[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2018-02-19 Thread Sky Coulter
Thanks for the suggestion Rich. I did consider pauls, but I wanted to keep it a super easy brake setup. Mike Varley had an article about brake clearances that I cam across ( http://blackmtncycles.com/clearance-pt-ii-road-frames/ ) and from the images in it, it looked like the shimanos ought

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2018-02-19 Thread RichS
Sky, If you can swing it, Paul centerpulls for your Romulus would give you the fender clearance you’re looking for. Just completed a Roadeo and installed the Paul CPs. They are as nicely performing as others on the list have noted from time to time. Regards, Richard -- You received this

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2018-02-17 Thread Sky Coulter
Bold thoughts Clayton. But I think I’m closing in on what works for me through slow refinement. The short-lived, sti-shifting, disc-brake-having sequoia was a good lesson for me in that sense. It might be fundamentally boring, but what I like most are Rivendell bikes. I don’t really see a

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2018-02-17 Thread Clayton.sf
sell them all, get something different, experience, enjoy the journey, life is short. Clayton Scott SF, CA -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "RBW Owners Bunch" group. To unsubscribe from this group and stop receiving emails from it, send an email to

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2018-02-17 Thread Max S
Sky, that's a really nice Joe Appaloosa set-up! I don't see many of them set up with drop bars, perhaps due to the longer TT. But if one decides that a long seatpost is OK, and takes into account the upsloping TT... I could see it working really well to get the bars level with or a bit lower

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2018-02-17 Thread Sky Coulter
Hi Max, I sold the bombadil frameset to another lister and the specialized sequoia at a pretty steep loss on craigslist. I bought the 55cm appa and it worked out great using the stack and reach numbers to choose size. I think the appaloosa is as nice as my saluki in general, with a

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2018-02-17 Thread Max S
So, how'd it all turn out?.. (It's the long dark teatime of the soul here in MI right now, so I'm trying really hard to not compensate for my lack of riding by purchasing bike stuff.) - Max On Sunday, March 19, 2017 at 10:49:15 AM UTC-4, Sky Coulter wrote: > > Thanks Max, good advice if a

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-19 Thread Bob Lovejoy
And thank you Sky for letting people into the thought process! That and for showing us some very cool bikes. I do like the way you think - and the way you choose and use your bikes. Do let people know if you decide to go the Appaloosa route or another direction. > > To great rides and

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-19 Thread Sky Coulter
Thanks Max, good advice if a bit hard to take. Well, thanks for the thoughts everyone. I think the bombadil will probably end up for sale. Not sure beyond that at the moment. If I'm gonna sell any of them on the list though, I'll create a new post with more info (prices, builds, etc). Thanks

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Max S
I think I can relate to your original comment about freeing up mental space, which is at a premium for me, so going N-1 offers considerable merit, IMO. Also, I recently read Mari Kondo. And if pretending to be you, I would do this: - Find a good new home for the Bomba - Find a new home for the

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread scott
Touring bikes suffer from the pick-up truck syndrome. Some folks buy them for the potential of hauling a lot, but the actual amount they get used for the intended purpose is not worth the expense (both trucks and bikes). Your other bikes will probably suit light touring duty. When you are ready

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Sky Coulter
Thanks Ryan. Ya, I'm not completely fixated on the Appaloosa. Just a riv that I can use for touring. If it could double as a mtb and take drops, that'd be about perfect. If I had a spare 3500 I'd be trying to convince Pudge to part with his Atlantis...or I'd be happy to go w a 56cm

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Ryan Fleming
I'd have a tough time dumping a Riv since I love all of them...but in your situation maybe it's time to move the Bomba since the fit's not ideal. And keep an open mind for the N+1 ...I suspect it would be nice to test ride the Appaloosa. You have an elegant stable BTW On Thursday, March 16,

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread iamkeith
I guess i glossed over the part about wanting to use drop bars. Given that, the smaller joe might make sense than the hunq. For some reason (based on nothing but speculation) I don't think of the joe as a drop bar bike. For what it's worth, i'm an n+1 guy too, and the thing that has so far

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread stevef
I used to have a lot of overlapping bikes in my herd and I sold off more than half. It wasn't easy but it was rewarding. The simplicity of having fewer bike to maintain and store is pretty great. They were all nice bikes that I appreciated but once I decided some had to go, it was pretty

Re: [RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Jim Bronson
I agree with Leaf Slayer, sell the Bombadil and Sequoia. Of course, I'm the guy who keeps bikes just for the sake of keeping them, that I never ride. I have 3 that should leave, really: my mountain bike from college (25 years ago) that's way too small, my tandem that is way too small, and my

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Leaf Slayer
Sell the Bombadil and Sequoia. A few years back I sold off the last of my Rivs, an AHH to make room for and fund a mountain bike. I don't regret that move. This may sound crazy, but my LHT was the bike I wish my AHH was. I had previously sold off my Rambouilet and Quickbeam. About a year before

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Bob Lovejoy
No, I know *exactly* the feeling as I am making the same decisions. But agreed on the paint option and all for any of the bikes. But still I look, envision, study, imagine... I will admit the silver Appaloosa's call to me as well. Bob On Friday, March 17, 2017 at 7:28:02 AM UTC-5, Sky

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Sky Coulter
He pretty much said that either would work out, but he thought the 58 was the more appropriate size. He did suggest that the bar height between the 55 appa and the 60saluki would be about the same, but didn't offer much more in the way of specifics. I don't think there are any appas in BC at

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Bob Lovejoy
Not that I am a role model for patience, but there is some wisdom here... That said, I truly understand the timing and the lure. Sky - Would there be any chance for you to find and ride a 55cm Appaloosa, just to verify the numbers with actual? I study the numbers too, and believe in them

