Re: [pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] pmacctd in docker

2022-05-12 Thread Thomas Eckert
Great, thanks! That was fast :-) Regards, Thomas On Tue, May 10, 2022 at 4:29 PM Paolo Lucente wrote: > > Hi Thomas, > > I think some confusion may be deriving from docs (to be improved) and > the fact 1.7.6 is old. > > Nevertheless, from the interface indexes from your last output (ie. >

Re: [pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] pmacctd in docker

2022-05-10 Thread Paolo Lucente
Hi Thomas, I think some confusion may be deriving from docs (to be improved) and the fact 1.7.6 is old. Nevertheless, from the interface indexes from your last output (ie. 1872541466, 3698069186, etc.) i can tell that you did configure pcap_ifindex to 'hash' (being honored as you can see)

Re: [pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] pmacctd in docker

2022-05-09 Thread Thomas Eckert
Hi Paolo, Thanks for the hint, I gave it a try. I'm observing the exact same behavior between running pmacct in a container & directly on my host in all cases. Tested with * official docker image: 281904b7afd6 * official ubuntu 21.10 package: pmacct/impish,now 1.7.6-2 amd64 I *think* the problem

Re: [pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] pmacctd in docker

2022-05-08 Thread Paolo Lucente
Hi Thomas, The simplest thing i may recommend is to check it all working outside a container - this way you can easily isolate whether the issue is somehow related to the container (config or interaction of pmacctd with the container) or with the pmacct config itself. Paolo On 6/5/22

[pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] pmacctd in docker

2022-05-06 Thread Thomas Eckert
Hi everyone, pmacct starter here, trying to get pmacctd working inside of a container to listen to the (container's) host's traffic. I suppose this is a, if not the, standard use case for pmacctd in a container. So I'm sure it works in principle but I'm doing something wrong. Command for

Re: [pmacct-discussion] docker

2021-10-02 Thread Marc Sune
Steven, John, John, thank you for jumping in. I agree it's the proper solution. I believe the reason why the first container immediately stops is because, in docker, a container will be alive until the main process (or entrypoint) is alive. For the pmacctd container, the entry point is:

Re: [pmacct-discussion] docker

2021-10-01 Thread Steve Clark
Hi, I found if I set daemonize: false in my pmacctd.conf file and use the -d flag on the docker run line it seems to work. Don't know if this is the proper solution though. Thanks, Steve On 10/1/21 7:21 AM, Steve Clark wrote: Hello, I am having trouble getting the "latest" or

Re: [pmacct-discussion] docker

2021-10-01 Thread John Jensen
Hey Steve, It is the proper solution. To add some context, if you don't pass '-it' (-i keeps STDIN open on the container and -t allocates a pseudo-TTY and attaches it to the STDIN of the container) or '-d' (which spawns the container in 'detached' mode, which will return your running container

[pmacct-discussion] docker

2021-10-01 Thread Steve Clark
Hello, I am having trouble getting the "latest" or "bleeding-edge" docker image to run by using the following command: docker run --privileged --network host -v /etc/pmacct_netwolves/pmacctd.conf:/etc/pmacct/pmacctd.conf pmacct/pmacctd:bleeding-edge $ docker ps CONTAINER ID IMAGE

Re: [pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] docker nfacct ... strange udp source ip !

2021-06-10 Thread Marc Sune
Alessandro, Since conntrack -D -p udp does fix the issue, it's clear conntrack cache is incorrect. The conjecture here is that pmacct docker container is started (or probably, restarted) with the UDP traffic flowing. Linux's connection tracker (conntrack) keeps track on connections, and also

Re: [pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] docker nfacct ... strange udp source ip !

2021-06-09 Thread Alessandro Montano | Fiber Telecom
Dusan, I'm new in this docker world, I don't know swarm It's think it's a normal docker-compose version 1.29.2, build 5becea4c -- AlexIT ___ pmacct-discussion mailing list http://www.pmacct.net/#mailinglists

Re: [pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] docker nfacct ... strange udp source ip !

2021-06-09 Thread Marc Sune
Dusan, Thanks. I seemed to have misunderstood yo before. That sounds like it, yes. After reading through most, this might be _the_ issue: https://github.com/moby/moby/issues/16720#issuecomment-435637740 https://github.com/moby/moby/issues/16720#issuecomment-444862701 Alessandro, can you try

Re: [pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] docker nfacct ... strange udp source ip !

2021-06-09 Thread Marc Sune
Dusan, Alessandro, Let me answer Dusan first. Missatge de Dusan Pajin del dia dc., 9 de juny 2021 a les 18:08: > > Hi Alessandro, > > I would say that this is a "known" issue or behavior in docker which is > experienced by everyone who ever wanted to receive syslog, netflow, telemetry > or

Re: [pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] docker nfacct ... strange udp source ip !

2021-06-09 Thread Alessandro Montano | Fiber Telecom
Hi Dusan, A know issue? and nobody can solve it ! with udp packets it's a real problem. And in many situations, it-s not possibile di ricetly-attach to host network. For scalability I was thinking to have many istances of the same collector (with docker -scale) , and an nginx as

Re: [pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] docker nfacct ... strange udp source ip !

2021-06-09 Thread Dusan Pajin
Hi Alessandro, I would say that this is a "known" issue or behavior in docker which is experienced by everyone who ever wanted to receive syslog, netflow, telemetry or any other similar UDP stream from network devices. When you expose ports in your docker-compose file, the docker will create the

Re: [pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] docker nfacct ... strange udp source ip !

2021-06-09 Thread Paolo Lucente
Hi Alessandro, (thanks for the kind words, first and foremost) Indeed, the test that Marc proposes is very sound, ie. check the actual packets coming in "on the wire" with tcpdump: do they really change sender IP address? Let me also confirm that what is used to populate peer_ip_src is

Re: [pmacct-discussion] [docker-doctors] docker nfacct ... strange udp source ip !

2021-06-09 Thread Marc Sune
Alessandro, inline Missatge de Alessandro Montano | FIBERTELECOM del dia dc., 9 de juny 2021 a les 10:12: > > Hi Paolo (and Marc), > > this is my first post here ... first of all THANKS FOR YOU GREAT JOB :) > > I'm using pmacct/nfacctd container from docker-hub >

[pmacct-discussion] docker nfacct ... strange udp source ip !

2021-06-09 Thread Alessandro Montano | FIBERTELECOM
Hi Paolo (and Marc), this is my first post here ... first of all THANKS FOR YOU GREAT JOB :) I'm using pmacct/nfacctd container from docker-hub (+kafka+telegraf+influxdb+grafana) and it's really a powerfull tool The sender are JUNIPER MX204 routers, using j-flow (extended netflow) NFACCTD