Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-24 Thread Michael Pittaro
When it comes to server software, log files are not just for developers. In my experience, the first people who look at log files are operators and users. For non-English speakers, something as simple as the absence of the word 'ERROR' or 'WARNING' in a critical message can mean the difference b

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-24 Thread Joshua Harlow
Maybe that's a problem as well. Log files might be best just for log messages ;) On 2/21/12 6:01 AM, "David Kranz" wrote: Because at least some OpenStack projects use log files for more than just error messages, there may not be a one-size-fits all answer to this. I agree strongly with point 1 b

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-21 Thread David Kranz
Because at least some OpenStack projects use log files for more than just error messages, there may not be a one-size-fits all answer to this. I agree strongly with point 1 below but have also gotten a lot of value from generic web searching of error snippets from log files, including searches

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-20 Thread Ahn, Jaesuk
We have a small discussion at OpenStack Korea Community about logging in local language. Most of participants said that they prefers having logging message in English only. Reasons are: 1. Logging messages are searchable keywords. Having a single entry point for searching is important. 2.

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-20 Thread Thierry Carrez
Diego Parrilla Santamaría wrote: > Joshua, most of non-english speaking developers I know try to use > english for class names, methods, fields, constants... English is the > 'lingua franca' for code, so even developers with bad english level like > me try to use english all the time... so internat

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-13 Thread Eric Windisch
both ways... -- Eric Windisch On Monday, February 13, 2012 at 2:41 PM, Joshua Harlow wrote: > Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln? Agreed, I do that as well. > > But I’m also a biased yankee, now a californian (not hippie/ster yet, haha). > > On 2/13/12 2:37 PM, "Andrew Bog

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-13 Thread Joshua Harlow
Agreed, I do that as well. But I'm also a biased yankee, now a californian (not hippie/ster yet, haha). On 2/13/12 2:37 PM, "Andrew Bogott" wrote: On 2/13/12 3:58 PM, Eric Windisch wrote: I'm guessing that you're looking at this from a developer's perspective rather than a support and oper

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-13 Thread Andrew Bogott
On 2/13/12 3:58 PM, Eric Windisch wrote: I'm guessing that you're looking at this from a developer's perspective rather than a support and operations perspective. Developers will understand English, but the operations and especially the support team may not. Having native language log message

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-13 Thread Eric Windisch
outsource support). -- Eric Windisch On Monday, February 13, 2012 at 1:50 PM, Joshua Harlow wrote: > Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln? Interesting, that is one way of doing it. > > Is this pretty common with other major open-source projects? > > Logging just seems like a diffe

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-13 Thread Joshua Harlow
Interesting, that is one way of doing it. Is this pretty common with other major open-source projects? Logging just seems like a different place to me, where english seems like it should be required. I am biased of course ;) On 2/13/12 1:39 PM, "Eric Windisch" wrote: Josh, I think the prob

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-13 Thread Eric Windisch
useful for debugging purposes. -- Eric Windisch On Monday, February 13, 2012 at 1:15 PM, Joshua Harlow wrote: > Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln? Sure but to contribute they have to > understand python which itself is english based?? > I can understand for sys-ops people t

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-13 Thread Joshua Harlow
Sure but to contribute they have to understand python which itself is english based?? I can understand for sys-ops people that can't understand english this might be useful, but then they are running in unix which is also english based. For FE (front-end facing) sites I completely agree that, th

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-13 Thread Diego Parrilla Santamaría
Joshua, most of non-english speaking developers I know try to use english for class names, methods, fields, constants... English is the 'lingua franca' for code, so even developers with bad english level like me try to use english all the time... so internationalized logging messages do not make se

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-13 Thread Ronald Bradford
Hi Josh, I cannot speak about the i18n specifics in OpenStack, but let me give you an answer to the general question. I added a slide to a presentation last week that uses the graph at http://www.internetworldstats.com/top20.htm I recommend you check it out. The title of the slide is "English is

Re: [Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-13 Thread Eric Windisch
Josh, you raise an interesting point. This also affects the ability to search on these terms. On the other hand, having log messages in a language that the user doesn't understand will require those users to seek assistance when they might otherwise be able to solve the problems themselves. It

[Openstack] Question on i8ln?

2012-02-13 Thread Joshua Harlow
Hi all, I was just wondering if I could get clarification on something I never understood related to i8ln. In nova HACKING.rst there is a line that mentions how log messages should be using gettext for i8ln. Is it common in other companies to attempt to internationalize log messages? I've see