Re: Dialogs in JavaFX 8u40

2014-11-01 Thread Kevin Rushforth
There are no more design improvements planned for 8u40, and b12 has all of the latest changes. If there is something specific that you had in mind you could either discuss on this thread or file a JIRA, but it will be post-8u40. As for fixing bugs, we have about one more month -- M4 is on Dec

Re: Dialogs in JavaFX 8u40

2014-11-01 Thread Jonathan Giles
Other than bug fixes, there is no additional work planned. If there are things you would like to see supported, please file requests in Jira. If there are design bugs, please report them! -- Jonathan Sent from a touch device. Please excuse my brevity. On 2 November 2014 07:05:10 GMT+13:00, Pete

Re: Dialogs in JavaFX

2014-06-20 Thread Jonathan Giles
Jeff, could you please post your comments in Jira so that we don't lose them? Thanks! -- Jonathan On 21/06/2014 3:59 a.m., Jeff Martin wrote: I agree that the four showXXX() methods are a slight complexity, but I think they are simpler than the alternative. They quickly communicate the impli

Re: Dialogs in JavaFX

2014-06-20 Thread Jeff Martin
I agree that the four showXXX() methods are a slight complexity, but I think they are simpler than the alternative. They quickly communicate the implied "Type" of the DialogBox and response: // Type Message: No response DialogBox dbox = new DialogBox("FYI"); dbox.setMessage("Just

Re: Dialogs in JavaFX

2014-06-20 Thread Stephen F Northover
This essentially matches my current thinking, however, I would have DialogBox as an abstract superclass of Alert. Further, I would not have many different types of show() methods. Want to take the discussion further in the JIRA? That way, is will track everyone's thinking on the various issu

Re: Dialogs in JavaFX

2014-06-20 Thread Jeff Martin
That is a great post. I think the big problem with dialogs in Swing was the permutations problem. There were four basic types of dialogs (Message, Confirm, Option, Input) with six different parameters (Title, Message, Icon, Content, MessageType, Options) - so JOptionPane ended up with a sea of s

Re: Dialogs in JavaFX

2014-06-20 Thread Stephen F Northover
Great post Jonathan. The summary is that whatever direction we take, we'll have a plan for the future. So if we run out of time and provide only a very scaled back API, we'll have prototyped how it can evolve to handle more complex cases. Steve On 2014-06-20, 12:37 AM, Jonathan Giles wrote: