Re: for discussion: license inclusion guidelines

2022-09-16 Thread Russ Allbery
"Steve Winslow" writes: > I expect we'd want to be a bit specific about what we mean by "is > included in the distro". For instance, for Debian I'd think `main` would > be covered, `non-free` would not, and I don't know for `contrib`. Debian Developer here. The contrib archive area has the

Re: for discussion: license inclusion guidelines

2022-09-16 Thread J Lovejoy
Thanks Richard, that’s helpful to point out! That and Steve’s point re: Debian Main makes me think we’d need to be somewhat specific for each distro that would trigger a lighter-weight review. More to ponder…. And Steve - agreed re: Change Proposal, I’ll add that to my list of things to do

Re: for discussion: license inclusion guidelines

2022-09-15 Thread Richard Fontana
On Wed, Sep 7, 2022 at 2:17 PM Steve Winslow wrote: > > Jilayne -- yes, I'd be open to a lighter-weight or streamlined approach to > approving licenses submitted from use in distros such as Debian and Fedora. > > In these cases we have greater confidence that those communities have done > the

Re: for discussion: license inclusion guidelines

2022-09-08 Thread Phil Odence via lists.spdx.org
All makes sense to me. Good idea. From: Spdx-legal@lists.spdx.org on behalf of Steve Winslow Date: Wednesday, September 7, 2022 at 2:14 PM To: Karsten Klein Cc: J Lovejoy , SPDX-legal Subject: Re: for discussion: license inclusion guidelines Jilayne -- yes, I'd be open to a lighter-weight

Re: for discussion: license inclusion guidelines

2022-09-07 Thread Steve Winslow
Jilayne -- yes, I'd be open to a lighter-weight or streamlined approach to approving licenses submitted from use in distros such as Debian and Fedora. In these cases we have greater confidence that those communities have done the work to vet certain of the license inclusion principles. In

Re: for discussion: license inclusion guidelines

2022-09-05 Thread Karsten Klein
Hi Jilayne, once in a while I come back with my yet informal proposal to treat new licenses in two stages: Stage 1 - Registration Register a license text providing a unique name and short id. (New) Registration guidelines only make sure no other SPDX license is duplicated / affected. This