[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-06-25 Thread RJM
Thanks Chris and Patrick for sending the reply to me. It will help quite a bit. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-06-24 Thread 'Chris Lampe 2' via RBW Owners Bunch
Patrick, I'm doing the keto thing in the hopes that I can reverse my recently diagnosed Type 2 diabetes, lose some weight and be able to spend more time riding my bicycle in interesting places. I'm encouraged by your experience with a ketogenic diet but did you experience a transition phase

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-06-24 Thread Deacon Patrick
Great questions, Chris. I'll reply off group. With abandon, Patrick -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-06-24 Thread RJM
I'm interested in your reply too. In a similar boat as Chris but blood sugar is higher. On Tuesday, June 24, 2014 5:09:16 PM UTC-5, Deacon Patrick wrote: Great questions, Chris. I'll reply off group. With abandon, Patrick -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-06-24 Thread Deacon Patrick
Och! I'm sorry. I sent it via the web interface, so have no record of it. Perhaps Chris can forward it to you? One thing I meant to put in but don't know if I did or not is that measuring ketones via urine is not very helpful. As you becomes keto adapted, your body will hold on to ketones,

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-17 Thread 'Tim' via RBW Owners Bunch
I know that my Roadeo, which I built up with the Dura Ace parts and the Mavic Ksyrium wheels from my go fast Cannondale, *feels* faster than my fendered Homer. It is definitely lighter but since I am working in CT and the Homer is here but the Roadeo is home in KC, I don't have a lot of

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-16 Thread Montclair BobbyB
Intriguing topic, eating and nutrition... For every dietary theory, there's a counter theory... I guess you go with what works for you... After all, it's not rocket surgery (my new fave saying). Now on the bike side, there seems to be a similar debate raging around a well-balanced drive train

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-15 Thread Montclair BobbyB
You must realize, Patrick... that one is pretty out there... most people (including myself) will have a hard time getting their heads around that kind of diet.. It's just such a radical departure from what we've been taught about fats and balanced diet ... and then there are those who rail

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-15 Thread Deacon Patrick
You're right, from a modern perspective, it's out there to eat mostly animal fat. From a bigger picture and understanding nutrition, relying heavily on grains and veggie oils and processed foods with who knows what in them is the out there diet, and is at most 60 years old out of 2 million of

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-15 Thread Ron Mc
the neolithic life expectancy was 20 years - it went to 35 with the development of grain agriculture, and is 67 today. On Thursday, May 15, 2014 10:48:40 AM UTC-5, Deacon Patrick wrote: You're right, from a modern perspective, it's out there to eat mostly animal fat. From a bigger picture

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-15 Thread Deacon Patrick
I think its a bit more complicated that that. Here's a two part post on the topic: http://www.marksdailyapple.com/bone-dating-life-span/#axzz31nmEfCy7 and http://www.marksdailyapple.com/life-expectancy-hunter-gatherer/#axzz31nmEfCy7 And even if you are right about life expectancy, how do you

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-15 Thread Ron Mc
don'f forget reality tv On Thursday, May 15, 2014 11:26:34 AM UTC-5, Deacon Patrick wrote: I think its a bit more complicated that that. Here's a two part post on the topic: http://www.marksdailyapple.com/bone-dating-life-span/#axzz31nmEfCy7 and

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-15 Thread Deacon Patrick
You lost me there, Ron. But no need to delve in further on this. I'm just sharing my experience and what I've learned along the way. I am far more functional because I eat wrong. I'm perfectly happy with that. With abandon, Patrick On Thursday, May 15, 2014 10:31:48 AM UTC-6, Ron Mc wrote:

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-15 Thread Ron Mc
the 67 vs. 35 vs. 20 is actually quite telling. On a planet of 7 billion, where most are still trying to figure out where the next meal is coming from, the current 67 is not skewed by western wealth and medicine, because that skew as you pointed out is balanced in turn by those who eat from

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-15 Thread 'Tony McG' via RBW Owners Bunch
If cavemen were dying at the age of 20, what were they dying of and who was rearing their children? I am 10 lbs heavier than when I put the bicycles away last Fall, but my health is good and I'm still seeing ribs, abs, and veins when I look in the mirror. I cut sugar, grain, phoney fat, and

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-15 Thread Ron Mc
my parents are in their 80s and aren't going to die any time soon, so the encyclopedic data is a stated average life expectancy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Life_expectancy On Thursday, May 15, 2014 4:22:54 PM UTC-5, Tony McG wrote: If cavemen were dying at the age of 20, what were they

