Re: [Standards] Thoughts on XEP-0385 Stateless Inline Media Sharing

On Fri, Jul 2, 2021 at 1:22 PM Florian Schmaus wrote: > On 02.07.21 12:15, JC Brand wrote: > > So, my proposal is that XEP-0385 be updated so that the XEP-0300 hash > > requirement gets relaxed to a SHOULD > > +1. I would even make the hash OPTIONAL as SHOULD is already pretty strong. > > I'd be

Re: [Standards] Thoughts on XEP-0385 Stateless Inline Media Sharing

Am 2. Juli 2021 13:41:26 MESZ schrieb Tobias Markmann : >On Fri, Jul 2, 2021 at 1:22 PM Florian Schmaus >wrote: > >> On 02.07.21 12:15, JC Brand wrote: >> > So, my proposal is that XEP-0385 be updated so that the XEP-0300 >hash >> > requirement gets relaxed to a SHOULD >> >> +1. I would even

Re: [Standards] Thoughts on XEP-0385 Stateless Inline Media Sharing

On 02.07.21 12:15, JC Brand wrote: > So, my proposal is that XEP-0385 be updated so that the XEP-0300 hash > requirement gets relaxed to a SHOULD +1. I would even make the hash OPTIONAL as SHOULD is already pretty strong. > and that the inclusion of the Etag > header be documented as an

Re: [Standards] Thoughts on XEP-0385 Stateless Inline Media Sharing

Sorry, I see now that Thunderbird has completely mangled the stanza that it showed so nicely to me in the email editor. I guess because I have it configured to send out only plaintext. Here it is again:     Look at this funny cat picture     type='data'>                                    

Re: [Standards] Thoughts on XEP-0385 Stateless Inline Media Sharing

On 02.07.21 12:42, Sergey Ilinykh wrote: What about a slightly different scenario? Romeo sees a funny picture on funnypics.com , copies it to a messenger's input field. The messenger prefetches the whole picture, generates a thumbnail (at least it's impossible to have

Re: [Standards] UPDATED: XEP-0458 (Community Code of Conduct)

Hi all, There was an interesting discussion, alongside a reference to a free book I'd not come across, in the XSF Chatroom starting here by "pep.": XSF Discussion - 2021-06-28 (xmpp.org) Of particular note here is how we

Re: [Standards] Thoughts on XEP-0385 Stateless Inline Media Sharing

What about a slightly different scenario? Romeo sees a funny picture on funnypics.com, copies it to a messenger's input field. The messenger prefetches the whole picture, generates a thumbnail (at least it's impossible to have a thumbnail without fetching everything), computes hashes and then

[Standards] Thoughts on XEP-0385 Stateless Inline Media Sharing

Hi everyone I've been reading XEP-0385 SIMS with an eye towards potentially implementing it, when I noticed that a XEP-0300 hash is required, in order to allow integrity checking and caching. In the introduction of SIMS, the following is written: "This proposal aims to provide a protocol