Re: [Tagging] landuse=reservoir vs water=reservoir

2019-06-12 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
sent from a phone > On 12. Jun 2019, at 01:51, Warin <61sundow...@gmail.com> wrote: > > Other features in the key natural are either land covers or land forms and > could be split into those 2 keys. that’s not completely accurate, there are also point features, e.g. natural=spring,

Re: [Tagging] landuse=reservoir vs water=reservoir

2019-06-11 Thread Warin
On 11/06/19 19:30, marc marc wrote: Le 11.06.19 à 11:14, Tomas Straupis a écrit : What do you think? I find very strange that reservoir is a landuse by itself it would be a bit like putting landuse=rest on a bench or landuse=stop on a parking lot. landuse should be what the place is for.

Re: [Tagging] landuse=reservoir vs water=reservoir

2019-06-11 Thread Warin
On 11/06/19 19:30, marc marc wrote: Le 11.06.19 à 11:14, Tomas Straupis a écrit : What do you think? I find very strange that reservoir is a landuse by itself it would be a bit like putting landuse=rest on a bench or landuse=stop on a parking lot. landuse should be what the place is for.

Re: [Tagging] landuse=reservoir vs water=reservoir

2019-06-11 Thread Peter Elderson
I agree with Marcin preference for natural=water, water=reservoir, because it keeps landuse open for the actual use of the land that contains a reservoir. I dislike landuse-within-landuse. But I agree with Tomas that this preference does not make it a "better" option, and the wiki should not state

Re: [Tagging] landuse=reservoir vs water=reservoir

2019-06-11 Thread Tomas Straupis
> I find very strange that reservoir is a landuse by itself > it would be a bit like putting landuse=rest on a bench > or landuse=stop on a parking lot. > <...> There are a infinite number of arguments on both sides. Pandora box was already opened and dual standard for water tagging already

Re: [Tagging] landuse=reservoir vs water=reservoir

2019-06-11 Thread marc marc
Le 11.06.19 à 11:14, Tomas Straupis a écrit : >What do you think? I find very strange that reservoir is a landuse by itself it would be a bit like putting landuse=rest on a bench or landuse=stop on a parking lot. landuse should be what the place is for. reservoir is the function of the