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-15 Thread john muhl
Are you actually trying to respond to the post you quote or is this just some sort of Gmail goof? On Thursday, May 15, 2014 4:31:20 PM UTC-5, Ron Mc wrote: my parents are in their 80s and aren't going to die any time soon, so the encyclopedic data is a stated average life expectancy

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-15 Thread Daniel D.
Depends, closer you are to forklift shape, the easier it is to lose weight without sacrificing much. Closer you are to greek god shape, the harder it is to lose weight without sacrificing much. :p On Tuesday, May 13, 2014 2:52:27 PM UTC-7, Deacon Patrick wrote: Loosing weight doesn't have

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-15 Thread Daniel D.
I don't buy any of hemming and hawing over food now a days. Being a normal healthy weight(whatever that means:p) isn't rocket surgery. Now if I wanted six pack abs or a 5 hour century time bad enough, I might have to make some sacrifices and change my diet. But no thanks I'd rather enjoy the

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-14 Thread grrlyrida
That's so true Patrick. I fell in with the CrossFit crowd and decided to cut out sugars and grains. I thought I would have a plateau like most diets and 22 lbs later I'm still losing and will reach my goal of 25 lbs sooner than I expected. I don't have craving for sugar but I have to make

Re: [RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-14 Thread Jim Bronson
Bagels have a ton of calories - I've been trying to stay away from them lately. Portion control is key for me. Doesn't matter so much what I eat but moreso how much of it I eat. Granted, I do try to stay away from red meats and fried foods. I need to weigh myself and see how I've been doing

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-14 Thread Deacon Patrick
No worries! Just drink 100% grass fed cream and you'll be so satiated and happy, you won't need to eat till dinner. If I take any food on a ride (even an all day one), it's a thermos of cream or butter or coconut oil. I don't need anything else. And yes, Patrick, I think you are right. Most

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-13 Thread RJM
Losing weight off the person is easier, cheaper, and more effective at lowering your power needs to make the bike go faster, especially up hill. Here is a video of someone trying to do a sort of scientific test on it. Turns out that being heavier requires much more power to climb (which we all

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-13 Thread Ron Mc
I'm 6'3 and never been 300 lbs.. Was 190 lbs in fighting trim at 19 y-o while running the Marine Corps PAT. I maintain 215, stay active, paddle, wade-fish, eat what I want and pedal it off. I get tired of food Nazis. When someone finds a diet that works for them, they want to apply it to

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-13 Thread Daniel D.
I politely disagree :p On Tuesday, May 13, 2014 4:01:48 AM UTC-7, RJM wrote: Losing weight off the person is easier, -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups RBW Owners Bunch group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-13 Thread Ron Mc
Daniel is right - gaining weight is easy - you simply increase the number of fat cells in your body. Losing weight, however, doesn't decrease the number of fat cells, it simply leans out the existing number of fat cells. So losing weight is tough. On Tuesday, May 13, 2014 11:16:38 AM

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-13 Thread Deacon Patrick
Loosing weight doesn't have to be tough. Never felt hungry once. The weight just came off. With abandon, Patrick On Tuesday, May 13, 2014 3:50:24 PM UTC-6, Ron Mc wrote: Daniel is right - gaining weight is easy - you simply increase the number of fat cells in your body. Losing weight,

Re: [RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-13 Thread Patrick Moore
Not to turn this into a weight loss thread, but: I find that, if I don't keep junk food, particularly snacks, in the house (because my will power is approximately nil, and I'll eat it all on one go), so that I have to eat actual, real food that I have to prepare, be this merely sandwiches prepared

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-12 Thread Tony DeFilippo
As a 250 lb guy riding mostly 30ish pound bikes (+commuting load) I don't get to wrapped up about weight... But I am always intrigued when I heft a light weight bike. Thing is you'll never be able to do side by side testing of a +/-25 lbs 'engine' but it's easy to try a +/-10lb bike/equipment.

Re: [RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-12 Thread Eric Platt
I'm in Tony's camp, both with personal and bike weight. One thing I've noticed does make a difference is tires. Have now had a second, longer ride on the Compass Barlow Pass tires and have noticed that I am faster on my Hillborne with those tires. But that is me. Have a friend who is very

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-12 Thread Eric Peterson
It seems that everyone agrees that losing 25 lbs would be better than lightening the bike by 4 lbs. A different question: If the rider lost 4 lbs would that be equivalent to riding a bike that was 4 lbs lighter? For example, last weekend I rode out 20 miles to pick up two 2-lb jars of honey.

