Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-27 Thread Robert . Kloefkorn
Hi all, The first is what has been the main focus for the black-oil simulator, the second was made to enable parallel MPI simulations with Dune solvers. The two codes have been diverging lately (some code for transmissibility multipliers was implemented only for the unstructered grid),

Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-27 Thread Andreas Lauser
Hida, you forgot an important point: On Wednesday 27 August 2014 10:03:06 robert.kloefk...@iris.no wrote: A + B) build an interface that allows for both grids (GridHelpers) pros: - everybody is happy? (fair to Norwegian standards ;-)) - ? cons: - maintenance for two grid

Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-27 Thread Atgeirr Rasmussen
27. aug. 2014 kl. 10:03 skrev robert.kloefk...@iris.no: Hi all, The first is what has been the main focus for the black-oil simulator, the second was made to enable parallel MPI simulations with Dune solvers. The two codes have been diverging lately (some code for transmissibility

Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-27 Thread Robert . Kloefkorn
Hi Atgeirr, thanks for your thoughts. To clarify, I think a grid interface with one realization of it I would count as an implementation. A grid that can load different type of geometric cells I would count as one grid implementation (e.g. UG, the other UG from Heidelberg). In that sense I think

Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-27 Thread wireless
On 08/27/14 06:54, robert.kloefk...@iris.no wrote: I think I have seen one new grid interface per year for the last 7 or so years. And they were all introduced for very good reasons. So I am a little reluctant to enter this discussion again... Atgeirr Hi Atgeirr, thanks for your

Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-27 Thread Paolo Orsini
Hi, Before any comments, let me say I am new to OPM, and I have only been browsing through the code of opm-core, and the eclipse-parser (no longer than a couple months). For that reason I can comment only from a user point of view. One of the reasons we are looking at OPM is because we are

Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-27 Thread wireless
On 08/27/14 08:34, Paolo Orsini wrote: For that reason I can comment only from a user point of view. One of the reasons we are looking at OPM is because we are looking to for an open source black-oil simulator which we can start testing, using, and eventually help with the development of the

Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-15 Thread Alf Birger Rustad
solution with helper classes is not ideal. Cheers, Alf From: Paolo Orsini [paolo.ors...@gmail.com] Sent: Wednesday, August 13, 2014 5:01 PM To: Alf Birger Rustad Cc: opm@opm-project.org Subject: Re: [OPM] Grid interface Ok, doing some more browsing I found some

Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-14 Thread Paolo Orsini
Marcus: thanks for confirming. Paolo On Thu, Aug 14, 2014 at 4:58 PM, Markus Blatt mar...@dr-blatt.de wrote: Hi, On Wed, Aug 13, 2011 at 05:01:54PM +0200, Paolo Orsini wrote: Ok, doing some more browsing I found some reference to the black-oil model (BO) in the opm-autodiff, this has

Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-10 Thread wireless
On 08/09/14 18:45, wireless wrote: On 08/09/14 07:18, Alf Birger Rustad wrote: Hello everybody, Finally we have a reference black-oil simulator coming into shape, but admittedly still some rough edges to iron out. During this effort we uncovered challenges with our plumbing. The most

Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-10 Thread Alf Birger Rustad
Hi James, The points you raise all make sense. The documentation part is a moving target, which always needs improvement. As much as we would like to improve on it to make opm attractive for more developers, we are currently prioritizing getting a useful black-oil simulator in place. Doxygen

Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-10 Thread wireless
On 08/10/14 12:50, Alf Birger Rustad wrote: Hi James, The points you raise all make sense. The documentation part is a moving target, which always needs improvement. As much as we would like to improve on it to make opm attractive for more developers, we are currently prioritizing getting a

Re: [OPM] Grid interface

2014-08-10 Thread Andreas Lauser
Hi All, On Sunday, August 10, 2014 13:17:09 wireless wrote: On 08/09/14 18:45, wireless wrote: On 08/09/14 07:18, Alf Birger Rustad wrote: Hello everybody, Finally we have a reference black-oil simulator coming into shape, but admittedly still some rough edges to iron out. During this