Re: [onap-tsc][onap-discuss]Questions about Security Requirements for Casablanca: is CADI the only option to enable RBAC?

2018-06-28 Thread Yang Bin
Hi Jonathan, Appreciate your explanation. Glad to know Python CADI has been touched , hope it will be available sometime. But integration with CADI requires effort and knowledge to understand the whole workflow, and debug/maintain effort as well. It will be great

Re: [onap-tsc][onap-discuss]Questions about Security Requirements for Casablanca: is CADI the only option to enable RBAC?

2018-06-28 Thread Yang Bin
Hi Srini, I believe for multicloud the access rules based on URI/HTTP header values are pretty enough. If ISTIO CA and RBAC could help that would be great relief. Thanks for the comment. Best Regards, Bin Yang,Solution Readiness Team,Wind River Direct +86,10,84777126

Re: [Onap-seccom] [onap-tsc][onap-discuss]Questions about Security Requirements for Casablanca: is CADI the only option to enable RBAC?

2018-06-27 Thread GATHMAN, JONATHAN C
FYI, when I say “AAF is entirely RESTful”, I mean that calling AAF is RESTful. This means that any language that can do HTTP/S and TEXT can talk to AAF legitimately, including, I’ve seen MainFrames. Just because AAF itself is RESTful does not mean that applications using AAF must be RESTful.

Re: [onap-tsc][onap-discuss]Questions about Security Requirements for Casablanca: is CADI the only option to enable RBAC?

2018-06-27 Thread GATHMAN, JONATHAN C
Greetings, Bin, Secure calls using Python is different depending on the Environment. However, remember that for Casablanca, we are still on the hook for “HEAT” as well as OOM (where “OOM” is Kubernetes). If in Kubernetes, there is an effort underway to create a Security Microservice, and

Re: [Onap-seccom] [onap-tsc][onap-discuss]Questions about Security Requirements for Casablanca: is CADI the only option to enable RBAC?

2018-06-27 Thread Samuli Kuusela
Hi, as this topic was discussed also in Risk Assessment sessions in Beijing F2F event, adding here some aspects (disclaimer, my summary text below has not been reviewed): Authentication and authorization (AA) solution: non-REST APIs, and components written in other language than Java are not

Re: [onap-tsc][onap-discuss]Questions about Security Requirements for Casablanca: is CADI the only option to enable RBAC?

2018-06-27 Thread Srini
Hi Bin, As Ramki mentioned in the wiki page, ISTIO CA and ISTIO RBAC may be good enough for Multi-Cloud. But to be sure, it is good to know from Multi-Cloud team on what kind of APIs are present and what kind of restrictions the team thinks it should provide to various consumers of

Re: [onap-tsc][onap-discuss]Questions about Security Requirements for Casablanca: is CADI the only option to enable RBAC?

2018-06-27 Thread Stephen Terrill
Hi Bin, I am looping in the onap-seccom distribution list as well. @Jonathan, what guidance would you provide for Bin regarding use CAD with python? Best Regards, Steve. From: Yang, Bin Sent: Wednesday, June 27, 2018 5:57 AM To: Stephen Terrill ; onap-tsc Cc: onap-disc...@lists.onap.org

[onap-tsc][onap-discuss]Questions about Security Requirements for Casablanca: is CADI the only option to enable RBAC?

2018-06-26 Thread Yang Bin
Dear TSC and Security Subcommittee, As part of S3P requirement, the CII Silver badge requires: *Level 2: CII Silver badge, plus: -All internal/external system communications shall be able to be encrypted. -All internal/external service calls shall have common role-based