Re: [onap-discuss] [Onap-usecasesub] [onap-tsc] The summary of Usecase subcommittee meeting 14/05/2017 - Casablanca use cases/functional requirements endorsement

2018-05-17 Thread Martin Skorupski
Thanks Dan! I fully agree to your view! The SDN-R project just adds some wireless/ran related applications/functions according to ONAP procedures and process to SDNC. That was the reason, why SDN-R is a subproject of SDNC – also visible as subfolder of in the ONAP wiki and in ONAP

Re: [onap-discuss] [Onap-usecasesub] [onap-tsc] The summary of Usecase subcommittee meeting 14/05/2017 - Casablanca use cases/functional requirements endorsement

2018-05-17 Thread Parviz Yegani
Agree with Alla. The name doesn’t matter. You can call it “Pineapple”. What we need to do is to review the ONF architecture and other relevant specs to see if this module, indeed, implements only a subset of the SDN-C functions. I glanced through some of these documents. The good news is like

Re: [onap-discuss] [Onap-usecasesub] [onap-tsc] The summary of Usecase subcommittee meeting 14/05/2017 - Casablanca use cases/functional requirements endorsement

2018-05-17 Thread Stephen Terrill
Hi, Thanks Alla - I would like to elaborate on this. At the end of the release we have to be able to articulate what we are doing and why, otherwise we reduce ONAPs credibility. Part of this is ensuring architectural coherence and the appropriate project structure as part of our governance.

Re: [onap-discuss] [Onap-usecasesub] [onap-tsc] The summary of Usecase subcommittee meeting 14/05/2017 - Casablanca use cases/functional requirements endorsement

2018-05-17 Thread Alla Goldner
Vladimir, if I understood Steve's comment correctly, it is not about any particular name, but more about recognition of yet additional standalone controller, while we don't have it as a part of our architecture. This is why the proposal is to contain it under SDN-C (as, also according to our

Re: [onap-discuss] [Onap-usecasesub] [onap-tsc] The summary of Usecase subcommittee meeting 14/05/2017 - Casablanca use cases/functional requirements endorsement

2018-05-16 Thread Vladimir Yanover (vyanover)
SDN-R is ONF project based on the Microwave Information Model TR-532, which is quite distant from what is needed for cellular RAN. So what we knew as SDN-R in fact never was SDN Radio controller :) Therefore we are free to keep the name SDN-R or find another good looking name. After all, it's