[Simile-Widgets] Re: Exhibit: Is it possible to select an exclusionary filter?

2009-11-15 Thread lbjvg
Thanks David (H K) - I haven't worked with collections before - thanks for bringing them to my attention. My big idea was to - on the fly - have the user be able to exclude any color listed - as if red in the div's above were replaced with a variable that could change on the user's whim. So,

[Simile-Widgets] Re: Exhibit: Is it possible to select an exclusionary filter?

2009-11-15 Thread David Karger
I can't really follow your second paragraph as I don't see the logic of including something red when not-red is selected. But, in regard to your first paragraph, I think you get what you want by just preselecting all facet values, and allowing the user to _uncheck_ red if they want to exclude

[Simile-Widgets] Re: Exhibit: Is it possible to select an exclusionary filter?

2009-11-15 Thread lbjvg
David - You are right about the illogic of the second paragraph - that is a major criticism of that approach. But I don't think selecting all and deselecting say red works any differently. I put together a sample database and html to illustrate: So all five colors start off selected and all

[Simile-Widgets] Re: Exhibit: Is it possible to select an exclusionary filter?

2009-11-15 Thread lbjvg
David - You are right about the illogic of the second paragraph - that is a major criticism of that approach. But I don't think selecting all and deselecting say red works any differently. I put together a sample database and html to illustrate: So all five colors start off selected and all

[Simile-Widgets] Re: Exhibit: Is it possible to select an exclusionary filter?

2009-11-15 Thread lbjvg
David - Thank you for further clarifying the issue. I suppose that including the ability to add a NOT operation adds SQL levels of complexity that sort of defeat the whole point of Exhibit. Thanks for the interesting discussion. - Jim --~--~-~--~~~---~--~~ You

[Simile-Widgets] Re: Exhibit: Is it possible to select an exclusionary filter?

2009-11-15 Thread David Huynh
lbjvg wrote: David - Thank you for further clarifying the issue. I suppose that including the ability to add a NOT operation adds SQL levels of complexity that sort of defeat the whole point of Exhibit. Thanks for the interesting discussion. - Jim You could also create a new kind of

[Simile-Widgets] Re: Exhibit: Is it possible to select an exclusionary filter?

2009-11-15 Thread David Karger
perhaps we could introduce an ex:negate=true attribute to the facet tag, if only we could figure out which negation semantics we wanted. One is for the checked values to denote the ones you are _not_ asking for---essentially, to invert the role of checked/not checked in the facet.