Re: [Resin-interest] Resin V Glassfish

2009-11-30 Thread Daniel López
Hi, From my personal point of view, I prefer Resin because its philosophy suits me better as it is more open and flexible, meaning it usually accomodates different ways of doing things. OTOH, GlassFish is for me more opinionated and it tries to guide you on how you should do things, so if

Re: [Resin-interest] Resin V Glassfish

2009-11-28 Thread Kai Virkki
Well, JBoss already has a CDI implementation called Weld, so Resin really isn't exceptional in this account. CDI is actually based on JBoss Seam and Google Guice. Cheers, -Kai On 27.11.2009, at 12.10, Wesley Wu wumen...@gmail.com wrote: As long as Scott continue to work for the Resin's

Re: [Resin-interest] Resin V Glassfish

2009-11-28 Thread Wesley Wu
Yes, congratulations to Gavin King. Competition is a good thing. I think Scott will produce products with less bugs or we'll change to Weld :) 2009/11/28 Kai Virkki kai.vir...@gmail.com Well, JBoss already has a CDI implementation called Weld, so Resin really isn't exceptional in this

[Resin-interest] Resin V Glassfish

2009-11-26 Thread Stavros Stavrakis
Hi All, We have had in-house Java based systems running on resin for many years now (since 2001). A few newer developers have thrown out the suggestion to switch to Glassfish V3. I am looking for justifications of why we should remain with Resin or switch to Glassfish. Is there anyone out

Re: [Resin-interest] Resin V Glassfish

2009-11-26 Thread Alan Wright
Hi Stavros Glassfish may be great - but even if it was technically and performance comparable to Resin I would be wary about adopting it as a free alternative because I am reassured to know that Resin is Caucho's bread and butter core business. Scott and his team will stand behind it but I