Re: [silk] Can you separate tradition and culture from religion?

2012-07-29 Thread ss
On Saturday 28 Jul 2012 11:46:30 am Charles Haynes wrote: African Christianity is very different from European Christianity which in turn is very different from South American Christianity. Tibetan Buddhism is very different from Japanese Buddhism which is very different from Sri Lankan

Re: [silk] Can you separate tradition and culture from religion?

2012-07-28 Thread Charles Haynes
On Jul 28, 2012 3:35 AM, ss cybers...@gmail.com wrote: On Friday 27 Jul 2012 5:23:53 am Shoba Narayan wrote: What will Indian culture (or any culture) be like without religion? I am not sure that I should reply to this because it typically launches me off on one of my rambles. Religion

Re: [silk] Can you separate tradition and culture from religion?

2012-07-28 Thread Charles Haynes
To expand slightly, I interpret religion is never culture to assert that religion and culture are orthogonal - independent of each other. (I am ignoring the islamophobic attempt at 'othering' Islam.) For this to be true, culture would not affect religion and religion would not affect culture.

Re: [silk] Can you separate tradition and culture from religion?

2012-07-28 Thread ashok _
On Sat, Jul 28, 2012 at 3:34 AM, ss cybers...@gmail.com wrote: On Friday 27 Jul 2012 5:23:53 am Shoba Narayan wrote: What will Indian culture (or any culture) be like without religion? I am not sure that I should reply to this because it typically launches me off on one of my rambles.

Re: [silk] Can you separate tradition and culture from religion?

2012-07-28 Thread Charles Haynes
On Jul 28, 2012 3:36 PM, ashok _ listmans...@gmail.com wrote: I think religion is always cultural ... i remember traveling in tanzania years ago and the southern region bordering mozambique has the yao people who practice their brand of islam (they dont eat pork, they pray five times a day

Re: [silk] Can you separate tradition and culture from religion?

2012-07-27 Thread ss
On Friday 27 Jul 2012 5:23:53 am Shoba Narayan wrote: What will Indian culture (or any culture) be like without religion? I am not sure that I should reply to this because it typically launches me off on one of my rambles. Religion is never culture. The exception in my view is Arab culture.

[silk] Can you separate tradition and culture from religion?

2012-07-26 Thread Shoba Narayan
On Wednesday 25 Jul 2012 3:43:06 pm Deepa Mohan wrote: Sorry for top-posting, but it is Rahu Kalam ot the moon is looking at Jupiter or something like that. Not to mention the fact that Ashaada the inauspicious month is just over and you still haven't recovered. I find a curious

Re: [silk] Can you separate tradition and culture from religion?

2012-07-26 Thread Thaths
On Thu, Jul 26, 2012 at 4:53 PM, Shoba Narayan sh...@shobanarayan.comwrote: I find a curious disjointedness between my generation and my parents'. The things that mean a lot to my mother's generation, for instance, like Varalakshmi Puja, doesn't seem to resonate so much with mine. Indeed,

Re: [silk] Can you separate tradition and culture from religion?

2012-07-26 Thread Suresh Ramasubramanian
it either. So.. That said, I seriously doubt that my daughter, or either of my nieces will know or care about patthu --srs (HTC One X) - Reply message - From: Thaths tha...@gmail.com To: silklist@lists.hserus.net Subject: [silk] Can you separate tradition and culture from religion? Date

Re: [silk] Can you separate tradition and culture from religion?

2012-07-26 Thread Aditya Chadha
On Thu, Jul 26, 2012 at 7:53 PM, Shoba Narayan sh...@shobanarayan.com wrote: [snip] I find a curious disjointedness between my generation and my parents'. The things that mean a lot to my mother's generation, for instance, like Varalakshmi Puja, doesn't seem to resonate so much with mine.

Re: [silk] Can you separate tradition and culture from religion?

2012-07-26 Thread Deepa Mohan
On Fri, Jul 27, 2012 at 5:23 AM, Shoba Narayan sh...@shobanarayan.com wrote: On Wednesday 25 Jul 2012 3:43:06 pm Deepa Mohan wrote: What will Indian culture (or any culture) be like without religion? I think there will always be a kind of transition, so there will be enough people believing in