Dissolving history (was Re: Re: Re: The US buys democracy for Yugoslavia.)

2000-09-26 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:2302] Re: Re: The US buys democracy for Yu, el 25 Sep 00, a las 23:03, [EMAIL PROTECTED] dijo: I disn't say that the historical facts are unimportant--although sometimes I think it's advisable to forget them for pragmatic purposes when trying to frame a solution to a

Re: clarifications

2000-09-26 Thread Charles Brown
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/25/00 10:56PM The personal squabble between Lou and Doug is going to ruin all three lists -- pen-l, marxism, and lbo -- if it doesn't stop. CB: Didn't Marx answer the question "What is ? " , " squabble" ?

Workers' Entitlements

2000-09-26 Thread JKSCHW
Many people have complained about my typos. they are no doubt due to my bkindfolding by imperialist propaganda. The argument that the ethical basis of Marxism is worker's is respectable, but, I believe, a mistaken reading of Marx. there is an extensive debate on this. A main figure on the

Re: Dissolving history (was Re: Re: Re: The US buys democracy for Yugoslavia.)

2000-09-26 Thread JKSCHW
I am not an academic or an economist. You will have to decide for yourself whether I am a faithful servant of the IMF. --jks In a message dated Tue, 26 Sep 2000 7:45:24 AM Eastern Daylight Time, "Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky" [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: En relación a [PEN-L:2302] Re: Re: The US

Re: Re: RE: Marx and Nature

2000-09-26 Thread Jim Devine
[By mistake, Michael P. sent the answer to Andrew's question to me rather than to the list as a whole. ] "Austin, Andrew" wrote: Didn't Marx argue that labor-power was the measure of exchange-value? Andrew Austin Green Bay, WI Michael Perelman wrote: Here is a thumbnail

Re: Re: Dissolving history (was Re: Re: Re: The US buysdemocracy for Yugoslavia.)

2000-09-26 Thread Michael Perelman
I don't think that Nestor was accusing you of either crime. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I am not an academic or an economist. You will have to decide for yourself whether I am a faithful servant of the IMF. --jks In a message dated Tue, 26 Sep 2000 7:45:24 AM Eastern Daylight Time, "Nestor

the labor theory of value

2000-09-26 Thread Charles Brown
By Chapter One of _Capital_, both Nature and human labor are sources of use-values. Only human labor is a source of exchange-values. If an apple falls off of a tree and someone eats it, Nature was a source of that use-value. But there is no such thing as an exchange-value falling directly off

Re: Re: Re: The US buys democracy for Yugoslavia.

2000-09-26 Thread Charles Brown
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/25/00 06:09PM Given the pressures on it, the Milosevic government has been one of the mildest in recent history. It is no more repressive than the FSLN in Nicaragua... Why this compulsion to lie to blacken the reputation of the Sandinistas? ((( CB: Would

Re: 8 Eurocentric Historians

2000-09-26 Thread Jim Devine
Why are we discussing this again? didn't we kill this topic? Nonetheless, I don't see why Blaut's distortions should go unanswered. Jim Blaut wrote: ROBERT BRENNER IN THE TUNNEL OF TIME Robert Brenner is a Marxist, a follower of one tradition in Marxism that is as diffusionist, as

RE: the labor theory of value

2000-09-26 Thread Lisa Ian Murray
By Chapter One of _Capital_, both Nature and human labor are sources of use-values. Only human labor is a source of exchange-values. = I know that. My question was trying to get at whether Marx was saying that even though nature is the source of use-values, it "in-itself" does or does not

Re: RE: Warning Signs

2000-09-26 Thread Doug Henwood
Max Sawicky wrote: I do have doubts as to the inevitability of crisis, but I don't believe we have reached "permanent prosperity, . . . " The latter is a separate matter. Everyday life might be in crisis, but crisis as a danger to the economic system is a whole different story. I think the

Re: RE: RE: Marx and Nature

2000-09-26 Thread Michael Perelman
Andrew, you are correct in so far as you go. Marx did sys, as you said, that "he only basis for their exchange, since they are otherwise differentiated (which is why their exchange is desirable), is the labor they contain." However, he qualifies that approach in Volume 3. "Austin, Andrew"

the labor theory of value

2000-09-26 Thread Charles Brown
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/25/00 05:49PM At 02:59 PM 9/25/00 -0400, you wrote: Wasn't Marx himself critical of the notion that only labor creates value? I recall something about nature being a partner in the enterprise. for Marx, labor and nature both create use-values, whereas only labor

