Re: systemd tftp xinetd

2018-09-11 Thread R P Herrold
On Tue, 11 Sep 2018, Ken Teh wrote: > I've done all that. But after I reboot the system, I cannot tftp a file from > the server. But if I start tftp.service manually, I can get the file. There may be permissions problems and more in play -- BUT you are trying to 'jump ahead' --- FIRST,

Re: systemd tftp xinetd

2018-09-11 Thread Ken Teh
I finally figured out my problem. (1) You don't need xinetd. The tftp-server package is enough. Iow, systemd supersedes xinetd. (2) Although the tftp-server rpm installs /etc/xinetd.d/tftp, there is no need to change `disable = yes` in this file. (3) The command `systemctl enable tftp`

Re: [SCIENTIFIC-LINUX-USERS] systemd tftp xinetd

2018-09-11 Thread Jose Marques
> On 11 Sep 2018, at 15:30, Ken Teh wrote: > > Manually, I can start the service and everything works. But enabling the > service stays disabled or indirect. Enabling the socket does not start the > service on reboot. Do I need xinetd or does systemd deprecate xinetd? I re-installed out TFTP

Re: systemd tftp xinetd

2018-09-11 Thread Paddy Doyle
On Tue, Sep 11, 2018 at 10:24:32AM -0500, Ken Teh wrote: > I've done all that. But after I reboot the system, I cannot tftp a file > from the server. But if I start tftp.service manually, I can get the file. > > If a service is never available on reboot after you've enabled it, what does >

Re: systemd tftp xinetd

2018-09-11 Thread Mark Stodola
On 09/11/2018 09:48 AM, Ken Teh wrote: What you described works manually. Basically, the service is not started on reboot even though I've enabled it. So I don't know what 'enabling' a service means. Since tftp-server installs /etc/xinetd.d/tftp, is it hinting that it should be started via

Re: systemd tftp xinetd

2018-09-11 Thread Ken Teh
I've done all that. But after I reboot the system, I cannot tftp a file from the server. But if I start tftp.service manually, I can get the file. If a service is never available on reboot after you've enabled it, what does 'systemctl enable' mean? Is there some magic sequence of steps I

Re: [EXTERNAL] Re: systemd tftp xinetd

2018-09-11 Thread O'Neal, Miles
I have only used tftp via xinetd. I'd try that. On 09/11/2018 09:48 AM, Ken Teh wrote: What you described works manually. Basically, the service is not started on reboot even though I've enabled it. So I don't know what 'enabling' a service means. Since tftp-server installs

systemd tftp xinetd

2018-09-11 Thread R P Herrold
On Tue, 11 Sep 2018, Ken Teh wrote: > I need help with how to enable tftp service. I am trying to > get something done and I have no patience for systemd's > convoluted logic. Time then, to retire from modern Unix, perhaps. Change and the tide of systemd will not be reversing > The

Re: systemd tftp xinetd

2018-09-11 Thread Ken Teh
What you described works manually. Basically, the service is not started on reboot even though I've enabled it. So I don't know what 'enabling' a service means. Since tftp-server installs /etc/xinetd.d/tftp, is it hinting that it should be started via xinetd? Do I need to install xinetd or

Re: systemd tftp xinetd

2018-09-11 Thread Hinz, David (GE Healthcare)
If you're asking what I think you're asking: systemctl enable tftp # This adds a symlink for tftp into the (target? Milestone? One of those), equivalent to saying "/etc/rc2.d is done, now let's go to rc3.d". systemctl start tftp # This tries to start it systemctl status tftp # This gives you

systemd tftp xinetd

2018-09-11 Thread Ken Teh
I need help with how to enable tftp service. I am trying to get something done and I have no patience for systemd's convoluted logic. The tftp-server installs (1) /etc/xinetd.d/tftp (2) tftp.socket (what's this?) (3) tftp.service Manually, I can start the service and everything works. But