Re: [Standards] Bookmarks and autojoin issues

2020-05-24 Thread Maxime Buquet
On 2020/05/24, Philipp Hörist wrote: > Hi, > > let me try with XEP-0402 > > > > > > name='The Plays the Thing' > autojoin='true'> > JC > > > > > > >

Re: [Standards] Bookmarks and autojoin issues

2020-05-24 Thread Philipp Hörist
Hi, let me try with XEP-0402 JC - Clients offer a option to set one or more profiles for the device - Clients can ask the user on joining a bookmark which profiles should

Re: [Standards] Bookmarks and autojoin issues

2020-05-24 Thread Maxime Buquet
On 2020/05/24, Stefan wrote: > Am Sonntag, den 24.05.2020 um 00:41:53 +0200 schrieb mathi...@mathieui.net: > > The use cases I have in mind are a bit extreme (e.g. people with > 100 > > MUCs in their autojoined bookmarks), which are unusable on mobile, for > > example, where screen space is

Re: [Standards] Bookmarks and autojoin issues

2020-05-24 Thread Stefan
Am Sonntag, den 24.05.2020 um 00:41:53 +0200 schrieb mathi...@mathieui.net: > The use cases I have in mind are a bit extreme (e.g. people with > 100 > MUCs in their autojoined bookmarks), which are unusable on mobile, for > example, where screen space is limited and you probably want to limit >

Re: [Standards] Bookmarks and autojoin issues

2020-05-24 Thread Maxime Buquet
On 2020/05/24, Philipp Hörist wrote: > What first comes to mind is, that 402 now can hold extended payloads in > each bookmark item. > So we just add the profile there? Not against the idea, even though I'm not entirely sure how it would work. 0402 is not a bookmark XEP, just like the multiple

Re: [Standards] Bookmarks and autojoin issues

2020-05-24 Thread Philipp Hörist
Hi, So whats your ideas how we can implement that? What first comes to mind is, that 402 now can hold extended payloads in each bookmark item. So we just add the profile there? and UI wise i ask the user when he joins a room to what profile he wants to add that. regards Philipp Am So., 24.

Re: [Standards] Bookmarks and autojoin issues

2020-05-24 Thread Mathieu Pasquet
On 24.05.2020 06:50, Philipp Hörist wrote: Hi, The problem is there are no rules what goes into which profile. If i add a bookmark as a desktop client, i don't know if it should go into the mobile profile or not. And btw we try to abstract bookmarks away from the user, so managing profiles of

Re: [Standards] Bookmarks and autojoin issues

2020-05-23 Thread Philipp Hörist
Hi, The problem is there are no rules what goes into which profile. If i add a bookmark as a desktop client, i don't know if it should go into the mobile profile or not. And btw we try to abstract bookmarks away from the user, so managing profiles of bookmarks for different devices is exactly

Re: [Standards] Bookmarks and autojoin issues

2020-05-23 Thread Maxime Buquet
On 2020/05/24, Mathieu Pasquet wrote: > Greetings, > > I want to raise an issue that appears with bookmarks in their current > form in the multi-client scenario. It appears as long as we have more > than one client, and gets worse for every added client and MUC bookmark. > > XEP-0048 and

Re: [Standards] Bookmarks and autojoin issues

2020-05-23 Thread Sergey Ilinykh
Another perspective for profiles is work/life balance. Work/life MUCs or anything else fitting this concept. Particularly in Psi I've already added some options allowing to ignore some autojoining mucs for example at work or local-only (not stored on a server) bookmarks. Best Regards, Sergey

Re: [Standards] Bookmarks and autojoin issues

2020-05-23 Thread Sam Whited
On Sat, May 23, 2020, at 18:41, Mathieu Pasquet wrote: > In a multi-client scenario however, that quickly changes as you > probably do not want the same view everywhere. I disagree, I always want exactly the same view everywhere. Otherwise I inevitably leave my desk and then try to look up