Warning Signs

2000-09-26 Thread Charles Brown
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/25/00 06:44PM CB: "Suppose" ? Do you have any doubt that there will eventually be a crisis, or do you believe that we have reached permanent prosperity, land of milk and honey continuously ? I do have doubts as to the inevitability of crisis, but I don't believe we

RE: Warning Signs

2000-09-26 Thread Max Sawicky
CB: So do you not feel that there will inevitably , eventurally be a danger to the economic system as a whole ? Are you saying that capitalism might be eternal, permanent, unending ? yup. mbs

Re: Re: RE: Warning Signs

2000-09-26 Thread Doug Henwood
All you fans of crisis: what's the political benefit been of Japan's decade of stagnation? Of Latin America's two decades of polarization punctuated by depression, and of Africa's two decades of depression and social crisis? The next president of Mexico is going to be a morally conservative

Warning Signs

2000-09-26 Thread Charles Brown
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/26/00 12:19PM All you fans of crisis: what's the political benefit been of Japan's decade of stagnation? Of Latin America's two decades of polarization punctuated by depression, and of Africa's two decades of depression and social crisis? The next president of Mexico

Warning Signs

2000-09-26 Thread Charles Brown
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/26/00 12:08PM CB: So do you not feel that there will inevitably , eventurally be a danger to the economic system as a whole ? Are you saying that capitalism might be eternal, permanent, unending ? Max: yup. ( CB: An honest person !

RE: RE: Warning Signs

2000-09-26 Thread Lisa Ian Murray
CB: So do you not feel that there will inevitably , eventually be a danger to the economic system as a whole ? Are you saying that capitalism might be eternal, permanent, unending ? yup. mbs === But Jean-Luc Piccard says that in the 24th century material gain and economic

Doug's two questions

2000-09-26 Thread Michael Perelman
Doug asked if the normal downturn of the business cycle constituted a crisis. He also asked if the ongoing recession in various parts in the world was a positive factor. I don't feel particularly confident to give an absolute answer to either question, but his questions do merit an answer.

RE: Warning Signs

2000-09-26 Thread Max Sawicky
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/26/00 12:08PM CB: So do you not feel that there will inevitably , eventurally be a danger to the economic system as a whole ? Are you saying that capitalism might be eternal, permanent, unending ? Max: yup. ( CB: An honest person ! I never lie. mbs

prison time for ADM

2000-09-26 Thread Eugene Coyle
Yesterday's Wall St. Journal (9/25/00) carried the news that two ADM executives were ordered to serve sentences longer than originally set. The Appeals Court concurred with the prosecuter that the initial sentences were too short (two years each) and ordered the judge to tack a bit on. The

More re John Graaf's point

2000-09-26 Thread Eugene Coyle
The other day I received an unexpected package. A copy of the book EARTH ODESSEY by Mark Hertsgaard. It was a gift, courtesy of a man with bone cancer who wanted a safer world for his child. This wonderful person bought 20,000 copies of the book for distribution to "...activists, teachers,

Re: More re John Graaf's point

2000-09-26 Thread Louis Proyect
Gene Coyle: "Combining government leadership with market incentives, a Global Green Deal would do for environmental technologies like solar power and green cars what industry and government have already done so well for computer technologies: luanch their commercial

BLS Daily Report

2000-09-26 Thread Richardson_D
BLS DAILY REPORT, MONDAY, SEPTEMBER 25, 2000 Motorists have plenty of pungent words for the gasoline prices that have shot upward since 1998, says Peter Behr, writing in The Washington Post "Business" section (page 10). Economists sometimes call them a tax. That's how gasoline price increases

[ Marx and Nature

2000-09-26 Thread Charles Brown
[EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/25/00 10:28PM Didn't Marx argue that labor-power was the measure of exchange-value? ((( CB: Hello Andy ! The amount labor-time socially necessary for for the production of a commodity is the measure of the magnitude of its exchange-value. Labor-power is

the labor theory of value

2000-09-26 Thread Charles Brown
Actually air is a good example of a use-value from nature that does not have exchange-value because there is no human labor producing it for exchange. It is an example of wealth that human labor is not a source of . It's free, for now. CB [EMAIL PROTECTED] 09/25/00 08:35PM Of course, the

