Re: [osgi-dev] tool for initial semantic version

2013-08-01 Thread Peter Kriens
Just adding a packageinfo (or package-info.java) would help and would not cost anything. For the Consumer/Provider types ... well, I do not see an easy solution but would be curious to hear your experiences when you try Andrei Pozolotin andrei.pozolo...@gmail.com's application at

Re: [osgi-dev] tool for initial semantic version

2013-07-31 Thread Ferry Huberts
On 31/07/13 19:11, Raymond Auge wrote: Also, I would imagine for the initial behavior to only be build warnings that a developer may be breaking provider/consumer backward compatibility. I want to grow our team's awareness around the idea of semantic versionning... not make them want to

Re: [osgi-dev] tool for initial semantic version

2013-07-31 Thread Raymond Auge
On Wed, Jul 31, 2013 at 1:15 PM, Ferry Huberts maili...@hupie.com wrote: For (semantic) versioning in OSGi the bundle version actually is meaningless. It's a marketing number, so 6.2.0 in your case. Only package versions have meaning. Of course you can always version everything the same,

Re: [osgi-dev] tool for initial semantic version

2013-07-31 Thread Marcel Offermans
Hello Ferry, On 31 Jul 2013, at 19:15 , Ferry Huberts maili...@hupie.com wrote: For (semantic) versioning in OSGi the bundle version actually is meaningless. It's a marketing number, so 6.2.0 in your case. Only package versions have meaning. We've had this discussion in person before, but

Re: [osgi-dev] tool for initial semantic version

2013-07-31 Thread Ferry Huberts
On 31/07/13 20:05, Marcel Offermans wrote: Hello Ferry, On 31 Jul 2013, at 19:15 , Ferry Huberts maili...@hupie.com mailto:maili...@hupie.com wrote: For (semantic) versioning in OSGi the bundle version actually is meaningless. It's a marketing number, so 6.2.0 in your case. Only

Re: [osgi-dev] tool for initial semantic version

2013-07-31 Thread Raymond Auge
Thanks all, I guess what I was really after was a tool which would actually create all the packageinfo files for me so I wouldn't have to add them to the hundreds and hundreds of unversioned packages. I can script it. On Wed, Jul 31, 2013 at 2:56 PM, Ferry Huberts maili...@hupie.com wrote: