Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2010-01-14 Thread Niklas Lindström
Hi Jeni! 2010/1/7 Jeni Tennison j...@jenitennison.com: Thanks for the pointer! The compact (natural) example that you give at [1] is pretty much what I'd like to see as the JSON generated by default by a linked data API. Have you used this in anger anywhere? No and yes. :) That is, I haven't

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2010-01-07 Thread Jeni Tennison
Hi Niklas, On 4 Jan 2010, at 22:32, Niklas Lindström wrote: Gluon is a JSON format for RDF. It has a full syntax covering properties, resource references, bnodes and literals with optional datatype or language. With profiles, more more succinct forms are possible. Thanks for the pointer! The

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2010-01-04 Thread Niklas Lindström
Hi all! On Thu, Dec 17, 2009 at 4:40 PM, Mike Bergman m...@mkbergman.com wrote: Hi Dave, Dave Reynolds wrote: Dave Reynolds wrote: Jeni Tennison wrote: I don't know where the best place is to work on this: I guess at some point it would be good to set up a Wiki page or something that we

source code control: distributed, please [was: Creating JSON from RDF]

2009-12-22 Thread Dan Connolly
There was also some recent discussion at W3C about opening up Git or Mercurial distributed versioning systems for the standards community, which sounds like it could be a good fit for SemWeb IG-and-nearby collaborations. However that is at an early stage. Google Code might be easiest for

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-17 Thread Dave Reynolds
Dave Reynolds wrote: Jeni Tennison wrote: I don't know where the best place is to work on this: I guess at some point it would be good to set up a Wiki page or something that we could use as a hub for discussion? I'd suggest setting up a Google Code area and making anyone who is

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-17 Thread Frederick Giasson
Hi Jeni! Thanks, that looks interesting, and the idea of supporting similar mappings to XML and to CSV is very attractive. I also find this attractive :) But I couldn't actually work out how I would use it in the kind of situation we find ourselves in. We have, for example, RDF like this:

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-17 Thread Mark Birbeck
An excellent summary of the state of play so far, Dave...count me in. :) On Thu, Dec 17, 2009 at 1:48 PM, Dave Reynolds dave.e.reyno...@googlemail.com wrote: Dave Reynolds wrote: Jeni Tennison wrote: I don't know where the best place is to work on this: I guess at some point it would be

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-17 Thread Mike Bergman
Hi Dave, Dave Reynolds wrote: Dave Reynolds wrote: Jeni Tennison wrote: I don't know where the best place is to work on this: I guess at some point it would be good to set up a Wiki page or something that we could use as a hub for discussion? I'd suggest setting up a Google Code area

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Hammond, Tony
Hi Jeni: Agree with this: a normal developer would want to just get: [{ book: http://example.org/book/book6;, title: Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince },{ Wondered if you'd seen the JSONC proposal coming from the Google Data API work: Hi, As part of the

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Hammond, Tony
(Sorry for my last post. That'll learn me for composing in place. Hamfistedly hit the wrong buttons.) Hi Jeni: Agree with this: a normal developer would want to just get: [{ book: http://example.org/book/book6;, title: Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince },{

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Richard Light
In message c74badc3.20683%t.hamm...@nature.com, Hammond, Tony t.hamm...@nature.com writes Normal developers will always want simple. Surely what normal developers actually want are simple commands whereby data can be streamed in, and become available programmatically within their chosen

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Dan Brickley
On Mon, Dec 14, 2009 at 10:23 AM, Richard Light rich...@light.demon.co.uk wrote: In message c74badc3.20683%t.hamm...@nature.com, Hammond, Tony t.hamm...@nature.com writes Normal developers will always want simple. Surely what normal developers actually want are simple commands whereby data

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Dan Brickley
On Mon, Dec 14, 2009 at 10:37 AM, Jeni Tennison j...@jenitennison.com wrote: Richard, My opinion, based on the reactions that I've seen from enthusiastic, hard-working developers who just want to get things done, is that we (the data.gov.uk project in particular, linked data in general) are

Re: Creating JSON from RDF [OpenSearch Groups Link]

2009-12-14 Thread Hammond, Tony
Hi Damian: Sorry 'bout that. I did indeed include the wrong link (I was logged in at at the time). DeWitt's mail on the OpenSearch list is here: http://groups.google.com/group/opensearch/msg/f2f724e0e3123150 Here he's advocating JSONC as a possible (and practical) way forward. Cheers, Tony

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Mark Birbeck
Hi Richard, Isn't: Give 'em RDF and tell them to develop better toolsets ... exactly the approach that the RDF community has been pursuing for a decade or two, with less than impressive results? ;) Regards, Mark -- Mark Birbeck, webBackplane mark.birb...@webbackplane.com

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Richard Light
In message eb19f3360912140143m291c464brb76379d3cc2b0...@mail.gmail.com, Dan Brickley dan...@danbri.org writes RDF tooling still has some rough edges, it must be said. I am as enthusiastic about RDF as anyone (having been involved since 1997) but I've also seen the predictable results where on

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Mark Birbeck
Hi Richard, Despite the Bah, Humbug! tone of my previous mail, I am actually in favour too.  I just want to tease out the extent to which we would be giving developers what they say they want, rather than what they could actually use. The value of JSON is surely that JSON support is

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Richard Light
In message eb19f3360912140217w109daf1ah3c9320fa3363d...@mail.gmail.com, Dan Brickley dan...@danbri.org writes With every passing year the RDF tools do get a bit better, but also the old ones code rot a bit, or new things come along that need supporting (GRDDL, RDFa etc.). What can be done in

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Dave Reynolds
Jeni Tennison wrote: On 12 Dec 2009, at 22:27, Danny Ayers wrote: I can't offer any real practical suggestions right away (a lot to digest here!) but one question I think right away may some significance: you want this to be friendly to normal developers - what kind of things are they actually

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Dave Reynolds
Jeni Tennison wrote: It's worth noting that most of these APIs support a callback= parameter that makes the API return Javascript containing a function call rather than simply the JSON itself. I regard this as an unquestionably essential part of a JSON API, whether it uses RDF/JSON or RDFj or

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Dave Reynolds
Hi Jenni, Jeni Tennison wrote: On 13 Dec 2009, at 13:34, Dave Reynolds wrote: I agree we want both graphs and SPARQL results but I think there is another third case - lists of described objects. I absolutely agree with you that lists of described objects is an essential part of an API.

