Re: [Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-18 Thread Keith Addison
Yes, I think there should be promise with these technologies, but as you say, what really matters is whose hand controls the direction in which the work is done. As I have said before, there is no tool so benign that it cannot also be used as a weapon. How do we know we can trust those that

Re: [Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-18 Thread Joe Street
Hi Darryl; Or more importantly (and maybe this is what you meant) we don't understand the intricacies of the natural systems already in existence in order to meddle with them in a way that won't create larger problems than we already have. That is the way of human activity that I see most

Re: [Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-18 Thread Darryl McMahon
Keith, I'm not without hope on these matters. That is why I keep working away at solutions on many fronts. I also don't underestimate the challenges, which is not to say I understand them completely. You wrote: ... Precaution, definitely, and yet I can't help feeling that there should

Re: [Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-18 Thread Darryl McMahon
Hi Joe, yes, I think you have captured it better than I did. Darryl On 18/10/2010 9:11 AM, Joe Street wrote: Hi Darryl; Or more importantly (and maybe this is what you meant) we don't understand the intricacies of the natural systems already in existence in order to meddle with them in a

Re: [Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-18 Thread Chip Mefford
The way I've explained my reticence towards all this stuff has been; When we come up with computer modeling that is able to accurately predict the weather years into the future, THEN our models will be good enough that we can think about fiddling about with altering the genetics of 'stuff'

Re: [Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-18 Thread Keith Addison
Any gardener would disagree with you (and at least one of you is a gardener). There now, does that put the scale in perspective? You can't seem to help seeing it in gargantuan terms. Keith Hi Joe, yes, I think you have captured it better than I did. Darryl On 18/10/2010 9:11 AM, Joe Street

Re: [Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-18 Thread Keith Addison
Hi Darryl I agree with all that. Just about. Yes, it's difficult to separate the wheat from the chaff, to have an empty mind, free of expectation, but it's essential, and not impossible. We have to do the best we can - we might never get there, but we'll get a lot further than if we just

[Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-17 Thread Keith Addison
... Precaution, definitely, and yet I can't help feeling that there should be some potential for useful or helpful techno-fixes, that don't do more harm than good, nor any harm at all. I guess much depends on the mindset of the fixers. An empty mind is best, IMHO, free of expectation (and of

Re: [Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-17 Thread Zeke Yewdall
My thought when people suggest that technological fixes will solve the global climate change problem and that we don't have to worry about it... is that we already ignore all the technological fixes that have already been invented are, in the grand scheme of things, being solidly ignored.

Re: [Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-17 Thread Keith Addison
Hear hear, Zeke, well said, I fully agree. And we definitely do have to worry about it. There's good reason to believe, though, IMHO, that the required societal and behavioural changes are coming, spreading and growing fast - like wildfire, it seems to me, and worldwide. But, exactly because

Re: [Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-17 Thread Darryl McMahon
Zeke has pretty much covered what I was going to day regarding technology. What we need is here, sitting on the shelf, has been for decades. No one really speaking for it though, no adverts on TV or radio or Internet ads. Is it really as simple as there is no sure profit in selling such

Re: [Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-17 Thread Keith Addison
Well, you and Zeke both know I agree with all that. But I think there might be more to be seen in it, or at least hoped for - could be wrong of course, as ever. Of course people are brainwashed, especially in North America. There's never been such a thing in the world before as the sheer 24/7

Re: [Biofuel] UN to Confront Sci-fi Climate Solutions at Biodiversity Meeting

2010-10-17 Thread Darryl McMahon
Yes, I think there should be promise with these technologies, but as you say, what really matters is whose hand controls the direction in which the work is done. As I have said before, there is no tool so benign that it cannot also be used as a weapon. How do we know we can trust those