Re: URIs within URIs

2014-08-22 Thread Bill Roberts
Hi Luca We certainly find a need for that kind of feature (as do many other linked data publishers) and our choice in our PublishMyData platform has been the URL pattern {domain}/resource?uri={url-encoded external URI} to expose info in our databases about URIs in other domains. If there was

Re: Linked Data and Semantic Web CoolURIs, 303 redirects and Page Rank.

2014-07-23 Thread Bill Roberts
Hi Michael We've tended to use slash URIs where possible, because have found it more convenient when doing URI dereferencing from a triple-store backed site - in which case we essentially do a DESCRIBE on the relevant URI. (So we do 303ing for non-information resources, though in practice in a

Re: What is the correct approximate number of LOD datasets?

2013-10-09 Thread Bill Roberts
Unfortunately I don't think it's possible to come up with a meaningful single figure on the number of available LOD datasets. It depends on how you define a dataset and it depends on your approach to collecting information on what is available. Best regards Bill Roberts On 9 Oct 2013

Re: Datatypes with no (cool) URI

2012-04-03 Thread Bill Roberts
The ideal thing would be if ISO, Eurostat produced concise resolvable URIs of course. But while we wait for them to do that, why doesn't W3C mint and support URIs for the most commonly used code lists, that resolve to relevant documentation and/or links to the definitive documents from ISO etc.

Re: Conversion to RDF/Linked Data

2012-02-14 Thread Bill Roberts
/Linked_Data_Cookbook#Ingredients_for_High_Quality_Linked_Data Regards Bill Roberts On 14 Feb 2012, at 09:16, Mika Singh wrote: I want to convert persons data to RDF/Linked Data. I have data like this: Person_ID has_name N has_surname S

Linked Data visualisation of Indices of Multiple Deprivation

2011-09-08 Thread Bill Roberts
, but also pulls in stuff from all kinds of other APIs too. Blog post here: http://openviz.wordpress.com/2011/09/08/indices-of-deprivation-linked-data-prototype/ App itself here: http://dclgexamples.mywebcommunity.org/imd_demo_v7.htm Bill Roberts

HTTP status for timed-out SPARQL query

2011-06-28 Thread Bill Roberts
Looking for some advice from the community. If we time out a slow-running SPARQL query, what is the most appropriate HTTP status code to return to the client? We had been trying 408, but the problem with that is that some clients (notably Firefox) take it on themselves to keep retrying the

Re: HTTP status for timed-out SPARQL query

2011-06-28 Thread Bill Roberts
that it is temporary and after what time the client MAY try again. 500 Internal Server Error was also my first guess, but this may not stop clients from trying again. Martin On Jun 28, 2011, at 8:21 AM, Bill Roberts wrote: Looking for some advice from the community. If we time out a slow

Edinburgh hackday reminder

2011-06-27 Thread Bill Roberts
Just a quick reminder that there is still time to register for the Scottish Linked Data Hackday in Edinburgh next week - Tuesday 5 July. Details and sign-up here: http://scottishlinkeddatahackday2.eventbrite.com/ Best regards Bill

Re: Several questions about Linked Data

2011-03-23 Thread Bill Roberts
Although this has led to a discussion, no-one as far as I can tell has actually tried to answer Wenlei Zhou's question. Hope this helps: I can create a link from my dataset to yours just by including a triple in my dataset with one of 'your' URIs as object. http://mysite.com/id/1

Design issues 5-star data section tidy up

2011-03-09 Thread Bill Roberts
I like the new(ish) addition to http://www.w3.org/DesignIssues/LinkedData.html on 5-star data. Unfortunately it looks like TimBL typed it with his eyes shut :-) Since it's a much read and much referenced document, I'd like to offer the following version with typos corrected. Perhaps someone

Re: Design issues 5-star data section tidy up

2011-03-09 Thread Bill Roberts
state that a manufacturer or shop site that obeys all linked data rules and puts out a lot of valuable data in RDF does not even deserve a single star. Best Martin Hepp On Mar 9, 2011, at 9:46 PM, Bill Roberts wrote: I like the new(ish) addition to http://www.w3.org

Re: The truth about SPARQL Endpoint availability

2011-03-05 Thread Bill Roberts
Thanks Hugh - as someone running a couple of SPARQL endpoints, I'd certainly prefer if people don't run a global count too often (or at all). It is indeed something that makes typical SPARQL implementations work very hard. But it's a good reminder we should provide an alternative and i'll look

Re: 200 OK with Content-Location might work

2010-11-07 Thread Bill Roberts
Hi John Your points are good ones and some care should certainly be taken in how a possible 200-with-content-location option should be presented to the 'outside world'. 1) the public-lod forum is mostly aimed at practitioners, so hopefully not too many new LODers will have been alarmed by the

Re: Crowdsourcing request: Google People Finder Data as RDF

2010-03-04 Thread Bill Roberts
Hi Aldo - I'd like to help, but I see you posted your mail a few hours ago. Do you have updated information on what still needs done? Do you have a wiki or similar to coordinate volunteer programming efforts? Regards Bill On 4 Mar 2010, at 14:06, Aldo Bucchi wrote: Hi, As most of you

Re: Storing data with semantics..?

