Re: PK on Big Blackout

2003-08-20 Thread Patrick Bond
- Original Message - From: "Sabri Oncu" [EMAIL PROTECTED] People "steal" electricity regularly in Turkey (maybe Patrick Bond would offer some information about a similar phenomenon in South Africa) not only because they cannot pay for it but also because it is very difficult to determine wh

Re: PK on Big Blackout

2003-08-19 Thread Sabri Oncu
Max: > Don't know much about (anything, actually) > electricity, but . . . > > I doubt the relevance of rivalness/excludability > in this context (putting aside enviro/other > externalities). Seems to me the main things > are natural monopoly, oui or non. Well. I had to take a few courses from t

Re: PK on Big Blackout

2003-08-19 Thread Diane Monaco
Max wrote: So for items 2 and 3, the issue is not fragmentation ("competition") v. monopoly, but public v. private regulated monopoly. True, but can a privately regulated monopoly efficiently and reliably provide a good that sometimes behaves like a public good and sometimes behaves like a private

Re: PK on Big Blackout

2003-08-19 Thread Max B. Sawicky
Don't know much about (anything, actually) electricity, but . . . I doubt the relevance of rivalness/excludability in this context (putting aside enviro/other externalities). Seems to me the main things are natural monopoly, oui or non. #s 2 and 3 don't lend themselves to overlap-- 2 is land-int

Re: PK on Big Blackout

2003-08-19 Thread Diane Monaco
Paul Krugman wrote: We still don't know what started the chain reaction on Thursday. Whatever the initial cause, however, the current guess is that a local event turned into an epic blackout because the transmission network has been neglected. And the cause of that neglect is faith-based deregula

PK on Big Blackout

2003-08-19 Thread Devine, James
August 19, 2003/New York TIMES The Road to Ruin By PAUL KRUGMAN We still don't know what started the chain reaction on Thursday. Whatever the initial cause, however, the current guess is that a local event turned into an epic blackout because the transmission network has been neglected. That is,