Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Jacques Lema
The auth mechanism works very well and I don't want to change anything to it. The only thing missing is the ability to advertise that AUTH is available _also_ to trusted hosts. The behaviour currently is that if the host is trusted (127.0.0.1 typically) james hides it's ability to receive auth

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Danny Angus
> What I would like is: > a) be able to send a mail from localhost without authentication > b) be able to send a mail from localhost (precisely from a > spam-filtering proxy such as ASSP) _with_ authentication. As I understood it advertising AUTH supported is equivalet to requiring auth, are y

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Jacques Lema
Let me explain :-) I don't want to _require_ authentication. I want it to be a possibility. What I would like is: a) be able to send a mail from localhost without authentication b) be able to send a mail from localhost (precisely from a spam-filtering proxy such as ASSP) _with_ authentication. No

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Danny Angus
> At this point I have to chose between > authentication working through a local proxy or allowing localhost to > send mail. You asked for authentication to be required for localhost, you can't ask for it not to be required at the same time! d. ***

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Jacques Lema
No it wouldn't. Imagine I would like to send mail from localhost without authentication? I just can't. At this point I have to chose between authentication working through a local proxy or allowing localhost to send mail. Vincenzo Gianferrari Pini wrote: But wouldn't it be totally equivalent to

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Vincenzo Gianferrari Pini
But wouldn't it be totally equivalent to commenting out such option? Vincenzo Jacques Lema wrote: Yes, of course I actually fixed the problem for me by commenting this line since this exact server doesn't really need to allow localhost to send mail. However I think it would be a nice addition to

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Jacques Lema
Yes, of course I actually fixed the problem for me by commenting this line since this exact server doesn't really need to allow localhost to send mail. However I think it would be a nice addition to have an option to force always showing the AUTH capability. I am not familiar with james source

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Vincenzo Gianferrari Pini
Danny Angus wrote: The result? The connection issued by ASSP comes from 127.0.0.1 which is an authorized address, for obvious reasons. As a consequences james answer to isAuthorized() is Yes, which causes it not to display the 250 auth login message and therefore causes thunderbird not to use au

Re: Missing Option AuthRequiredForAllIPs

2004-07-28 Thread Danny Angus
> The result? > The connection issued by ASSP comes from 127.0.0.1 which is an > authorized address, for obvious reasons. As a consequences james answer > to isAuthorized() is Yes, which causes it not to display the 250 auth > login message and therefore causes thunderbird not to use auth. I th