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Sky Coulter
Keith, I don't see why the joe would be too small. Comparing the stack and reach numbers the appa would get the handlebars up higher and it would have a shorter reach to the bars - which i think would work well for drops. Is there something I'm missing? Thanks, Sky On Friday, March 17,

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Ron Mc
pick two, offer up both, see which bites, and let the interest of others decide for you On Friday, March 17, 2017 at 6:40:53 AM UTC-5, Deacon Patrick wrote: > > Cultivate contentment? > > With abandon, > Patrick > > On Thursday, March 16, 2017 at 7:45:54 PM UTC-6, Sky Coulter wrote: >> >> >> I

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Sky Coulter
Oh, I plan to Patrick. It's just that clearly contentment is just around the next corner, or in this case, in the saddle of n+1. But ya, of course. That would be the truly wise choicesky On Friday, March 17, 2017 at 4:40:53 AM UTC-7, Deacon Patrick wrote: > > Cultivate contentment? > > With

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Deacon Patrick
Cultivate contentment? With abandon, Patrick On Thursday, March 16, 2017 at 7:45:54 PM UTC-6, Sky Coulter wrote: > > > I have a bunch of bikes, with a fair bit of overlap, and yet I find myself > lusting after n+1. > -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Sky Coulter
oops, i meant 391.7 not 381.7 for reach On Thursday, March 16, 2017 at 8:53:10 PM UTC-7, Sky Coulter wrote: > > I don't really know for sure if the appa will work w drops, but i think it > will, otherwise i prolly wouldn't be interested in it. The other rivendell > option would be a 61cm

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Sky Coulter
Hi Mark, thanks for the thoughts. Ya actually, some part of it is the thrill of a new bike for sure. And I do love the silver-cream colour combo. But I guess the "reason" I want the appa is for touring. Not that I'm likely to get away for more than a couple days anytime in the next couple

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Sky Coulter
Thanks for your advice Chris. Ya, you're right. The size problem can't be corrected so moving it on is the right choicesky On Thursday, March 16, 2017 at 9:27:30 PM UTC-7, Christopher Murray wrote: > > Sell the Bomba and keep the rest. It sounds like you know this is the best > option but

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-17 Thread Sky Coulter
Thanks Tony, I appreciate your comments. Ya, I think the 56cm bomba would have been a better fit for me too. I think there is a consensus building pretty quickly that the bomba should go and that the romulus should be next in line. I can't really think of much more that I'd want to tweak

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-16 Thread 'Mark in Beacon' via RBW Owners Bunch
What are you expecting from the Appaloosa that you are not getting from your current bicycles? If it's the thrill of a new bike, a silver paint job, that's fine. But realize you will probably be in the same situation a year from now. My advice would be sell the Bombadil and put the money in a

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-16 Thread Christopher Murray
Sell the Bomba and keep the rest. It sounds like you know this is the best option but the price you'd likely get for the Bomba vs the price of the Appaloosa is stopping you. I'd sell the Bomba complete and buy a complete Appaloosa. Take off the parts you don't want and sell them. From your

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-16 Thread Tony DeFilippo
You've got good 'problems'! :) Great photo's and really gorgeous builds and bikes. And you and I are about the same size... I've also got a 60cm Saluki which is the jewel in my collection and recently sold a 56 Bombadil. I've never ridden a 60 Bombadil but given the fit of the 56 I don't

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-16 Thread Sky Coulter
I don't really know for sure if the appa will work w drops, but i think it will, otherwise i prolly wouldn't be interested in it. The other rivendell option would be a 61cm atlantis. The stack and reach numbers b/w it and the 55cm appa are pretty similar. But if those numbers are similar,

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-16 Thread Valerie Yates
Well, you don't sound too reluctant to see the Bombadil, so that's something. I wonder if a drop bar Appaloosa will make you happy. Has anyone been happy with that set-up? I love mine but feels very clearly an upright style bike. I feel on top of the world and can see forever when I ride it.

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-16 Thread Sky Coulter
Thanks Bob, Good advice. I took the AWOL for a quick spin too. I really quite liked it. But i felt a bit more comfortably stretched out on the sequoia, although i quite liked the improved clearance on the AWOL. Sky in new west -- You received this message because you are subscribed to the

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-16 Thread Sky Coulter
Val, Thanks for the input. What u say is wise. Once gone a bike is gone. But i have found a reluctance to sell every bike i've ever sold. So sometimes i worry it's more a hoarder tendency than a true love. And though you're right, the sequoia hasn't made my heart sing, it took me a while to

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-16 Thread Bob Lovejoy
Sky, It seems we live in parallel universes, except yours is a lot , LOT, nicer! You have chosen well... I do agree with Erl's recommendation on selling the Bombadil as that should cover Appaloosa costs. That, and the Appa, set up the way you are intending, with drops and all, might be a

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-16 Thread Valerie Yates
Fun question. It sounds to me like you'd be happiest selling the Bombadi because it is too big for the kind of riding you'd like to do with it and the Sequoia because you don't love it. I would not sell a bike I love even if overlaps with something else. You love the Romulus so I don't see why

[RBW] Re: Advice on herd thinning (or, scheming to get another bike)

2017-03-16 Thread Sky Coulter
Thanks Erl..that's a plan I hadn't considered...sky On Thursday, March 16, 2017 at 7:03:12 PM UTC-7, WETH wrote: > > Sky, > I'll get things started. If I were you, I'd sell the Bombadil as a > complete package to fund the Appaloosa. I'd then move the Romulus' > components to the Appaloosa and