Re: [Tagging] Status of proposed roof:ridge / roof:edge ?

2020-08-31 Thread Tobias Knerr
On 31.08.20 20:06, Oliver Simmons wrote: > Does anyone know if this tagging: > https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/ProposedRoofLines > > Is accepted and ok to use? > > It has “proposed” in the title but there’s none of the usual proposal > stuff saying if it was accepted or not. It never went

[Tagging] Status of proposed roof:ridge / roof:edge ?

2020-08-31 Thread Oliver Simmons
Does anyone know if this tagging: https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/ProposedRoofLinesIs accepted and ok to use? It has “proposed” in the title but there’s none of the usual proposal stuff saying if it was accepted or not. I was wanting to use it but thought I would ask first.Thanks :)- Oliver

Re: [Tagging] leisure=schoolyard

2020-08-31 Thread joost schouppe
Ah, yes, in smaller schools or schools in dense areas that might be the case. It came up here: https://www.openstreetmap.org/way/38911304 It's rather large; has kindergarten up to high school education; not all areas are available for students during breaks; areas are designated for some students

Re: [Tagging] Rail segment in a bike route

2020-08-31 Thread Peter Elderson
Volker Schmidt : > The double role issue, if it occurs, is there in either case, separate > relation or role in the bicycle route relation. > If a way or a chain of ways in a route relation has no forward/backward role, you can assign it a transfer/transport role.Easy for e.g. ferries operating

Re: [Tagging] leisure=schoolyard

2020-08-31 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
It's been a while that I have been to school, but from memory, as well as from the current situation I see from my kids at their school, the school grounds are basically the same as the "Pausenhof". E.g. in my school, pupils had their respective spaces according to age groups or maybe classes, and

Re: [Tagging] leisure=schoolyard

2020-08-31 Thread joost schouppe
Hi Martin, I stumbled upon the page when looking for something better than leisure=playground for the concrete slabs that are used for recess and are called "speelplaats" ("square for playing") in Dutch. I've added some links to that page, which made you notice. I hadn't noticed myself that it's

[Tagging] leisure=schoolyard

2020-08-31 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
I just discovered someone has added leisure=schoolyard to the wiki. It is not completely clear to me how to apply this tag, is there a difference between the school grounds minus the buildings and the schoolyard? Which parts have to be excluded from a schoolyard? Does it only apply to spaces

Re: [Tagging] Rail segment in a bike route

2020-08-31 Thread Volker Schmidt
The double role issue, if it occurs, is there in either case, separate relation or role in the bicycle route relation. Regarding travel details of ferry/rail/bus sections within bicycle routes: This information, if available, should go on the the ferry/rail/bus route relations, as these means of

Re: [Tagging] Rail segment in a bike route

2020-08-31 Thread Peter Elderson
Jo: > I added that it's not needed for ferries in the proposal on the wiki. It's > alright if we have more than 1 way to do it and leave it up to the mapper > to decide whether to map as a single route relation or split them and use a > superroute relation. > Wouldn't this apply to other

Re: [Tagging] Rail segment in a bike route

2020-08-31 Thread Jo
I added that it's not needed for ferries in the proposal on the wiki. It's alright if we have more than 1 way to do it and leave it up to the mapper to decide whether to map as a single route relation or split them and use a superroute relation. If I start doing a bicycle tour, I want to know in

Re: [Tagging] Rail segment in a bike route

2020-08-31 Thread Peter Elderson
'transport' role, 'transportation' role ... is this in use and documented somewhere? In bicycle routes, when the ways are different for the two directions, forward and backward roles apply to the ways in the relation. If a transfer/transport/transportation is to be applied as well, how would you

Re: [Tagging] Rail segment in a bike route

2020-08-31 Thread Jo
We've been doing it for years for ferries, so in that case I agree that it's somewhat overkill. In the case of transferring to a train or bus, I don't think it's overkill to be explicit about it though. It seems really odd to me to have railway ways or highway ways with bicycle=no|use_sidepath as

Re: [Tagging] Rail segment in a bike route

2020-08-31 Thread Warin
On 31/8/20 8:25 am, Volker Schmidt wrote: Keep it simple, if the simple solution does not limit you. Agreed. I see no reason why a way as a member of a simple route relation could not have the role 'transport'. ___ Tagging mailing list