Re: SV: Could the specs group consider making uid mandatory?

2016-12-19 Thread Thomas Beale
On 16/12/2016 02:37, Bjørn Næss wrote: If you add UID on ENTRY level and you want to use that for some referencing/look up functionality: How do you handle versioning of Compositions and its content? Is it a new entry UID for each version ? same UID across versions. There is a way to

Re: Could the specs group consider making uid mandatory?

2016-12-19 Thread Diego Boscá
I believe that ISO 13606 renewal has proposed uuid to be made optional, but they are still there El 18/12/2016 23:23, "Heath Frankel" escribió: > I think it should be a strong recommendation rather than mandatory > considering it is currently optional and the

SV: Could the specs group consider making uid mandatory?

2016-12-19 Thread Bjørn Næss
What kind of identifier should this be? ENTRY is not versioned. Will this UID be a version independent identifier or should it also keep references across a version hierarchy? I agree that there are good reasons to add some identifier on an ENTRY. And it must not be mandatory - because it