Re: [Opensim-dev] mantis resolved vs. closed

2009-01-27 Thread Justin Clark-Casey
Nebadon Izumi wrote: I always saw it as that when a developer or someone marked a ticket as resolved it meant they made an attempt to resolve this item and that the filer needs to test it and either close the ticket or re-open back to a true bug status, and only the reporter should close

Re: [Opensim-dev] mantis resolved vs. closed

2009-01-27 Thread James Stallings II
I can certainly appreciate the problem of abandoned mantii - most of them are. I think what caught me off-guard here is idb and I were actively working the issue - and without me knowing the ticket would be resolved as it was (automatically) it gave a certain appearance that did not reflect well

Re: [Opensim-dev] mantis resolved vs. closed

2009-01-27 Thread Mike Mazur
Hi, On Tue, 27 Jan 2009 10:47:14 -0600 James Stallings II james.stalli...@gmail.com wrote: suppose instead of setting the ticket to 'resolved' and closing it, we set it to 'resolution pending test' and leave it open I don't think there's enough difference between resolved and resolution

Re: [Opensim-dev] mantis resolved vs. closed

2009-01-25 Thread Nebadon Izumi
I always saw it as that when a developer or someone marked a ticket as resolved it meant they made an attempt to resolve this item and that the filer needs to test it and either close the ticket or re-open back to a true bug status, and only the reporter should close the ticket, that is until a

Re: [Opensim-dev] mantis resolved vs. closed

2009-01-25 Thread nlin
Hello, One possible source of confusion is that the OpenSim wiki says Please leave closing of bugs to core team. A closed bug means we think it's gone forever, or the bug report is invalid. (http://opensimulator.org/wiki/Bugs) That may explain why lots of issues remain in the resolved state. Is