Re: the labor theory of value

2000-09-26 Thread Ken Hanly
Surely it is too restrictive to distinguish only "use values" and "exchange values". Things can be intrinsically valuable to humans i.e. the enjoyment of a sunset, the taste of an apple, etc.etc. without being of any particular use in the ordinary sense of the world. "use values" recalls what

Re: Re: RE: Warning Signs

2000-09-26 Thread Jim Devine
A question for our more excitable contributors: is an ordinary business cycle recession a "crisis"? Not really, though "crisis theory" (a.k.a. Marxian macroeconomics, which has a heavy infusion from Keynes) helps us understand it. In a real crisis, either there'd be a major change of course

Re: RE: Warning Signs

2000-09-26 Thread Jim Devine
I never lie. mbs I, on the other hand, always lie (including this sentence). Jim Devine [EMAIL PROTECTED] http://bellarmine.lmu.edu/~jdevine

Re: RE: the labor theory of value

2000-09-26 Thread Jim Devine
At 09:01 AM 9/26/00 -0700, you wrote: By Chapter One of _Capital_, both Nature and human labor are sources of use-values. Only human labor is a source of exchange-values. = I know that. My question was trying to get at whether Marx was saying that even though nature is the source of

Re: Re: Dissolving history (was Re: Re: Re: The US buys democracy for Yugoslavia.)

2000-09-26 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:2320] Re: Dissolving history (was Re: Re: , el 26 Sep 00, a las 10:50, [EMAIL PROTECTED] dijo I am not an academic or an economist. You will have to decide for yourself whether I am a faithful servant of the IMF. --jks [I had previously pointed out that jks's way of

Re: Re: Re: Dissolving history (was Re: Re: Re: The US buys democracy for Yugoslavia.)

2000-09-26 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:2322] Re: Re: Dissolving history (was Re: , el 26 Sep 00, a las 8:30, Michael Perelman dijo: I don't think that Nestor was accusing you of either crime. [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I am not an academic or an economist. You will have to decide for yourself whether I

RE: Re: RE: the labor theory of value

2000-09-26 Thread Lisa Ian Murray
JD I think that for Marx, as with Locke, nature has no value _in society_ unless someone mixes labor with it. Both present theories of society when they present their labor theories. Locke's labor theory is a theory of property, BTW. That is, it's a (poor) theory of why some people have

The Internet Anti-Fascist: Tuesday, 26 Sep 2000 -- 4:78 (#471)

2000-09-26 Thread Paul Kneisel
--- Support our sponsor Great Dell prices. Great Dell value. Buy now and get $100 off powerful Dell(tm) Dimension(tm) 4100 desktops and mobile, lightweight Dell Inspiron(tm) 5000e notebooks. It's your money. Spend it wisely. Click now.

Electoral Circuses or Working Class Struggles?

2000-09-26 Thread neil
-- Forwarded Message -- From: neil, 74742,1651 TO: Neil C., 74742,1651 CC: DATE: 9/26/00 1:46 PM RE: Electoral Circuses or Working Class Struggles? Tis the season for yet another electoral circus. The Republican and Democratic Parties wallow in hundreds

Re: oil, wheat, argentina

2000-09-26 Thread Nestor Miguel Gorojovsky
En relación a [PEN-L:2216] oil, wheat, argentina, el 24 Sep 00, a las 22:33, Michael Perelman dijo: A recent report by the Worldwatch's Lester Brown points out that while the U.S pays for its oil imports in part with grain exports, exports of grain and oil are each concentrated in a

Re: Re: RE: the labor theory of value

2000-09-26 Thread JKSCHW
In a message dated 9/26/00 6:09:15 PM Eastern Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Locke's labor theory is a theory of property, BTW. That is, it's a (poor) theory of why some people have property and some people have more than others in society. Every few years I try to convince

Re: Re: Re: Re: 8 Eurocentric Historians

2000-09-26 Thread JKSCHW
In a message dated 9/26/00 6:12:13 PM Eastern Daylight Time, [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Brenner clearly went out on a limb to attack the D-of-U school. And Blaut attacks back, also going out on a limb. I won't say which of these two has higher levels of scholarship. It seems to me that both

Re: Re: Re: Re: Dissolving history (was Re: Re: Re: The US buys ...

