Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-18 Thread Fernando Trebien
The routing app could also say "go to the first circle and then take the second exit" and it would be well understood too, I think. If the user is aware of the differences between a roundabout and a traffic circle, he/she will even know beforehand if they're supposed to stop/yield at the entrances

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-18 Thread Janko Mihelić
2014-06-18 13:57 GMT+02:00 Pieren : > > Currently, the wiki suggests to tag equally both types of junctions > ([1]). To avoid confusion, we could use a specific tag like > "junction=traffic_circle" (already 33 in taginfo) (then we could > discuss about the "oneway=yes" implied or not). But I don't

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-18 Thread Pieren
On Wed, Jun 18, 2014 at 1:42 PM, Janko Mihelić wrote: > I've never heard of this "turning circle" term. Maybe we should call this a > turning circle, and then beg routing application developers to treat it the > same as roundabout. Currently, the wiki suggests to tag equally both types of juncti

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-18 Thread Janko Mihelić
2014-06-18 8:38 GMT+02:00 Volker Schmidt : > As the Wikipedia article shows, the original French sign for roundabout > implied the priorité a droite and is identical to the one shown in the > Croatian example ( > https://maps.google.hr/?ll=45.492397,15.549753&spn=0.004543,0.00883&t=h&z=17&layer=c&

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-18 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
2014-06-18 11:06 GMT+02:00 Elena ``of Valhalla'' : > +1, any case where the traffic light is usually off (or blinking yellow) > and normal roundabout rules apply except for sporadic events (pedestrian > crossings, too much traffic on some direction, etc.) walks and quacks > like a roundabout to me

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-18 Thread Elena ``of Valhalla''
On 2014-06-17 at 14:49:33 -0400, Phil! Gold wrote: > * Martin Koppenhoefer [2014-06-17 16:43 +0200]: > > you can find big roundabouts with traffic lights in most of the big > > European cities, another reason (besides the controlling the motorized > > traffic) is to let pedestrians (and sometimes

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-18 Thread Pieren
On Wed, Jun 18, 2014 at 10:43 AM, Pieren wrote: Btw, we also have some special cases like this one: http://www.openstreetmap.org/#map=19/47.20880/-1.58741&layers=N where a tramway is crossing the roundabout. It's a normal roundabout (not a traffic circle) excepted that traffic lights stop the r

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-18 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
> Am 17/giu/2014 um 22:47 schrieb Paul Johnson : > > I'd call it a full blown roundabout, since you're still expected to go around > it to the right in order to go left. +1, this is by no means a mini roundabout. cheers, Martin ___ Tagging mailing

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-18 Thread Pieren
On Wed, Jun 18, 2014 at 8:38 AM, Volker Schmidt wrote: > Only relatively recently (1984) the French introduced the roundabout with > priority in the ring. Today, most of the roundabouts in France are ... roundabouts where traffic in the ring has right of way and they are tagged with "junction=ro

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Volker Schmidt
If I am not mistaken, the French were the first to have roaundabouts in quantities, but they all had the priority-to-the-right rule at the time, i.e. the priority was to the traffic entering the circle. See http://fr.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carrefour_giratoire This was one of the particularities you nee

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Fernando Trebien
IMHO I think that the main idea in the concept of "roundabout" is that the center of the cycle (which may not be a perfect circle, sometimes not even an ellipse) has right of way over entering traffic. That's why I find it weird when: - Croatian (and perhaps some other) authorities apply the rounda

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Bryan Housel
We have a bunch of roundabouts and traffic circles here in NJ. Today I learned that roundabouts and traffic circles are not necessarily the same thing. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roundabout - no traffic signals controlling access to the roundabout - circling traffic in the roundabout has right

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Paul Johnson
Wonder if we're talking regional differences. The south of France is known to follow the Vienna Convention on Traffic (traffic in the circle yields to traffic entering from the right), and the US and Canada make no signage differences between a roundabout and a traffic circle. For navigation purp

