence me. Just a coincidence that none of these folks, supposedly interested in dialogical

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Roman Seidl
For some time it was kind of entertaining to read something which seems totally out of time, like from the 1980s. It seems like it's going to go on like this for ever. We are all going to get insulted until "strategic ‘intervention' from our moderators" takes place. I stopped reading it but

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread John Young
"iterate forward" is promisingly constructive action. Not so much name-callingly destructive "sinomane telecommunist." Demanding moderators to regulate is hardly insightful, more inciteful, downright spiteful. My cognita wistful at paralyzing ad homina. So say, this forum must not suppress

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Felix Stalder
On 16.01.21 17:40, Dmytri Kleiner wrote: > You can't do "a China" in your country. You can, however, work to > improve the conditions of people in your country, while working against > the aggression of your country abroad. Yes, obviously we cannot, and should not, "do" China. In the same way

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Geoffrey Goodell
Dear Iain, I'm not sure whether it adds anything to the discussion, but I've experienced this before. I am on a mailing list for alumni of a particular house at my undergraduate university. One particular contributor to this list has unleashed (and continues to do so) an unending stream of

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread John Young
Indeed, The horrors of Joseph Conrad: The Gentleperson's Guide To Forum Spies https://cryptome.org/2012/07/gent-forum-spies.htm Techniques for dilution, misdirection and control of a internet forum. Twenty-Five Rules of Disinformation Eight Traits of the Disinformationalist Saboteurs

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 2021-01-18 19:11, John Young wrote: "iterate forward" is promisingly constructive action. "Discover the truth through practice, and again through practice verify and develop the truth. Start from perceptual knowledge and actively develop it into rational knowledge; then start from

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread John Young
Well said. Concur. Agree. Whew. Where is Ted? At 02:26 PM 1/18/2021, you wrote: Geoffrey Goodell wrote: "So, I must ask: Is it possible that our pseudonymous contributor is deliberately seeking to exploit our respect for anonymous speech as a way to undermine our forum?" I've met Dmitry, he

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread voyd
Hi, everyone -  Watching this curiously as I re-acclimate to being back in the United States after 5 years based in the UAE, but engaged in thinking across the Caucusus, Turkey, Armenia/Azerbaijan, the I-place, and the Central Asian -Stans, and a tiny bit of China. Being that I

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Brian Holmes
Geoffrey Goodell wrote: "So, I must ask: Is it possible that our pseudonymous contributor is deliberately seeking to exploit our respect for anonymous speech as a way to undermine our forum?" I've met Dmitry, he is an actual person, well known in Berlin, involved in practices relevant to this

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Andreas Broeckmann
folks, i know that there are peace negotiations under way among left intellectuals and activists on this list; i hope they will be fruitful. i find it unbearable though to see untenable claims of "mccarthyism" made against somebody who just stays in an argument, when anybody in his right

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Roman Seidl
All right, but which one? The CPC? I thought I have to be a migrant worker in China to really understand the true emancipatory nature of the CPC. Else I can neither criticise them nor follow them. Because ignoring China is not an option either. We are all lost. So it all ends up in a double

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 2021-01-18 20:26, Brian Holmes wrote: Why don't we all just cool out? I am glad to bury the hatchet. It's also possible to simply not read what one has no patience for. Yes, and when we talk in person, social cues, back channel and nonverbal communications enrich the dialog, reducing the

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread podinski
on > Eight Traits of the Disinformationalist > Saboteurs > Provocateurs > Informants > Recruiting > Surveillance > Scare Tactics > Seventeen Techniques for Truth Suppression > -- next part -- > An HTML attachment was scrubbed... > URL: > <h

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Joseph Rabie
Time for us all to be useful idiots, and follow the Party line!! Joe. > Le 18 janv. 2021 à 19:01, Roman Seidl a écrit : > > For some time it was kind of entertaining to read something which seems > totally out of time, like from the 1980s. It seems like it's going to go on > like this for

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Iain Boal
OK, John, apologies. Mistakes were made. I was not feeling well. I now recognize my "name-calling destructiveness”. I retract "sinomane”. Would “sinophilic” meet your approval? As for “telecommunist”, you surely noticed, it's their self-description! Those nettimers, stakhanovite heroes and

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Brian Holmes
I am sure you heard last week's joke, Iain: "Due to the pandemic, the United States decided to have its coup at home this year." Has anyone heard one about the Green Zone? cheers, BH On Mon, Jan 18, 2021 at 5:33 PM Iain Boal wrote: > OK, John, apologies. Mistakes were made. I was not feeling

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 2021-01-18 23:47, Allanmini2 wrote: What is also unbearable is someone who name drops revolutionary and theoretical icons (gee, how did you miss Rosa Luxemburg or Nelson Mandela, etc. etc. Dmytri?) as if the names alone qualify you to continue with unbearably one dimensional verbiage about

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 2021-01-18 23:11, podinski wrote: But i am going to move on, without feeling too abused this time... it was simply ear-less mansplaining + more-radical-than- you attitude... at a pretty belligerent level ! And i can laugh a little more about it now ! Once again, you come in with insults

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 2021-01-18 21:09, Andreas Broeckmann wrote: i find it unbearable though to see untenable claims of "mccarthyism" made against somebody who just stays in an argument, when anybody in his right mind should know that we must reserve the "mccarthy" reference to cases where livelihoods are

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Allanmini2
Hello Thank you Andreas! What is also unbearable is someone who name drops revolutionary and theoretical icons (gee, how did you miss Rosa Luxemburg or Nelson Mandela, etc. etc. Dmytri?) as if the names alone qualify you to continue with unbearably one dimensional verbiage about strategies for

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Dmytri Kleiner
On 2021-01-18 19:22, Geoffrey Goodell wrote: Every now and then, people talk of forcing his removal, but for various logistical reasons this seems not to be possible, and moreover the other people on the list want to profess openness to debate. [...] So, I must ask: Is it possible that

Re: The Left Needs a New Strategy

2021-01-18 Thread Andreas Broeckmann
Dmytri, for me, the conversation stops here: > However, as we all know, the government of China enjoys broad support > from it's people. > After all, by every measure they are doing better > than we are in terms of getting what they want from their government. I'm not in the "we" group of your