Re: [Tagging] RFC: shop=pastry

2011-11-28 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, On 11/28/11 03:21, Martin Koppenhoefer wrote: Thing is, it doesn't help you if shop=bakery is rendered, when you are looking for bread and find a pastry, while it wouldn't help you neither if you looked for pastry and were led to a bakery, so basically to make this subtagging work you will

Re: [Tagging] RFC: shop=pastry

2011-11-28 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
2011/11/28 Frederik Ramm frede...@remote.org: On 11/28/11 03:21, Martin Koppenhoefer wrote: Thing is, it doesn't help you if shop=bakery is rendered, when you are looking for bread and find a pastry, while it wouldn't help you neither if you looked for pastry and were led to a bakery, so

[Tagging] RFC: shop=pastry

2011-11-27 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
I'd like to propose shop=pastry. (Currently there are 13 of these according to taginfo) There is some recommendations for similar features 1. amenity=cafe cuisine=cake and 2. shop=confectionery I interpret the first as a place to sit and the second seems to be more suitable for candy and/or

Re: [Tagging] RFC: shop=pastry

2011-11-27 Thread Greg Troxel
Martin Koppenhoefer dieterdre...@gmail.com writes: I'd like to propose shop=pastry. (Currently there are 13 of these according to taginfo) There is some recommendations for similar features 1. amenity=cafe cuisine=cake and 2. shop=confectionery I interpret the first as a place to

Re: [Tagging] RFC: shop=pastry

2011-11-27 Thread Mike N
On 11/27/2011 11:19 AM, Greg Troxel wrote: I am not aware of any that sell cake only, and not other kinds of dessert. http://www.chocomoosebakery.com/ is probably very close: cake plus one or two additional items. Instead of shop=pastry, I would say shop=bakery bakery=pastry, because then

Re: [Tagging] RFC: shop=pastry

2011-11-27 Thread Jo
Wouldn't it make more sense to have shop=bakery bread=yes (the default) pastry=yes (when they have pätisserie/banketgebak) chocolates=yes (if they have fine chocolate sweets) or something of the kind. I think this is more consistent with other schemes. We also make a difference between 'warme

Re: [Tagging] RFC: shop=pastry

2011-11-27 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
2011/11/27 Greg Troxel g...@ir.bbn.com: Instead of shop=pastry, I would say shop=bakery bakery=pastry, because then the bakery rules work, for data consumers that don't know/care about pastry.  And, in the grand ontology we are avoiding building, a pastry shop is generally a kind of bakery.