Re: KDE Gear: add Kalm
El dimarts, 16 d’abril del 2024, a les 0:56:57 (CEST), Heiko Becker va escriure: > On Sunday, 14 April 2024 23:48:37 CEST, Albert Astals Cid wrote: > > El dimecres, 27 de març del 2024, a les 9:23:54 (CEST), Plata va escriure: > >> Generally, I think the reasoning makes sense. However, in the case of > >> Kalm, I don't think it's required. If you look at the app, it's pretty > >> simplistic (intentionally, due to its purpose). > >> > >> Therefore, I would prefer to just get it out to the public to > >> eventually ... > > > > The dependency freeze for KDE Gear 24.05 is this thursday, it > > would be good if > > we get some tie breaking comment here so far we have two votes (the person > > proposing it for yes "obvious, so only gets 0.5 value for yes") > > and (me voting > > 0.5 against). > > To be honest, I don't feel very decisive about this one. For me it seems > even a tad too simple for monthly releases. On the other hand, it doesn't > have any insane dependencies and is well behaved, so in absence of other > rules I'll add my +0.1. Ok, so with your 0.1 the answer, this is a "yes" and I've added it to the release. Cheers, Albert > > Regards, > Heiko
Re: KDE Gear: add Kalm
On Sunday, 14 April 2024 23:48:37 CEST, Albert Astals Cid wrote: El dimecres, 27 de març del 2024, a les 9:23:54 (CEST), Plata va escriure: Generally, I think the reasoning makes sense. However, in the case of Kalm, I don't think it's required. If you look at the app, it's pretty simplistic (intentionally, due to its purpose). Therefore, I would prefer to just get it out to the public to eventually ... The dependency freeze for KDE Gear 24.05 is this thursday, it would be good if we get some tie breaking comment here so far we have two votes (the person proposing it for yes "obvious, so only gets 0.5 value for yes") and (me voting 0.5 against). To be honest, I don't feel very decisive about this one. For me it seems even a tad too simple for monthly releases. On the other hand, it doesn't have any insane dependencies and is well behaved, so in absence of other rules I'll add my +0.1. Regards, Heiko
Re: KDE Gear: add Kalm
El dimecres, 27 de març del 2024, a les 9:23:54 (CEST), Plata va escriure: > Thanks for the feedback! > > > Generally, I think the reasoning makes sense. However, in the case of > Kalm, I don't think it's required. If you look at the app, it's pretty > simplistic (intentionally, due to its purpose). > > Therefore, I would prefer to just get it out to the public to eventually > get some feedback. I think it's pretty unlikely that anybody will notice > it if I just create a release myself. The dependency freeze for KDE Gear 24.05 is this thursday, it would be good if we get some tie breaking comment here so far we have two votes (the person proposing it for yes "obvious, so only gets 0.5 value for yes") and (me voting 0.5 against). Cheers, Albert > > > El dilluns, 25 de març de 2024, a les 8:10:43 (CET), Plata va escriure: > >> Dear Release Team, > >> > >> > >> Kalm has spent some time in KDE Review (see > >> https://invent.kde.org/utilities/kalm/-/issues/2). Can we add it > >> to/release it in KDE Gear? > > > > As far as I understand Kalm has never been released, right? > > > > For new apps *personally* I always suggest to do a few releases on your > > own > > because it allows for much faster feature turn-around than KDE Gear that > > has a very strict 3 months for new features schedule, that is usually > > fine for "established" apps but for something new you may very well find > > that there's that obvious feature missing that everyone needs and now you > > can't add it until 3 months in the future. > > > > Cheers, > > > >Albert > >> > >> Best regards > >> > >> Plata > >> > >> P.S.: CC me on the answers, I'm not subscribed
Re: KDE Gear: add Kalm
Thanks for the feedback! Generally, I think the reasoning makes sense. However, in the case of Kalm, I don't think it's required. If you look at the app, it's pretty simplistic (intentionally, due to its purpose). Therefore, I would prefer to just get it out to the public to eventually get some feedback. I think it's pretty unlikely that anybody will notice it if I just create a release myself. El dilluns, 25 de març de 2024, a les 8:10:43 (CET), Plata va escriure: Dear Release Team, Kalm has spent some time in KDE Review (see https://invent.kde.org/utilities/kalm/-/issues/2). Can we add it to/release it in KDE Gear? As far as I understand Kalm has never been released, right? For new apps *personally* I always suggest to do a few releases on your own because it allows for much faster feature turn-around than KDE Gear that has a very strict 3 months for new features schedule, that is usually fine for "established" apps but for something new you may very well find that there's that obvious feature missing that everyone needs and now you can't add it until 3 months in the future. Cheers, Albert Best regards Plata P.S.: CC me on the answers, I'm not subscribed
Re: KDE Gear: add Kalm
El dilluns, 25 de març de 2024, a les 8:10:43 (CET), Plata va escriure: > Dear Release Team, > > > Kalm has spent some time in KDE Review (see > https://invent.kde.org/utilities/kalm/-/issues/2). Can we add it > to/release it in KDE Gear? As far as I understand Kalm has never been released, right? For new apps *personally* I always suggest to do a few releases on your own because it allows for much faster feature turn-around than KDE Gear that has a very strict 3 months for new features schedule, that is usually fine for "established" apps but for something new you may very well find that there's that obvious feature missing that everyone needs and now you can't add it until 3 months in the future. Cheers, Albert > > Best regards > > Plata > > P.S.: CC me on the answers, I'm not subscribed
KDE Gear: add Kalm
Dear Release Team, Kalm has spent some time in KDE Review (see https://invent.kde.org/utilities/kalm/-/issues/2). Can we add it to/release it in KDE Gear? Best regards Plata P.S.: CC me on the answers, I'm not subscribed