2000-09-26 Thread JKSCHW
Fair enough. Actually I think being an academic is more of a vice and being an economist is a venial sin. As for stepping further in that direction, I really to think sometimes it is best to say, Look, I don't care who hit whom first: we have a Situation here, and what are we going to do about

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Dissolving history (was Re: Re: Re: TheUS buys ...

2000-09-26 Thread Carrol Cox
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: Fair enough. Actually I think being an academic is more of a vice and being an economist is a venial sin. According to Doug (answering a question at the marxism 2000 plenary he spoke at) the economics profession is intellectually and morally bankrupt. (I think I

Re: RE: Re: RE: the labor theory of value

2000-09-26 Thread Jim Devine
Ian wrote: My sense is that this would be somewhat helpful in developing Marxian theories of enterprises [not Marxian theories of capitalist firms] which took legal factors into account. It is alternatives not more critique that needs to be done now. For the last ten months the critiques have

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Dissolving history (was Re:Re: Re: TheUS buys ...

2000-09-26 Thread Doug Henwood
Carrol Cox wrote: According to Doug (answering a question at the marxism 2000 plenary he spoke at) the economics profession is intellectually and morally bankrupt. (I think I have it right from memory. Doug can -- and no doubt will -- correct me if I'm wrong.) Yeah, I got a little carried away

Re: Re: the labor theory of value

2000-09-26 Thread Carrol Cox
Ken Hanly wrote: Surely it is too restrictive to distinguish only "use values" and "exchange values". Things can be intrinsically valuable to humans i.e. the enjoyment of a sunset, the taste of an apple, (Preliminary: Neither Marxism nor any other ism is a TOE [theory of everything])

Hostile takeovers: Russian style.

2000-09-26 Thread Ken Hanly
*** #1 Vodka Dispute Shows Russia Chaos September 26, 2000 By JIM HEINTZ MOSCOW (AP) - Heading the Kristall vodka distillery should be a businessman's dream - the chance to manage one of Russia's most prestigious enterprises, with a world-renowned array of products, a diligent work force

Fwd: the Economist on globalization

2000-09-26 Thread Jim Devine
from SLATE magazine's on-line summary of the content of other magazines: Economist, Sept. 22 The cover story criticizes the spate of WTO/World Bank/IMF protests, scheduled to continue in Prague next week. To defuse the protesters, the international organizations have farmed out

Re: Re: oil, wheat, argentina

2000-09-26 Thread Eugene Coyle
Although payments to farmers are always discussed as subsidies, I prefer to think of them as covering the difference between marginal cost -- what the farmer sells at -- and average cost, which includes overhead cost. Farmers can't cover total costs while selling at marginal cost. So farming is

[Fwd: nudists for nader]

2000-09-26 Thread Michael Perelman
This post constitutes proof positive that Chico is in the forefront of politics, despite all the news from Prague. dna wrote: If you would lke to join the Nudist for Nader here is the deal, Meet at behind the stage in park plaza thursday at 6:30 bring any funky costumes (or lack therof)

Morally Bankrupt economists on their way to becoming financially so...

2000-09-26 Thread Lisa Ian Murray
[full article http://www.nytimes.com/2000/09/27/national/27HARV.html ] September 27, 2000 U.S. Seeks Millions in Suit Against Advisers to Russia By CAREY GOLDBERG BOSTON, Sept. 26 — Federal prosecutors today filed a civil suit contending that two Harvard University advisers who helped mold

BILL FLETCHER, JR. TO TALK AT THE MARXIST SCHOOL OF SACRAMENTO

2000-09-26 Thread Seth Sandronsky
September 27, 2000 For more information: News ReleaseCall John Rowntree 916-446-1758 BILL FLETCHER, JR. TO TALK ABOUT THE LABOR MOVEMENT IN THE NEW MILLENIUM AT THE MARXIST SCHOOL OF SACRAMENTO Bill Fletcher, Jr., Assistant to the President of

Fwd: [fla-left] [women's health issues] Study: Poor Access to (fwd)

2000-09-26 Thread Michael Hoover
forwarded by Michael Hoover Poor Access to Abortion Endangers Women's Health Run Date: 09/18/00 By Melinda Voss WEnews contributing editor States can improve women's health by ensuring access to abortion services, but most states, and the nation as a whole, have failed to