Hallo Ken,
Monday, 18 October, 2004, 04:38:15, you wrote:
KR --- Legal Eagle [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
The US is no friend to anybody, when carefully
looked at. They have NEVER
ever done anything sacrificially in it's entire
existance.
KR You never heard of World War I or World War II
--- Legal Eagle [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote:
The US is no friend to anybody, when carefully
looked at. They have NEVER
ever done anything sacrificially in it's entire
existance.
You never heard of World War I or World War II
Ken
___
Do you
Hello Steve,
- Original Message -
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Tuesday, September 28, 2004 7:03 PM
Subject: Re: [Biofuel] Re: [Off Topic]US to sell 5000 smart bombs to Israel
If a soldier decides not to fight in an illegal war, then he must be
prepared to accept
- Original Message -
From: Greg Harbican [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Tuesday, September 28, 2004 2:04 PM
Subject: Re: [Biofuel] Re: [Off Topic]US to sell 5000 smart bombs to Israel
- Original Message -
From: Keith Addison [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: [EMAIL
- Original Message -
From: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Monday, September 27, 2004 8:58 PM
Subject: [Biofuel] Re: [Off Topic]US to sell 5000 smart bombs to Israel
Afghanistan and Iraq were bombed and invaded and their infrastucture
destroyed, their children slaughtered, air
- Original Message -
From: Gustl Steiner-Zehender [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: Keith Addison [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Tuesday, September 28, 2004 11:15 AM
Subject: Re[2]: [Biofuel] Re: [Off Topic]US to sell 5000 smart bombs to
Israel
Hallo All,
Tuesday, 28 September, 2004, 09:39:31, you
Afghanistan and Iraq were bombed and invaded and their infrastucture
destroyed, their children slaughtered, air anw water polulted with
depleted
uranium with a shelf life of BILLIONS of yearsw for a lot less than what
Israel has and is doing,snip
Luc
Ron B.,
Soldiers follow orders and if they are killing women and children, it is
not many who refuse to follow the orders. The culpable is the head that
sets the rules, environment and issues the orders. US have no reason to
claim any noble superiority in human warfare. The problem with US
Hi Hakan,
Thanks for your reply, but Luc in a previous post (Why We Cannot Win),
mentioned it was the duty of a soldier to refuse to fight in an illegal
war.
BTW- Did you happen to visit Da Lat, where pine trees grow and the weather
is cool? Also, did you visit the villas and beaches of Vung
We started by arriving in Hanoi and spent 3 days there, made trip to the
mountains and the 200 km long hydro power dam. At the lake in Hanoi it is
a monument from when a US plane was shot down and the pilot parachuted into
the city lake. Senator John Macain seams to have a good humor,
If a soldier decides not to fight in an illegal war, then he must be prepared
to accept the consequences of that decision. It won't be pretty.
= = = Original message = = =
Hi Hakan,
Thanks for your reply, but Luc in a previous post (Why We Cannot Win),
mentioned it was the duty of a soldier
Thanks for your reply, but Luc in a previous post (Why We Cannot Win),
mentioned it was the duty of a soldier to refuse to fight in an illegal
war.
Is it a soldier's duty to do whatever he/she's told?
BTW- Did you happen to visit Da Lat, where pine trees grow and the weather
is cool? Also,
Steve,
You are right and soldiers very seldom have a choice. Therefore the
principle of responsibility for any atrocities must be carried all the way
to the political and military top, which Bush and Co. seams to avoid. It is
not a valid excuse to blame the soldiers, because they a trained
Hallo All,
Tuesday, 28 September, 2004, 09:39:31, you wrote:
Hi Hakan,
Thanks for your reply, but Luc in a previous post (Why We Cannot Win),
mentioned it was the duty of a soldier to refuse to fight in an illegal
war.
KA Is it a soldier's duty to do whatever he/she's told?
This is the
While you are on this subject...if you happen to cross paths where you
live with some of the fine Canadian (Canadien) soldiers that were fighting
side-by-side with the USA in Afghanistanwould you let your true
feelings be heard and tell them in their face that they are murderers,
Hi Hakan,
Thanks for your reply, but Luc in a previous post (Why We Cannot Win),
mentioned it was the duty of a soldier to refuse to fight in an illegal
war.
Is it a soldier's duty to do whatever he/she's told?
This was a popular defense at Nuremberg. The duty of a soldier to
obey
Gustl,
Well described and anyone who went trough military service must recognize
this description, this regardless if they have been in action or not.
Sweden have mandatory military service, but today it does not call in all
youngsters, because of economic reasons. We are very lucky in
One of my best friends is a US soldier who recently returned from Iraq.
He is a soldier who volunteered to protect his country and was ordered to
instead go fight an illegal war. He is not a murderer, thug or baby
killer, and I would fight anyone who called him such.
On the other hand, I
PROTECTED]
Behalf Of Gustl Steiner-Zehender
Sent: Tuesday, September 28, 2004 11:15 AM
To: Keith Addison
Subject: Re[2]: [Biofuel] Re: [Off Topic]US to
sell 5000 smart bombs to
Israel
Hallo All,
Tuesday, 28 September, 2004, 09:39:31, you wrote:
Hi Hakan,
Thanks for your reply, but Luc
- Original Message -
From: Keith Addison [EMAIL PROTECTED]
To: [EMAIL PROTECTED]
Sent: Tuesday, September 28, 2004 07:39
Subject: Re: [Biofuel] Re: [Off Topic]US to sell 5000 smart bombs to Israel
Is it a soldier's duty to do whatever he/she's told?
Hi Keith,
Perhaps I can
One of my best friends is a US soldier who recently returned from Iraq.
He is a soldier who volunteered to protect his country and was ordered to
instead go fight an illegal war. He is not a murderer, thug or baby
killer, and I would fight anyone who called him such.
On the other hand,
Yes, I agree, but I think it depends what's meant by duty. Duty isn't
just orders and rules and punishments for breaking them. Unless a
soldier sheds his humanity when he dons his uniform, his first duty
is to be human. It's his conscience he has to listen to, regardless
of the
22 matches
Mail list logo
