Re: The mysterious pg_proc.protrftypes

[Tom Lane]

"Joel Jacobson"  writes:
> Attached patch adds "(references pg_type.oid)" to the documentation for 
> pg_proc.protrftypes.

Agreed, pushed.  I also stumbled over a backend core dump while
testing it :-(.  So this whole area seems a bit spongy ...

regards, tom lane

Re: The mysterious pg_proc.protrftypes

[Pavel Stehule]

po 25. 1. 2021 v 8:47 odesílatel Joel Jacobson  napsal:

> On Mon, Jan 25, 2021, at 08:14, Pavel Stehule wrote:
> >you should to use TRANSFORM clause in CREATE FUNCTION statement
>
> Thanks, it worked, and like expected it references the pg_type.oid of the
> transform.
>
> Attached patch adds "(references pg_type.oid)" to the documentation
> for pg_proc.protrftypes.
>
> Suggested commit message: "Document the fact that pg_proc.protrftypes
> references pg_type.oid"
>

+1

Pavel


> /Joel
>

Re: The mysterious pg_proc.protrftypes

[Joel Jacobson]

On Mon, Jan 25, 2021, at 08:14, Pavel Stehule wrote:
>you should to use TRANSFORM clause in CREATE FUNCTION statement

Thanks, it worked, and like expected it references the pg_type.oid of the 
transform.

Attached patch adds "(references pg_type.oid)" to the documentation for 
pg_proc.protrftypes.

Suggested commit message: "Document the fact that pg_proc.protrftypes 
references pg_type.oid"

/Joel

pg-proc-protrftypes-references-pg-type-oid.patch
Description: Binary data

Re: The mysterious pg_proc.protrftypes

[Pavel Stehule]

po 25. 1. 2021 v 8:05 odesílatel Joel Jacobson  napsal:

> Hi,
>
> I'm trying to understand how pg_proc.protrftypes works.
>
> The documentation says "Data type OIDs for which to apply transforms.".
> For this column, there is no reference to any catalog table?
> I would guess it should be "(references pg_type.oid)", right?
>
> I tried to generate a value for this column to verify my hypothesis,
> but I struggle to find an example that produces a not null value here.
>
> I grepped the sources and found the "CREATE TRANSFORM FOR type_name"
> command,
> and found an extension using it named "bool_plperl" which I installed.
>
> I assumed this would cause a value, but no.
>
> Both of bool_plperl's two functions get null pg_proc.protrftypes values.
>
> I've tried running the full regression "make installcheck",
> but protrftypes doesn't seem to be covered:
>
> $ cd postgresql
> $ make installcheck
> ...
> ===
> All 203 tests passed.
> ===
> $ psql regression
> regression=# SELECT COUNT(*) FROM pg_proc WHERE protrftypes IS NOT NULL;
> count
> ---
>  0
> (1 row)
>
> Can someone please show me how to generate a function with a not null
> pg_proc.protrftypes value?
>

you should to use TRANSFORM clause in CREATE FUNCTION statement

https://www.postgresql.org/docs/current/sql-createfunction.html

CREATE EXTENSION hstore_plperl CASCADE;

CREATE FUNCTION test2() RETURNS hstore
LANGUAGE plperl
TRANSFORM FOR TYPE hstore
AS $$
$val = {a => 1, b => 'boo', c => undef};
return $val;
$$;

Regards

Pavel


> Many thanks.
>
> /Joel
>
>
>
>
>
>
>

The mysterious pg_proc.protrftypes

[Joel Jacobson]

Hi,

I'm trying to understand how pg_proc.protrftypes works.

The documentation says "Data type OIDs for which to apply transforms.".
For this column, there is no reference to any catalog table?
I would guess it should be "(references pg_type.oid)", right?

I tried to generate a value for this column to verify my hypothesis,
but I struggle to find an example that produces a not null value here.

I grepped the sources and found the "CREATE TRANSFORM FOR type_name" command,
and found an extension using it named "bool_plperl" which I installed.

I assumed this would cause a value, but no.

Both of bool_plperl's two functions get null pg_proc.protrftypes values.

I've tried running the full regression "make installcheck", but protrftypes 
doesn't seem to be covered:

$ cd postgresql
$ make installcheck
...
===
All 203 tests passed.
===
$ psql regression
regression=# SELECT COUNT(*) FROM pg_proc WHERE protrftypes IS NOT NULL;
count
---
 0
(1 row)

Can someone please show me how to generate a function with a not null 
pg_proc.protrftypes value?

Many thanks.

/Joel