Re: Imperialist progressivism (was Re: Thatcher andnationalism)

2000-09-11 Thread Brad DeLong
Brad DeLong wrote: On the one hand, trees and hills. On the other hand, people. On what theory of political justice can the first ever trump the second? Well, Senator Albert Beveridge seemed to have a fairly firm grasp of one such. I guess it depends on which people you are addressing.

Re: Imperialist progressivism (was Re: Thatcher andnationalism)

2000-09-10 Thread Brad DeLong
For what they are worth, my views on the Malvinas are very simple. Geography alone would suggest that they are a part of Argentina, and I would recognise Argentinian sovereignty. Michael K. On the one hand, trees and hills. On the other hand, people. On what theory of political justice can the

Re: Imperialist progressivism (was Re: Thatcher andnationalism)

2000-09-08 Thread Brad De Long
If, as Tam Dalyell has shown, Thatcher prepared the war in order to win her elections... How did Thatcher do that? Did she bribe the Junta to send troops to the Malvinas Islands? Brad DeLong The population in the Malvinas are the result of forcible eviction, by a British fleet, of the legal

Re: Imperialist progressivism (was Re: Thatcher andnationalism)

2000-09-08 Thread Michael Perelman
The debate on the Falklands/Malvinas is troubling. I thought the the outcome meant that Thatcher triumphed politically, while the junta had to face political defeat, eventually. As to rights, such matters are troubling. I live on property stolen from the Mexicans who stole it from the Native