2010-02-24 Thread Bill Roberts
I definitely reckon first approach would be better - then the data can be easily downloaded if required and you can add some RDF metadata about that file if you want to. Having base64 data in the RDF is going to be messy, especially if there is a lot of data, and less flexible for user

Re: Linking HTML pages and data

2010-02-18 Thread Bill Roberts
Hi Michael - maybe also include the RDFa approach, using about=http://example.org/people/jane#me; ? And a trivial point, but having introduced the Jane example, maybe better to change the Mogwai examples to use Jane instead? Thanks for doing this - v useful. Bill On 18 Feb 2010, at 14:08,

Re: Ontology Wars? Concerned

2009-11-18 Thread Bill Roberts
Hi Nathan I think you have to try harder than that to cause offence! I think an attempt at standardisation on the one 'true' set of ontologies is futile, not scalable and ultimately a dead end. However, using suitable existing ontologies in a sensible way leads to a kind of lingua franca

Re: Subjects Tagging - Help?

2009-11-03 Thread Bill Roberts
Finally, regarding dc:subject, a tag can be used not as a subject (think of a webpage tagged cool or todo, they are probably not used as subject) so the semantics of dc:subject is probably not what you want here. I think this comment from Alexandre gets to the core of the matter.

Re: Newbie LOD Questions :)

2009-10-28 Thread Bill Roberts
on the web which happens to hold a bunch of RDF. I don't think sameAs is really relevant for the mirror example you presented. I'll have to stop there for now - hopefully you'll get further responses to address your other questions. Hope that helps Bill Roberts On 28 Oct 2009, at 19:04, Nathan

Re: Representing time varying data - suggestions for ontologies?

2009-07-31 Thread Bill Roberts
Thanks everyone for comments on this. I'll do some work on RDFizing a real data set or two and feed back experience/examples of that to the list to see what people think Cheers Bill

Representing time varying data - suggestions for ontologies?

2009-07-30 Thread Bill Roberts
Suppose I want to say something like: The total rainfall in Edinburgh in 2006 was 600mm. There are various ways to do it, but I'd probably go for something like this in pseudo-RDF Edinburgh hasMeasuredProperty _b _b measureOf Annual Rainfall _b period 2006 _b rdf:value 600 _b unit

Re: owl:sameAs

2009-07-25 Thread Bill Roberts
Eric Simply use owl:sameAs like you would any other property. The object of the triple is the URI you want to say refers to the same thing. So rdf:Description rdf:about=http://infomotions.com/etexts/id/more-utopia-221 owl:sameAs resource=http://dbpedia.org/resource/Utopia_(book)

Re: owl:sameAs (oops, minor correction)

2009-07-25 Thread Bill Roberts
sorry forgot the rdf: in front of resource: rdf:Description rdf:about=http://infomotions.com/etexts/id/more-utopia-221 owl:sameAs rdf:resource=http://dbpedia.org/resource/Utopia_(book) /rdf:Description On 25 Jul 2009, at 11:09, Bill Roberts wrote: Eric Simply use owl:sameAs like

Re: .htaccess a major bottleneck to Semantic Web adoption / Was: Re: RDFa vs RDF/XML and content negotiation

2009-07-02 Thread Bill Roberts
I thought I'd give the .htaccess approach a try, to see what's involved in actually setting it up. I'm no expert on Apache, but I know the basics of how it works, I've got full access to a web server and I can read the online Apache documentation as well as the next person. So... after

Re: .htaccess a major bottleneck to Semantic Web adoption

2009-06-26 Thread Bill Roberts
I agree, with Bernard (and also with an earlier comment of Mark's): if we are talking about widespread adoption of RDF, we need to think of who is currently creating HTML, and how they are doing it. I think we all know this, but it's easy to forget when we spend all our time on the web or

Re: RDFa vs RDF/XML and content negotiation

2009-06-23 Thread Bill Roberts
Thanks everyone who replied. It seems that there's a lot of support for the RDFa route in that (perhaps not statistically significant) sample of opinion. But to summarise my understanding of your various bits of advice: since there aren't currently so many applications out there

Re: Bestbuy.com goes Semantic Web the GoodRelations Way

2009-06-09 Thread Bill Roberts
Yeah, I too think this is a big deal. Semantic web in the commercial world obviously suffers the same chicken and egg problem as elsewhere, but if a big company like BestBuy just does it anyway, then services that consume and aggregate this kind of data are likely to spring up. Semantic

Re: Bestbuy.com goes Semantic Web the GoodRelations Way

2009-06-09 Thread Bill Roberts
, Kingsley Idehenkide...@openlinksw.com wrote: Bill Roberts wrote: Yeah, I too think this is a big deal. Semantic web in the commercial world obviously suffers the same chicken and egg problem as elsewhere, but if a big company like BestBuy just does it anyway, then services that consume