Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-12 Thread Patrick Moore
I've told this anecdote many times before, but don't let that stop me. I once carried 50 lb on a Tubus Fly attached to a lightweight -- noticeably lighter than my Riv Roads -- 531 1973 Motobecane Grand Record (brake bridge mounting and the frame had fender eyelets IIRC). It handled such loads

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-12 Thread Chester
On Thursday, February 1, 2024 at 3:42:11 PM UTC-8 Patrick Moore wrote: I used to put my work kit into a shoulder bag and put that bag into my Carradice Camper Longflap; I still don't understand the advantages of a big front basket except that you don't need to undo and re-do straps. Probably

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-07 Thread John Rinker
The marmot abides. On Wednesday, February 7, 2024 at 1:21:18 PM UTC-8 Jacob Kersey wrote: > Nice marmot. > > On Thursday, February 1, 2024 at 7:51:18 PM UTC-8 John Rinker wrote: > >> My pet marmot much prefers to ride in the airy, open basket rather than >> buckled in the dark recesses of my

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-07 Thread Jacob Kersey
Nice marmot. On Thursday, February 1, 2024 at 7:51:18 PM UTC-8 John Rinker wrote: > My pet marmot much prefers to ride in the airy, open basket rather than > buckled in the dark recesses of my Sackville. It's a thing of beauty to > watch the wind whip through her fur and hear the whistle

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-04 Thread Patrick Moore
I do the same thing with all my bikes. I've used VeloRetro musettes tightly wadded up and stuffed in seat wedges -- Chuck Schmidt will do custom photo prints (there's a tech term I forget) and I have Beryl Burton at time-trial speed and I lost Reg Harris in an all-out effort near the finish line)

[RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-04 Thread Chris Halasz
A hack I now use that may be obvious to others on this list for unexpected pop-up bike storage, such as for stopping for one small item at the store and walking out with five or six items: I stow a thin, light, nylon musette-type bag stuffed inside a small bar or saddle bag. That way the

[RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-03 Thread velomann
I've done quite a bit of self-supported touring over the years, mostly solo, and I pretty quickly transitioned away from using a rear rack and rear panniers as soon as I started riding a low-trail 650b bike (my Ocean Air Cycles Rambler, RIP). I don't imagine I'll ever go back now. Both of my

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread Richard Rose
Kai, very interesting. But this pic is beyond category!Sent from my iPhoneOn Feb 2, 2024, at 10:19 PM, Kainalu V. -Brooklyn NY wrote:I’ve got a bike with no top tube, and since there’s no top tube, I think it’s best to load the front so’s to avoid the certain twistability of a step-through. I

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread Patrick Moore
I want to see Keith P's *racing basket!* Patrick "I can live with a racing basket" Moore On Fri, Feb 2, 2024 at 3:04 PM vernon brooks wrote: > I’ve tried out a lot of different set ups with my Atlantis and ultimately > landed on handlebar bag with Mini front rack. Having a basket is nice for

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread vernon brooks
I’ve tried out a lot of different set ups with my Atlantis and ultimately landed on handlebar bag with Mini front rack. Having a basket is nice for hauling stuff around, but I found it feels a little clunky and out of place because I primarily ride drop bars. I am in the process of restoring a

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread Patrick Moore
Photo of Lightning Bolt, please? On Fri, Feb 2, 2024 at 2:54 PM ian m wrote: > No harm no foul. My newest bike is a Crust Lightning Bolt currently > sporting a front basket, wide(ish) drop bars, platform pedals, a leather > saddle, and XTR rapid rise derailer. Everything I want out of a

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread ian m
No harm no foul. My newest bike is a Crust Lightning Bolt currently sporting a front basket, wide(ish) drop bars, platform pedals, a leather saddle, and XTR rapid rise derailer. Everything I want out of a road(ish) bike. On Friday, February 2, 2024 at 4:00:48 PM UTC-5 Patrick Moore wrote: >

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread Patrick Moore
Good point; I was thinking about bar type and position and rider position in this preference equation. While I do all my grocery shopping by bike, I rarely carry 50 lb of of stuff and when I do I have front lowriders and a smaller pair of Ortliebs for those. A good balance is 30-35 rear and 15-20

[RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread Bill Lindsay
Any reply from me would be mostly irrelevant because of the OP use case: carrying 50 pounds of groceries. I never (never) carry 50 pounds of groceries on a bicycle. I do often carry 1-5 pounds of stuff on general bicycle errands. Sometimes I take bike parts down to the post office to mail

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread EGNolan
In my experience, as handlebars get higher and closer to the rider the better some weight in a basket works. The dual effect of reducing front end weight (lightening the front wheel & feel) AND increasing body weight on the rear end of the bike makes a front load seem ideal. If you ride drops,

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread John Rinker
Patrick, Lovely photo of the flowers in the panniers. This discussion, like many about human preferences, it's so much about our habits and that to which we've become accustomed. An argument can be made that flowers are better carried in a front basket so the rider can enjoy both the view,

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread Chris Halasz
I concur with Patrick's assessment for his criteria. Popping off and on a set of Ortliebs is so quick and clean, and they carry so much, and roll up so nicely, and the handy shoulder straps make them great for shopping, farmer's market or otherwise. As for weight, our little ten-pound Dorkie

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread Shoji Takahashi
I, too, have tried many iterations. My go-to for my commute is saddlesack and front basket. I can fit almost all my stuff in the saddlesack. The front basket is for taking off my jacket or occasional stops to the library or grocery. When I've ridden in and stopped at a place where I'm not

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread Brian Turner
I think a bike looks and feels incredibly unbalanced with just two big stuffed rear panniers. Like many here have stated, the super noodly rear-end just isn't desirable. And, if you're carrying so much stuff that you're filling two big panniers, why not balance the load a bit more and carry

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-02 Thread m f
I like using the front for my gear because it just seems a bit easier to mount/dismount the bike in that configuration. Rear panniers have a time and place, but just not for 99% of my riding. Hey acksf78...Tell me you're on Instagram without telling me :) *I have tried it all and I will never

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-01 Thread Armand Kizirian
Best is both worlds! A 137 up front with either my swift sugarloaf or shopsack and 1 or 2 panniers in the rear. About all one could ask for with nearly all day-long commuting or utilitarian purposes. I scored the most recent version of an Ortlieb Vario off eBay. That has been the ultimate

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-01 Thread Brenton Eastman
If you ever want to bike-pack and go somewhere remote or accessible via single track, having your luggage up in a basket, frame bag, saddlebag, avoids the risk of catching a pannier (or both) on roots, branches, downed trees cut just wide enough for passage, etc. I learned this the hard way on

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-01 Thread Neale S.
One reason to put some weight on the front of the bike is that all of your (body) weight is mostly on the rear already. On Thursday, February 1, 2024 at 5:26:41 PM UTC-8 Stephen wrote: > I have basically the same reasoning as Ian, and also live in a city and > dont want to leave bags on my bike

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-01 Thread Stephen
I have basically the same reasoning as Ian, and also live in a city and dont want to leave bags on my bike when I lock up, plus i like my daily bag to not look too bikey (I use the shopsacks). Convenient and easy, easier to pile up with whatever shit i want, take a jacket or sweater off if i

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-01 Thread Patrick Moore
IMO, baggage ought to complement the handling characteristics of the bicycle. My benchmark idea of handling has been formed by 30 years of riding Rivendells which, IME, do best with rear loads, or at least loads biased toward the rear and not the front. On Thu, Feb 1, 2024 at 5:18 PM ian m

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-01 Thread ian m
I'm not sure how it makes more sense to put a bag into another bag than into a basket, but to each their own. My perspective probably comes from living in the Bay Area where I refused to leave anything attached to my bike that didn't look like a part of the bike or was easily removable, far

Re: [RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-01 Thread Patrick Moore
I used to put my work kit into a shoulder bag and put that bag into my Carradice Camper Longflap; I still don't understand the advantages of a big front basket except that you don't need to undo and re-do straps. On Thu, Feb 1, 2024 at 4:31 PM ian m wrote: > Short and sweet answer: I can put a

[RBW] Re: Why baskets and front bags instead of rear panniers or perfect Rivendell saddlebags?

2024-02-01 Thread ian m
Short and sweet answer: I can put a bag in my basket and take it with me when I'm off the bike. On Thursday, February 1, 2024 at 5:18:59 PM UTC-5 Patrick Moore wrote: > I'm curious why so many Rivendell-listers prefer baskets to rear > saddlebags or panniers -- saddlebags in particular