Locals Finding Over Burdened / Under Sized Systems

2007-06-20 Thread Dave Phelan
Greetings list, I'd like to just offer yet another opinion on the thread going on regarding the SC Sofa Store fire and a question earlier on what do / can local authorities do when / if they find a building with an over taxed or under designed system in it. Presumably if you are performing inspec

RE: Power source for electric fire pump

2007-06-20 Thread art
Need more info. Where is coming from? What is it crossing? If it runs thru the building there is fire resistant wiring. It must be protected from fire. -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Thomas Reinhardt Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2007 4:25 PM

RE: Power source for electric fire pump

2007-06-20 Thread Steve Leyton
Depending on which code you're using, the back-up power circuit from a generator or alternate second source must be rated cable or concrete-encased. Not sure about the primary ... Steve Leyton PROTECTION DESIGN & CONSULTING -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTE

Power source for electric fire pump

2007-06-20 Thread Thomas Reinhardt
Does the electric power source for a fire pump need to be encased in concrete? Thanks Tom ___ Sprinklerforum mailing list Sprinklerforum@firesprinkler.org http://lists.firesprinkler.org/mailman/listinfo/sprinklerforum To Unsubscribe, send an email

RE: domestic demand for 13D systems

2007-06-20 Thread Jamie Seidl
Thanks guys, I was thinking a combined line needed to have the domestic included for sizing the line. Jamie Seidl -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Ed Kramer Sent: Wednesday, June 20, 2007 3:54 PM To: sprinklerforum@firesprinkler.org Subj

RE: domestic demand for 13D systems

2007-06-20 Thread Ed Kramer
Jamie - in the '02 edition, section 6.3 may be what you're looking for. Ed Kramer Littleton, CO > > >I was just glancing thru 13D and I can't find the section on domestic >demand. Is domestic demand required to be included in the calculations >for 13D? > >Jamie Seidl >___

RE: 13D domestic demand

2007-06-20 Thread Bob Knight
Jamie, With 13D, usually no domestic demand is required. The exception is when a multipurpose piping system is being used and it is serving more than one dwelling unit. See 13D 6.3 2002 ed. Bob Knight -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On Behalf Of Jami

RE: Digital Flowmeter For Hydrant Flow Test

2007-06-20 Thread Tom Duross
Frank- I've used the NCI unit, nice but you can't calibrate it. I was asked to check one against a playpipe once by FM (at the convention ctr. here in Boston, site of the NFPA show) and it was WAY off, not even close at multiple flows, both under and over. I wouldn't recommend it. I have the pol

RE: [SPAM] - RE: Charleston SC fire-follow-up -

2007-06-20 Thread Thomas Reinhardt
Craig, Great question. The answer is yes we can legally stop them from storing illegally. If the building is sprinklered and the commodity changes, they have to prove to the AHJ that there is enough density in the system to handle the commodity. I explain to the responsible party that they need to

Re: Viking Cold Storage Systems

2007-06-20 Thread Todd Williams - work
John, I'd appreciate hearing some of the feedback you get. I'm looking at a job where that might be appropriate. At 08:12 AM 6/20/2007, you wrote: Dear Forum, I am looking for feedback from sprinkler contractors who have installed the Viking "Cold Storage System" using K-25 ESFR heads and

RE: [SPAM] - RE: [SPAM] - RE: Charleston SC fire-followup - -Emailhas different SMTP TO: and MIME TO: fields in the emailaddresses

2007-06-20 Thread Jamie Seidl
I was just glancing thru 13D and I can't find the section on domestic demand. Is domestic demand required to be included in the calculations for 13D? Jamie Seidl ___ Sprinklerforum mailing list Sprinklerforum@firesprinkler.org http://lists.firesprinkl

RE: [SPAM] - RE: [SPAM] - RE: Charleston SC fire-followup - - Emailhas different SMTP TO: and MIME TO: fields in the email addresses

2007-06-20 Thread Smith, David (VFD)
Ditto. I see it regularly. 11,500 square foot spec building with 25 foot ceilings and 14 foot tall doors. Just under our local requirements for sprinklers -- actually one guy split his building into three so he didn't have put sprinklers in. Nearly every time I see a new tenant move in, I stop in