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Paul Johnson
Wow, really? Got a photo? On Jun 17, 2014 4:22 PM, "Clifford Snow" wrote: > I've seen one actual mini round about in Seattle and one in Mount Vernon. > Certainly there are numerous traffic calming islands incorrectly tagged as > mini runabouts. > On Jun 17, 2014 1:10 PM, "Paul Johnson" wrote: >

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Volker Schmidt
No. One of the characteristics of a roundabout is that you have precedence when you are in it. In this case there is a main road that has precedence over the two minor roads. If you want to turn left (looking in the direction of the photo) you have to yield to oncoming traffic coming from the oppos

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Clifford Snow
I've seen one actual mini round about in Seattle and one in Mount Vernon. Certainly there are numerous traffic calming islands incorrectly tagged as mini runabouts. On Jun 17, 2014 1:10 PM, "Paul Johnson" wrote: > Not as rare as you think, and growing more common. I go through 2 or 3 > roundabou

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Volker Schmidt
It's certainly not a mini-roundabout, because the centre piece is not intended to be traversed by vehicles (see http://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:highway%3Dmini_roundabout) On 17 June 2014 22:43, Tod Fitch wrote: > How would you tag this intersection in Mountain View, California? > > > htt

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Paul Johnson
I'd call it a full blown roundabout, since you're still expected to go around it to the right in order to go left. On Jun 17, 2014 3:43 PM, "Tod Fitch" wrote: > How would you tag this intersection in Mountain View, California? > > > https://www.google.com/maps/place/Mountain+View,+CA/@37.387343,-

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Tod Fitch
How would you tag this intersection in Mountain View, California? https://www.google.com/maps/place/Mountain+View,+CA/@37.387343,-122.080352,3a,89.9y,118.3h,70.82t/data=!3m4!1e1!3m2!1sHblffm0KZ7pzUXLakrlBQw!2e0!4m2!3m1!1s0x808fb7495bec0189:0x7c17d44a466baf9b Should it be tagged as traffic_calming

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Paul Johnson
At least one roundabout in Portland is actually square. On Jun 13, 2014 3:15 PM, "Martin Koppenhoefer" wrote: > > > > Am 13/giu/2014 um 18:28 schrieb Clay Smalley : > > > > Out of curiosity, what are others' criteria for a roundabout? > > > priority for the inner traffic is the main > > "circular

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Paul Johnson
Arc du Triumph? On Jun 17, 2014 8:32 AM, "Pieren" wrote: > On Sat, Jun 14, 2014 at 9:41 AM, Philip Barnes > wrote: > > > This roundabout originally had no lights, but they were added with the > > ring road. > > Interesting. Now you get the disadvantages of both systems : you have > the unnecessa

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Paul Johnson
Not as rare as you think, and growing more common. I go through 2 or 3 roundabouts regularly. The US official definitions defined in the MUTCD are that roundabouts are uncontrolled or have yield signs entering, traffic circles have stop signs. Neither are signal controlled in the MUTCD. We do n

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Phil! Gold
* Martin Koppenhoefer [2014-06-17 16:43 +0200]: > you can find big roundabouts with traffic lights in most of the big > European cities, another reason (besides the controlling the motorized > traffic) is to let pedestrians (and sometimes cyclists) cross. I know of a traffic circle (here: http://

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
2014-06-17 16:29 GMT+02:00 Marc Gemis : > There is a similar situation near Geel, Belgium. First they constructed > several roundabouts along the R14, then they turned them back to regular > crossings > Only the roundabout with the N19 is kept at the moment, but there they > placed traffic signals

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Marc Gemis
There is a similar situation near Geel, Belgium. First they constructed several roundabouts along the R14, then they turned them back to regular crossings Only the roundabout with the N19 is kept at the moment, but there they placed traffic signals (http://osm.org/go/0ErQgoDk--?m=&relation=1263541

