Re: Re: The Stalingrad thesis.

2003-03-30 Thread Peter Dorman
I hate to say this -- it's really pretty ugly -- but the reason Baghdad will not be Stalingrad is fairly simple. The US has the power to destroy as much of the city and its inhabitants as it wants. There is no military impediment to this, only the political cost of such slaughter. It comes

RE: Re: The Stalingrad thesis.

2003-03-29 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:36269] Re: The Stalingrad thesis. right. I've been telling people that I fully expect the US to win the war (especially since Honor is At Stake and we wouldn't want a repeat of Somalia) but then lose the occupation. I think I've been right: the US will be trying to run