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Dave Reynolds
Mark Birbeck wrote: On Sat, Dec 12, 2009 at 9:42 PM, Jeni Tennison j...@jenitennison.com wrote: One thing that we want to do is provide JSON representations of both RDF graphs and SPARQL results. I wanted to run some ideas past this group as to how we might do that. Great again. :) In the

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Kjetil Kjernsmo
On Monday 14. December 2009 11:17:37 Dan Brickley wrote: I wish that kind of funding was easy to come by, but it's not. A lot of the work we need to get done around here to speed up progress is pretty boring stuff. It's not cutting edge research, nor the core of a world-changing startup, nor a

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-14 Thread Danny Ayers
2009/12/14 Richard Light rich...@light.demon.co.uk: In message c74badc3.20683%t.hamm...@nature.com, Hammond, Tony t.hamm...@nature.com writes Normal developers will always want simple. Surely what normal developers actually want are simple commands whereby data can be streamed in, and

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-13 Thread Nathan
Damian Steer wrote: On 12 Dec 2009, at 21:42, Jeni Tennison wrote: Hi, As part of the linked data work the UK government is doing, we're looking at how to use the linked data that we have as the basis of APIs that are readily usable by developers who really don't want to learn about RDF

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-13 Thread Jeni Tennison
Frederick, Thanks, that looks interesting, and the idea of supporting similar mappings to XML and to CSV is very attractive. But I couldn't actually work out how I would use it in the kind of situation we find ourselves in. We have, for example, RDF like this:

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-13 Thread Dave Reynolds
Hi Jeni, Jeni Tennison wrote: As part of the linked data work the UK government is doing, we're looking at how to use the linked data that we have as the basis of APIs that are readily usable by developers who really don't want to learn about RDF or SPARQL. Wow! Talk about timing. We are

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-13 Thread Mark Birbeck
Hi Jeni, On Sat, Dec 12, 2009 at 9:42 PM, Jeni Tennison j...@jenitennison.com wrote: Hi, As part of the linked data work the UK government is doing, we're looking at how to use the linked data that we have as the basis of APIs that are readily usable by developers who really don't want to

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-13 Thread Dan Brickley
On Sun, Dec 13, 2009 at 8:03 PM, Dave Reynolds dave.e.reyno...@googlemail.com wrote: Hi Jeni, [Rest of post snipped for now, I'll respond properly later. Seems like we are on sufficiently similar wavelengths that it is just a matter of working the details.] I don't know where the best place

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-13 Thread Toby Inkster
On Sat, 2009-12-12 at 21:42 +, Jeni Tennison wrote: To put this in context, what I think we should aim for is a pure publishing format that is optimised for approachability for normal developers, *not* an interchange format. RDF/JSON [1] and the SPARQL results JSON format [2] aren't

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-13 Thread Ivan Herman
Dan is right on many front... (it usually true:-) - I personally do not see a problem this being done on ESW, this does not mean any type of formal 'Association' with W3C (giving you a writing right is a matter of setting up a user for you and sending, eg, me or dan a mail to add you to the

Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-12 Thread Jeni Tennison
Hi, As part of the linked data work the UK government is doing, we're looking at how to use the linked data that we have as the basis of APIs that are readily usable by developers who really don't want to learn about RDF or SPARQL. One thing that we want to do is provide JSON

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-12 Thread Frederick Giasson
Hi Jeni, One project, amongst other, in this trend is irON [1] (with its irJSON[2] serialization profile). Also note that a revision of this specification will be released in the coming month or so based on the latest work we have done regarding the development of some parsers. The biggest

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-12 Thread Kingsley Idehen
Frederick Giasson wrote: Hi Jeni, One project, amongst other, in this trend is irON [1] (with its irJSON[2] serialization profile). Also note that a revision of this specification will be released in the coming month or so based on the latest work we have done regarding the development of

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-12 Thread Danny Ayers
Jeni, marvellous that you're working on this, and marvellous that you've thought this through an awful lot already. I can't offer any real practical suggestions right away (a lot to digest here!) but one question I think right away may some significance: you want this to be friendly to normal

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-12 Thread Nathan
Damian Steer wrote: On 12 Dec 2009, at 21:42, Jeni Tennison wrote: Hi, As part of the linked data work the UK government is doing, we're looking at how to use the linked data that we have as the basis of APIs that are readily usable by developers who really don't want to learn about RDF

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-12 Thread Nathan
Jeni Tennison wrote: Hi, As part of the linked data work the UK government is doing, we're looking at how to use the linked data that we have as the basis of APIs that are readily usable by developers who really don't want to learn about RDF or SPARQL. One thing that we want to do is

Re: Creating JSON from RDF

2009-12-12 Thread Frederick Giasson
Hi Kingsley, Why not use Jeni's dump as a usecase example/tutorial re. irON? A What (for the problem), Why (for irON virtues) and a How (an example based on the usecase presented). This is how you can formulate a very sharp apex for the irON value pyramid. Also note, UK, US, and Aussie