Charleston SC Fire

2007-06-20 Thread Steve Leyton
This is kind of wordy (those who know me well, please stop snickering), but I thought I'd share it anyway. Thanks Mark for calling attention to that article; below is my correspondence to the writer. To: Jason Ryan, The State Re: The Sofa Super Store Fire It appears that you were quoting other

Building Separation

2007-06-20 Thread John . Kaminski
I'm designing the suppression system for a new 17 story building. The building sits next an existing 4 story building. The separation between the two is just two feet. Our wall has a two rating and their wall also has a two hour rating. However, their wall has an ERIS finish on it. The t

RE: [SPAM] - RE: [SPAM] - RE: Charleston SC fire-followup - - Email has different SMTP TO: and MIME TO: fields in the email addresses

2007-06-20 Thread Mark Finocchio
Absolutely. They are in violation of their Certificate of Occupancy if they have non-approved conditions. We just went through a situation were we found an excessive amount of plastic pallets and totes stacked in a warehouse to full height (25') in a 300,000 sq.ft. building. The area that contai

RE: Charleston SC Fire

2007-06-20 Thread Mark Sornsin
FYI, there is an article at http://www.thestate.com/154/story/96873.html which included the following statement: "Given the swiftness and ferocity of the furniture-fueled fire, officials speculated, the extra water might not have mattered." I have sent the writer my opinion about the veracity

RE: Charleston SC Fire

2007-06-20 Thread Craig.Prahl
>From the pics, no, not historic. Looks like a typical metal/block siding, steel bar joist type big-box building. Nothing special at all. Craig L. Prahl, CET Fire Protection Group Mechanical Department CH2MHILL Lockwood Greene 1500 International Drive PO Box 491, Spartanburg, SC 29304-0491 Dir

RE: [SPAM] - RE: Charleston SC fire-followup -

2007-06-20 Thread Craig.Prahl
It will come down to the fact that as the local AHJ said, when the building was built sprinklers weren't required. And if not required why waste the money on something that will never be used. Since there are no retrofit laws on the books, no requirement to update the building. Do what you wan

Charleston SC Fire

2007-06-20 Thread Steve Leyton
Anyone know if this building was considered or registered as historic? That might explain the absence of sprinklers, but not the permission to occupy with a furniture warehouse store. Steve Leyton PROTECTION DESIGN & CONSULTING -Original Message- From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] [mailto:[EMAIL PR

RE: [SPAM] - RE: Charleston SC fire-followup - Email has different SMTP TO: and MIME TO: fields in the email addresses

2007-06-20 Thread Mark Finocchio
Neil: Most departments have an entry protocol. Unfortunately, the initial reports indicated possibly 2 persons trapped. In fact it was one employee of the furniture store and he was rescued fairly quickly. When we receive a report of person(s) trapped, we are required to assess the tenability an

Re: Charleston SC fire-followup

2007-06-20 Thread Ron Greenman
On NPR as I drove home last night their report had extensive discussion about no sprinklers, that they had not been required when the building was built, that they would be required if the building were to be built now and that the entire tragedy would have been avoided if the building were sprink

RE: Charleston SC fire-followup

2007-06-20 Thread Neil Stong
It is scary that as many as 15 firemen were in an unsprinklered building when the roof collapsed. There could be 15 dead firemen instead of 9. I have never been a fireman but don't they have procedures for entering burning buildings, especially ones without sprinklers. Neil Stong STONG FIRE PROTE

RE: 150% pump curve

2007-06-20 Thread Jamie Seidl
In cases like this, we've been required to put a suction supply control valve. The valve has a sensing line that ties to the suction side of the pump and if the supply pressure drops below 20psi the control valve will throttle the discharge to maintain that 20 psi. The 20 psi pressure limit (I b

Charleston SC fire-followup

2007-06-20 Thread Craig.Prahl
Local news media reported that the building was NOT equipped with fire sprinklers. I must commend their report. After a recent industrial fire and not one word on whether the facility was protected by sprinklers I sent an e-mail to the reporter making an inquiry and adding a brief overview of spr

Viking Cold Storage Systems

2007-06-20 Thread John O'Connor
Dear Forum, I am looking for feedback from sprinkler contractors who have installed the Viking "Cold Storage System" using K-25 ESFR heads and propylene glycol in pre-action system(s) in freezers. Please respond off-line via email or phone. Thanks! John R. O'Connor, SET National Fire Sprinkle