Re: [Talk-transit] [OSM-talk] Automated Populate/Update Problem

2023-01-28 Thread Andrew Harvey
Yep you'll reach Victorian and Australian mappers better on talk-au as some might not join the global talk list -> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au. I'll echo other's comments here, if you are planning or have done the conflation I'd suggest sharing those results so the community

Re: [Talk-transit] [OSM-talk] Automated Populate/Update Problem

2023-01-28 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
Welcome to osm! Regarding the "remove existing as final step": we generally expect people to conflate new data with existing data, so you should not remove the existing ones, but enrich them (including position acuracy if possible) with your data, and only create new objects for things that

Re: [Talk-transit] [OSM-talk] Automated Populate/Update Problem

2023-01-28 Thread Eugene Alvin Villar
Hi, I work for the state transport department > Sorry if I missed this somewhere, but which state and which country? Depending on the answer, there might be a local community that can help and provide guidance as well with the conflation/import process. Thanks, Eugene On Wed, Sep 28, 2022 at

Re: [Talk-transit] [OSM-talk] Automated Populate/Update Problem

2023-01-28 Thread Phil Wyatt
Hi Rob,Given you are in Australia I would try the talk AU list as well. Maybe also the discord channels as there are a few Ozzie folks there in the Oceania channel with lots of transport experience. Cheers - Phil(On the phone so apologies for any typos)On 28 Sep 2022, at 6:36 pm, rob potter

Re: [OSM-talk] Automated Populate/Update Problem

2022-09-29 Thread Warin
G'day, Yes to contacting the Ozies on au-talk. In general I'd be careful on changing the 'old' data as some of it maybe better than the departments data, needs a judgement call. I'd think adding to it is fine - reference numbers that are missing, that kind of thing. Adding new stops should

Re: [OSM-talk] Automated Populate/Update Problem

2022-09-28 Thread Andrew Harvey
Yep you'll reach Victorian and Australian mappers better on talk-au as some might not join the global talk list -> https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/talk-au. I'll echo other's comments here, if you are planning or have done the conflation I'd suggest sharing those results so the community

Re: [OSM-talk] Automated Populate/Update Problem

2022-09-28 Thread Phil Wyatt
Hi Rob,Given you are in Australia I would try the talk AU list as well. Maybe also the discord channels as there are a few Ozzie folks there in the Oceania channel with lots of transport experience. Cheers - Phil(On the phone so apologies for any typos)On 28 Sep 2022, at 6:36 pm, rob potter

Re: [OSM-talk] Automated Populate/Update Problem

2022-09-28 Thread rob potter
Thanks for your reply. I have read the guidelines. I'm in Victoria, Australia Rob On Wed, 28 Sept 2022, 18:07 Eugene Alvin Villar, wrote: > Hi, > > I work for the state transport department >> > > Sorry if I missed this somewhere, but which state and which country? > Depending on the answer,

Re: [OSM-talk] Automated Populate/Update Problem

2022-09-28 Thread Eugene Alvin Villar
Hi, I work for the state transport department > Sorry if I missed this somewhere, but which state and which country? Depending on the answer, there might be a local community that can help and provide guidance as well with the conflation/import process. Thanks, Eugene On Wed, Sep 28, 2022 at

Re: [OSM-talk] Automated Populate/Update Problem

2022-09-28 Thread Marc_marc
Hello, Le 28.09.22 à 09:18, rob potter a écrit : My initial thought was extract current, match data location, enrich what stops.txt has then create all new and remove existing as final step. no :) keep the historic, no need to delete-create again. a better workflow : extract current match

Re: [OSM-talk] Automated Populate/Update Problem

2022-09-28 Thread Martin Koppenhoefer
Welcome to osm! Regarding the "remove existing as final step": we generally expect people to conflate new data with existing data, so you should not remove the existing ones, but enrich them (including position acuracy if possible) with your data, and only create new objects for things that

[OSM-talk] Automated Populate/Update Problem

2022-09-28 Thread rob potter
Hi, I work for the state transport department and we are looking to become an active member of the community and as a first dataset we have focused on is our public transport stops, bus and tram initially and then stations. I would like your advice on how to achieve the outcome. There are a