Re: [RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-12 Thread Steve Palincsar
On 05/12/2014 09:54 AM, Eric Peterson wrote: It seems that everyone agrees that losing 25 lbs would be better than lightening the bike by 4 lbs. A different question: If the rider lost 4 lbs would that be equivalent to riding a bike that was 4 lbs lighter? For example, last weekend I rode out

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-12 Thread 'Tony McG' via RBW Owners Bunch
I wish my stoker would lose 25 lbs, but I sure as hell ain't going to tell her so. The Santana is heavy, and I have no plans for trying to make it lighter. I guess I am just going to have to pedal harder... On Sunday, May 11, 2014 1:31:59 PM UTC-5, Michael wrote: Assuming the 1-manpower

Re: [RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-12 Thread Joe Hogg
On 05/12/2014 09:24 AM, 'Tony McG' via RBW Owners Bunch wrote: I wish my stoker would lose 25 lbs, but I sure as hell ain't going to tell her so. The Santana is heavy, and I have no plans for trying to make it lighter. I guess I am just going to have to pedal harder... On Sunday, May 11,

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-12 Thread Iron Rider
I think that reduced body weight makes much more of a difference even lb for lb. Even with no change in strength, reduced body weight increases strength to weight ratio. Lighter body weight increases VO2Max, i.e. results in increased performance. Reduced body weight also requires less

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-12 Thread eflayer
I think what we really need is a people lifter. A contraption that picks the person up with a caliper around your chest area. And once off the ground a robotic voice says, dude you are feeling so light today. you must have lost 50 grams between yesterday and today! love you for that! On Sunday,

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-12 Thread ted
Most likely, perhaps the weight off you would seem a bigger difference for esoteric and dubious reasons. To first order a lb is a lb, be it love handles on you, a jar in a bag, or part of your bike. The siren call of component and frame weight obsession is in close quarters with the lure of

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-12 Thread Michael
The thought that being 25lbs. overweight is like carrying around another bike on you is an eye opening statement. I don't think for a non-racer like me I would benefit from shaving bike weight. I need to ride more and eat less. -- You received this message because you are subscribed to

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-12 Thread IanA
I support you in that ambition! Needing to do the same. On Monday, May 12, 2014 10:56:14 PM UTC-6, Michael wrote: The thought that being 25lbs. overweight is like carrying around another bike on you is an eye opening statement. I don't think for a non-racer like me I would benefit from

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-11 Thread Deacon Patrick
Rework the engine. It's far cheaper and better for your health. I used to weigh nearly 300 pounds. I now weigh 190. I'm now on a full time ketogenic diet (high fat, very low carb). I can ride all day without food and far less water (processing carbs takes a LOT of water). I'm riding string,

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-11 Thread IanA
It's not just weight - it's a ratio of power to weight. If a person is 20lb over-weight, the knock-on of such a condition is often (not always) carrying the weight in the form of fat at the same time as lacking muscle and strength. I hover between 155lb and 175lb, but I only hit 155lb after

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-11 Thread eflayer
On Sunday, May 11, 2014 11:31:59 AM UTC-7, Michael wrote: Assuming the 1-manpower engine stays the same. From time to time I think of shaving weight off bikes and I wonder if it really matters for a non-racer person like me who could stand to lose 25 lbs. I think if I lost the weight it

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-11 Thread eflayer
I could stand to lose 10 lbs and 10 years. I have control over one but not the other. I was out riding my 23 lb New Albion Privateer today. We were flying as best we could. It would have been a bit faster and climbing would have been easier on the 17 lb Specialized Roubaix. I can't quantify

Re: [RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-11 Thread Lyle Bogart
Michael, I must come down on the side of decreasing rider weight whenever possible, provided one is keeping within healthy parameters. If one loses weight through exercise proper diet, then one should also be stronger and fitter for it and this will further improve performance on the bike. I

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-11 Thread dougP
Michael: Your intuition is correct. In addition to improving your cycling, losing 25 lbs will also improve your health. If done right, it's free, vs what it costs to get 4 lbs off a bike. Look at it this way: if you're carrying an extra 25 lbs, that's like lugging another bike around.

[RBW] Re: Losing Bike weight vs. Rider weight. Which one more effectively makes you go faster?

2014-05-11 Thread DS
I've been asking myself the same thing over the last few years. I just lost 20 lbs on a ketogenic diet and definitely noticed an increase in speed throughout the weight loss and afterwards. However, even after the weight loss, I still go faster on my wife's 18 lb carbon road bike than on my 22