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-17 Thread Pieren
On Sat, Jun 14, 2014 at 9:41 AM, Philip Barnes wrote: > This roundabout originally had no lights, but they were added with the > ring road. Interesting. Now you get the disadvantages of both systems : you have the unnecessary waitings on red lights and you use a maximum of land space for a junct

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-15 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
> Am 13/giu/2014 um 23:20 schrieb Janko Mihelić : > > There's a town in Croatia where all roundabouts have a roundabout sign, but > the traffic entering the roundabout has right of way. How do we tag that? > > Link to streetview of one such roundabout. nice. I'd ask the local authorities abo

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-14 Thread Philip Barnes
I think I should comment on this, I know this roundabout very well, actually too well. It is definitely a roundabout, that is how it is know in the UK, and in common with many signalised roundabouts, not all traffic joining is under traffic light control, these routes do give way to traffic on the

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-13 Thread Janko Mihelić
2014-06-13 22:11 GMT+02:00 Martin Koppenhoefer : > > -1, only roundabouts should get the tag, and roundabouts are only > situations where the traffic inside has the priority (traffic lights or > not). > Usually a roundabout has its sign (might differ according to the country ) > There's a town i

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-13 Thread Fernando Trebien
Great, so my assumptions were mostly correct, except in the case of traffic lights inside the roundabout and on its entrances. I did find some roundabouts that are not perfectly circular in a small town here in Brazil. They resemble the figure of the number 8 (the mapping of the area is still quit

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-13 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
> Am 13/giu/2014 um 18:28 schrieb Clay Smalley : > > Out of curiosity, what are others' criteria for a roundabout? priority for the inner traffic is the main "circular" is not a requirement, can have any shape (usually they are indeed circular) cheers, Martin ___

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-13 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
> Am 13/giu/2014 um 18:32 schrieb Janko Mihelić : > > I think we should call this a roundabout because it's round, and the general > public calls it a roundabout whatever the rules and laws say. -1, only roundabouts should get the tag, and roundabouts are only situations where the traffic in

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-13 Thread Colin Smale
A signal-controlled roundabout reverts to being a normal roundabout if the traffic signals are not working (assuming it is also signed as a roundabout), so the presence/absence of the traffic signals cannot be a criterion for it being a roundabout or not. I expect most countries will have a tr

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-13 Thread Janko Mihelić
I think we should call this a roundabout because it's round, and the general public calls it a roundabout whatever the rules and laws say. If some roundabouts are not "real" roundabouts, we can tag that with subtags, roundabout=unofficial or something. If we want to tag right of way, we tag that wi

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-13 Thread Clay Smalley
Coming from the US where any form of roundabout is rare, I would consider any circular intersection a roundabout. Some have signals, some don't have signals. I know that some people in the US distinguish between the two, where a 'roundabout' has no signals and a 'traffic circle' does have signals.

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-13 Thread Volker Schmidt
Good question. I think this is because originally it was, as many others in the UK, a true roundabout with priority in the ring. The traffic signals were added later to avoid blocking up the (ex-)roundabouts. I have seen many roundabouts in the UK go through these phases: New "clean" roundabout; a

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-13 Thread Dan S
Roundabouts like this sometimes (in Britain) have "part time traffic lights". So, some times of day it is a true roundabout, and some times of day it is a circle of road with traffic signals! I don't know the one you linked, to but it's possible that is what is going on here. Dan 2014-06-13 16:54

Re: [Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-13 Thread Matthijs Melissen
On 13 June 2014 16:54, Fernando Trebien wrote: > So why is it a roundabout? Is it because of the circular shape? Or > could it be because it's impossible to infer that any of the entering > ways have right of way, since they are all controlled by traffic > lights? I don't know about the UK, but [

[Tagging] Signal-controlled roundabouts

2014-06-13 Thread Fernando Trebien
Hello, I used to believe that, by definition, all roundabouts have free transit and right of way along the circle, and that anything that didn't display that property isn't a roundabout (just a circle). But reading the wiki once again, I'm a little in doubt. The wiki mentions that this is a rounda