Re: Re: Re: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Doug Henwood
Michael Perelman wrote: Lou is correct on several points. Brad typically supports neo-liberal policies abroad and, at least to my mind, he is more often than not wrong. Also, the 3 people he mentioned did leave in disgust about Brad's behavior. I thought that it would have been healthier to

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Michael Perelman
Dialogue requires a certain degree of courtesy that was often absent from his posts. On Tue, Dec 03, 2002 at 02:22:32PM -0500, Doug Henwood wrote: Michael Perelman wrote: Lou is correct on several points. Brad typically supports neo-liberal policies abroad and, at least to my mind, he is

RE: Re: RE: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Devine, James
Title: RE: [PEN-L:32724] Re: RE: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial I said: It's not the same as the self-perception and self-justification of imperialists that I described. Ian writes: Right, except that I think they're no longer worried about the fables of international public goods

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Carrol Cox
Doug Henwood wrote: Michael Perelman wrote: True enough, but it's an odd model of dialogue that will admit only people in fundamental agreement with each other. I guess it's the left version of Richard Feinberg's wonderful comment that democracy only works when there's fundamental

Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Re: Maquiladoras not beneficial

2002-12-03 Thread Louis Proyect
Carrol Cox: Brad is an enemy, but one can talk to him just as Chou tried to talk to Dulles one morning during the Geneva Conference. (They both arrived early one morning; Chou offered to shake hands, Dulles snubbed him.) In the present case Lou is playing a marxist version of Dulles's style,