[RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-18 Thread EricP
Nice. Is that the bike you brought on the ride in August? Don't remember those bars. Oh, and rain? In San Diego? Tell me it ain't so! Eric Platt St. Paul, MN On Dec 18, 12:06 am, cyclotourist cyclotour...@gmail.com wrote:  I just put my mudguards/wheelbrows back on last weekend when it was

Re: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-18 Thread cyclotourist
Yep, that's the one. That's why they call 'em an All-Rounder :-) I probably don't need them mounted as it only rains for a day or so now and then, but hey, it keeps the dust down, too. I change bars out every four to six months on whim. In fact, if all goes according to plan I'll pick up

Re: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-18 Thread John Speare
On Wed, Dec 16, 2009 at 9:20 PM, Rene Sterental orthie...@gmail.com wrote: Hi John, What you say makes a lot of sense. Have you ridden off-road (mountain biked) with steel fenders? Or is this just your logical analysis of the question I posed? While logical analysis make sense (usually),

[RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-18 Thread JoelMatthews
Seeing the response in this tread about the woman whose Honjo crumpled surprises me. I put to SKS breakaways on my Camper after a Honjos on my Hilsen crumpled while on a limestone trail. The front tire apparently accumulated some tar riding over a (poorly) paved section of the trail. Where

Re: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-18 Thread Rene Sterental
Well... I received the Planet Bike Cascadia 29er fenders and upon opening the package and inspecting them, there are no safety quick release tabs on either front or rear fender. In fact, nothing in the instructions refers to safety releases at all. I positioned the rear one on my Bombadil to see

Re: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-18 Thread PATRICK MOORE
I've mounted my Cascadias, also without safety releases, in a way that I believe (and hope) will prevent endos from obstructing sticks. On the front I have mounted the struts to clamps halfway up the fork legs (I hope soon to get a custom fork that will incorporate eyelets in similar positions) so

Re: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-17 Thread Rene Sterental
Thanks Rob, Very nice setups. Pretty convincing argument as well. What is that saddlebag you have on the Bleriot? René -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To post to this group, send email to rbw-owners-bu...@googlegroups.com.

[RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-17 Thread Patrick in VT
On Dec 17, 12:20 am, Rene Sterental orthie...@gmail.com wrote: Not that I'm challenging you or anything, I'm just curious since your logic pretty much goes against what a lot of people have advised in response to my question. another data point: my significant other got a stick stuck in her

Re: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-17 Thread PATRICK MOORE
Eric said: Plus wanted to add the Planet Bike Cascadia fenders have built in mudflaps. They do, but unless they have re-designed them -- and quite possibly they have -- they are, as mine are, absurdly short. That actually works out well on the Monocog with its very high bb, but they would leave

[RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-17 Thread Patrick in VT
On Dec 17, 4:21 pm, PATRICK MOORE bertin...@gmail.com wrote: I put them on during the wet and during the snow months here in ABQ and they do make a huge difference especially on dirt. I don't ride in mud, but I do ride through puddles and slush and I can attest that fenders on mtbs do a great

[RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-17 Thread rob markwardt
Thanks. Acorn. On Dec 17, 6:33 am, Rene Sterental orthie...@gmail.com wrote: Thanks Rob, Very nice setups. Pretty convincing argument as well. What is that saddlebag you have on the Bleriot? René -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners

Re: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-17 Thread cyclotourist
I just put my mudguards/wheelbrows back on last weekend when it was actually raining! I ride trails a lot with fenders on. These are dirt roads/fire roads/forest roads mainly, not singletrack and not with a lot of undergrowth to worry about. Gonna' ride some of them this Sunday with the SoCal

Re: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-16 Thread John Speare
On Thu, Dec 10, 2009 at 3:12 PM, JoelMatthews joelmatth...@mac.com wrote: On Dec 10, 5:01 pm, Rene Sterental orthie...@gmail.com wrote: I am debating whether to install fenders on my new Bombadil, which I still haven't had time to finish assembling, but should be done by Saturday at the

