Re: [Softwires] MAP-T Status

2014-05-19 Thread Edwin Cordeiro
that they will bother fixing the problem with the specification, the specification might be labeled an Experimental RFC. BR, Edwin Cordeiro NIC.br Em 19/05/14 14:04, Petersen, Matt J escreveu: This may be a silly question or a lack of my understanding, but why an experimental RFC over just a Standard RFC

[Softwires] Fwd: New Version Notification for draft-cordeiro-softwire-experience-mapt-02.txt

2013-09-26 Thread Edwin Cordeiro
Hi all, I'd like your feedback about the draft. I'd also wanted the feedback if this draft should be adopted by the group, moved to another group or proceed as an individual submission. Thanks, Edwin Cordeiro NIC.br Mensagem original Assunto:New Version Notification

Re: [Softwires] Call for adoption of draft-cai-softwire-6rd-mib-05 as wg draft

2013-07-31 Thread Edwin Cordeiro
I reviewed this draft and support it's adoption. Some comments about it: - I believe there is a typo error: typed sixRdSecurityCeck instead of sixRdSecurityCheck all over the draft - In the introduction, shouldn't it be explicit that this same MIB supports both CPE and BR? Regards, Edwin Em

Re: [Softwires] Call for agenda in IETF 87

2013-07-10 Thread Edwin Cordeiro
Hi, I'd like to request a slot: Edwin Cordeiro Experience from MAP-T Testing http://tools.ietf.org/html/draft-cordeiro-softwire-experience-mapt-01 10 minutes Thanks, Edwin Cordeiro IPv6 Evangelist NIC.br Em 09/07/13 07:54, Yong Cui escreveu: Hi folks, We will have our Softwires session

Re: [Softwires] Result from the consensus call on Map vs 4rd-U and official way forward

2012-04-26 Thread Edwin Cordeiro
happened with 6rd. If this code already exist, please make it public so it could be verified. Edwin Cordeiro Em 26-04-2012 06:50, Mark Townsley escreveu: Because of the history of MAP and 4rd-U, we will designate independent teams of volunteer reviewers to advise the working group about the state

Re: [Softwires] Mailing list question to gauge consensus on 4rd-U vs MAP

2012-04-09 Thread Edwin Cordeiro
Dear Softwire wg members: At the Paris IETF Softwire meeting, we had presentations on MAP (taken as a whole) and 4rd-U. We got very strong feedback that we needed to select one solution to cover that full stateless case, not two, and that we should make this decision relatively quickly.