Re: [9] Proposal to deprecate VP6 video and the FLV/FXM file formats

2015-09-02 Thread David DeHaven
Having heard no objections and gaining internal approval, we'll move forward with this plan. -DrD- > On Aug 26, 2015, at 11:53 AM, David DeHaven wrote: > > > I am proposing we deprecate support for the VP6 video encoding format and the > FXM/FLV file format in

Re: [9] Proposal to deprecate VP6 video and the FLV/FXM file formats

2015-08-27 Thread Kevin Rushforth
It's not directly related to JEP 257, no. Just some outstanding cleanup. Btw, speaking of JEP 257, we plan to integrate that to 9-dev today. -- Kevin Michael Berry wrote: +1 for deprecation - I haven't used VP6 in a long while, and would value the whole thing being open source more than its

Re: [9] Proposal to deprecate VP6 video and the FLV/FXM file formats

2015-08-27 Thread David DeHaven
+1 for deprecation - I haven't used VP6 in a long while, and would value the whole thing being open source more than its inclusion. Out of interest, is this anything to do with JEP 257? I started looking at this with Kirill's guidance a year or so ago, but sadly many other things had to

Re: [9] Proposal to deprecate VP6 video and the FLV/FXM file formats

2015-08-27 Thread Michael Berry
On 27 August 2015 at 19:53, David DeHaven david.deha...@oracle.com wrote: +1 for deprecation - I haven't used VP6 in a long while, and would value the whole thing being open source more than its inclusion. Out of interest, is this anything to do with JEP 257? I started looking at this

Re: [9] Proposal to deprecate VP6 video and the FLV/FXM file formats

2015-08-27 Thread Kirill Kirichenko
On 27.08.2015 9:29, Dr. Michael Paus wrote: To me this sounds again like a Java/JavaFX specific solution which, to my opinion, is a dead-end road. I think it would be much more important that JavaFX can directly use all system installed codecs. I simply don't understand why it is possible to

Re: [9] Proposal to deprecate VP6 video and the FLV/FXM file formats

2015-08-26 Thread David DeHaven
+1 for deprecation of VP6 and clearing the way to open sourcing of JFXMedia. On a related note, you will soon need to support H.265/HEVC. HEVC apparently also supports an alpha channel, so it may also address that concern. (See http://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-H.265-201504-I/en) 3D support

Re: [9] Proposal to deprecate VP6 video and the FLV/FXM file formats

2015-08-26 Thread Scott Palmer
+1 for deprecation of VP6 and clearing the way to open sourcing of JFXMedia. On a related note, you will soon need to support H.265/HEVC. HEVC apparently also supports an alpha channel, so it may also address that concern. (See http://www.itu.int/rec/T-REC-H.265-201504-I/en) All of this might