Re: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-16 Thread Rene Sterental
Hi John, What you say makes a lot of sense. Have you ridden off-road (mountain biked) with steel fenders? Or is this just your logical analysis of the question I posed? While logical analysis make sense (usually), nothing beats actual experience. Not that I'm challenging you or anything, I'm just

[RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-16 Thread rob markwardt
I hit the trails regularly on my Bleriot and an old RockCombo. Both are shod with Berthouds...the Bleriot doesn't have a ton of clearance so I keep to pretty clear trails. The RockCombo has oversized 700c fenders and long mudflaps over 26 wheels so I have quite a bit of clearance...it's my

RE: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-11 Thread Frederick, Steve
There's also the length issue. Most metal fenders wrap lower behind the front wheel which is good for coverage but bad for clearance over trail obstacles. With shorter plastic fenders, you can extend them with a flexible mud flap that won't get caught on roots, rocks or logs. (the holy

[RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-11 Thread Tom M
Soma makes EuroTrip fenders that are 60 mm wide. What's nice about the Somas is that the stays are designed to pull away from the mount should something become wedged between the tire and fender. To me, the mounting is cleaner than what PB uses. I have a set of the road versions on my single

[RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-11 Thread Dave Craig
Patrick Are you sure that you are writing about the Planet Bike Cascadia fenders here. Other models of PB fenders have what I might consider excessively short front fenders, but not the Cascadias: http://tinyurl.com/y8b82jh Dave On Dec 11, 7:48 am, PATRICK MOORE bertin...@gmail.com wrote:

[RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-10 Thread newenglandbike
I think for offroad you'd want plastic fenders like SKS.They sell a size (P55 I think) that will accommodate up to 2.0 tires. I'm planning on getting a pair for my bike. You will pick up many pebbles riding dirt, and metal fenders are just going to be too loud IMHO. On Dec 10, 6:01 pm,

[RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-10 Thread JoelMatthews
They sell a size (P55 I think) that will accommodate up to 2.0 tires. And then some. They are pretty big fenders. You will pick up many pebbles riding dirt, and metal fenders are just going to be too loud IMHO. That can get annoying real fast. On Dec 10, 5:18 pm, newenglandbike

Re: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-10 Thread Rene Sterental
The potential noise doesn't bother me, but the potential accident does. However, led by your suggestions, I just found out that Planet Bike makes a set of fenders for 29er moutnain bikes that will cover up to a 2.3 tire, and these fit the prescription perfectly. I'll be ordering a set of those.

[RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-10 Thread EricP
Have PB fenders on one bike. And wife uses them on her steel steed. Really good protection from mud and rocks. And the long mud flap seems to work better than most. Beware, though, the fenders do have the Planet BIke name etched into the plastic. Not overly visible, but there. Covered mine

Re: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-10 Thread Rene Sterental
I'll paint it black, like the song says... the PB logo, I mean... :-D I don't know if having the logos visible will bother me, but if it does I'll do something about them. On Thu, Dec 10, 2009 at 5:51 PM, EricP ericpl...@aol.com wrote: Have PB fenders on one bike. And wife uses them on her

[RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-10 Thread Dave Craig
While I haven't tried Extremes, there's absolutely no reason not to run 2.0 Marathon XR's on or off road on a Bombadil. I've used them touring and on rugged, fast single track. I'm a pretty aggressive rider and I don't feel limited by the XR's. They roll pretty well on roads, though they are a

Re: [RBW] Re: Fenders on Bombadil for off-road and mountain biking...

2009-12-10 Thread Brian Hanson
Mountain bikes with tires?? Heresy! How are you going to get muddy/dirty? That's half the fun :) Brian On Thu, Dec 10, 2009 at 8:35 PM, Dave Craig dcr...@prescott.edu wrote: While I haven't tried Extremes, there's absolutely no reason not to run 2.0 Marathon XR's on or off road on a